Murder, rape and shattered families: 1947 Partition Archive effort underway

[indianBong]

 

[Ind4Ever]

Modern day Pak was never part of Hindustan .. It was always a clear majority muslim territory .. The "frontier provinces" of the British empire.



The muslims supported Muslim League .. than there was a segment lead by the likes of Maulana "Azad" who were against the creation of Pak and were pro india... but they never had any influence in modern day Pak.. That is why they couldn't win any seat from this region (despite support from congress).


We don't want Kashmir (kashmir along with other muslim majority areas was already destined to be a part of Pakistan according to the partition formula).

Even in 47 .. Ghulab singh used genocode to try to stop the struggling KAshmiris who wanted to merge with Pak .. The genocode is well documented by neutral sources but I doubt you will accept them.

I don't think Pakistan which was India was birth place of Islam but part of Hindu Kingdom . And India's History don't starts with 1947 or 1000 years before that but it's very long than you can imagine . SO HOW COME PAKISTAN IS NOT PART OF HINDUSTAN ? Ur British history is not a valid .

And we don't need Pakistan either but Kashmir is our share. When the Kashmir Kingdom made a pact to join India who are Muslims residing in Kashmir to have any say ? That's not their mother land too. And for your kind information even Afghanistan , Pakistan , Bangladesh Sri Lanka was part of Hindu Kingdom .

So I don't know how you came to conclusions that Pakistan is the birth place of Muslims . Which is not .

 

[doppelganger]

Damn,Damn,you demolished him.Nice post ,Desert,very impressed.

By being a pompom boy for Desert, you have just contributed to the demise of your own thread. Nice going.

 

[doppelganger]

Damn,Damn,you demolished him.Nice post ,Desert,very impressed.

By being a pompom boy for Desert, you have just contributed to the demise of your own thread. Nice going.

Modern day Pak was never part of Hindustan .. It was always a clear majority muslim territory .. The "frontier provinces" of the British empire.

Nonsense. Since when did Muslim Majority Area = Not Hindustan ?

The frontier provinces were not Hindustan. Nor were they Pakistan. They were Afghanistan and Iran respectively. And arguably still are.

Punjab and Sindh and East Bengal were always Hindustan.

A troll got what he deserved.He was derailing the thread.

So are you and Desert.

 

[Ind4Ever]

No point in opening this thread.

Hindus will say, they were killed & oppressed.

Muslim will say, they were killed & oppressed.

Sikhs will say, they were killed & oppressed.

Ohhhh nice ... So how many Hindus are left in Pakistan .. In percentage ?
Today there are more than 300 million Muslims in India out of 1.2 billion Indians . I have gear stories from my grandmother . She said when Hindus been chased out of Pakistan and Bangladesh in India the hindus stood for the muslims of South India . They lived with peace and harmony . It was hindus who wanted to save muslims and helped with their lively hood. Don't say back about Hindus . We are at most peaceful and friendly people in the face of the earth and fry patriotic too.

 

[Sugarcane]

My father in law aged 10 at that time was lone survivor among all family members.

 

[Soumitra]

 

[indianBong]

Modern day Pak was never part of Hindustan .. It was always a clear majority muslim territory .. The "frontier provinces" of the British empire.



The muslims supported Muslim League .. than there was a segment lead by the likes of Maulana "Azad" who were against the creation of Pak and were pro india... but they never had any influence in modern day Pak.. That is why they couldn't win any seat from this region (despite support from congress).


We don't want Kashmir (kashmir along with other muslim majority areas was already destined to be a part of Pakistan according to the partition formula).

Even in 47 .. Ghulab singh used genocode to try to stop the struggling KAshmiris who wanted to merge with Pak .. The genocode is well documented by neutral sources but I doubt you will accept them.

very stupid logic...Y cant a muslim majority part be a part of india?? . if muslim league and congress would hav agreed to share govt without partition that day you wouldnt have said that sentence today.... who creates a map???? who creates boundaries.... its the mentality that makes borders....tomorow pak or india or usa may break into two.... some separatist will justify that with logic too....

 

[xTra]

Ohhhh nice ... So how many Hindus are left in Pakistan .. In percentage ?
Today there are more than 300 million Muslims in India out of 1.2 billion Indians . I have gear stories from my grandmother . She said when Hindus been chased out of Pakistan and Bangladesh in India the hindus stood for the muslims of South India . They lived with peace and harmony . It was hindus who wanted to save muslims and helped with their lively hood. Don't say back about Hindus . We are at most peaceful and friendly people in the face of the earth and fry patriotic too.

So Hindus never killed anyone.

 

[Ind4Ever]

A troll got what he deserved.He was derailing the thread.

Derail of what ? You posted this old crap when gave my views so it became troll ? Exactly you are doing everything to be a troll. Like posting something which has nothing to debate . Challl

 

[doppelganger]

I wonder what survivors of that time would say if they knew about PDF.

Sadly both sets of my grandparents are no more.

 

[Ind4Ever]

So Hindus never killed anyone.

See its not who killed how much ... Every one will stand to protect their kids and families. It won't make them a rogue but brave hearts. Same different between Terrorist's and Army .

 

[xTra]

See its not who killed how much ... Every one will stand to protect their kids and families. It won't make them a rogue but brave hearts. Same different between Terrorist's and Army .

We are not talking about Army/Terrorist, we are talking about 1947 partition.

Hindu, Muslims & Sikhs all have blood of each other in their hand.

 

[suresh1773]

Modern day Pak was never part of Hindustan .. It was always a clear majority muslim territory .. The "frontier provinces" of the British empire.
The muslims supported Muslim League .. than there was a segment lead by the likes of Maulana "Azad" who were against the creation of Pak and were pro india... but they never had any influence in modern day Pak.. That is why they couldn't win any seat from this region (despite support from congress).


We don't want Kashmir (kashmir along with other muslim majority areas was already destined to be a part of Pakistan according to the partition formula).

Even in 47 .. Ghulab singh used genocode to try to stop the struggling KAshmiris who wanted to merge with Pak .. The genocode is well documented by neutral sources but I doubt you will accept them.

What about the genocide by Tribal raiders from NFWP in Kashmir which is also well documented but u will not accept that version.

Why was Mr Jinnah more interested in Hyderbad & Junagadh though both had more 90% Hindu population.

Why did Liaqaut Ali Khan refused to exchange Kashmir with Hyderabd & Junagadh

you have hit the nerves.... heard a lot of painful stories from my grandparents when they had to leave Dhaka and Noakhali.....

Well Bong,Dhaka had more then 80% Hindu population, I have read it somewhere

 

[indianBong]

In 1947, Beaumont was private secretary to the senior British judge, Sir Cyril Radcliffe, who was chairman of the Indo-Pakistan Boundary Commission.
Radcliffe was responsible for dividing the vast territories of British India into India and Pakistan , separating 400 million people along religious lines.
The family documents show that Beaumont had a stark assessment of the role played by Britain in the last days of the Raj.
"The viceroy, Mountbatten, must take the blame - though not the sole blame - for the massacres in the Punjab in which between 500,000 to a million men, women and children perished," he writes.
"The handover of power was done too quickly."

But Beaumont - who later in life was a circuit judge in the U.K. - is most scathing about how partition affected the Punjab, which was split between India and Pakistan.
"The British government and Mountbatten must bear a large part of the blame for this tragedy.

Gallimaufry: Christopher Beaumont 1947 and the horror stories of India's brutal partition into pakistan and india-FROM INTERNET
read this article....