LfcRed
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2014
- Messages
- 185
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
This issue has made the mentalities and ignorance of our majority and religious scholars quite apparent. Unfortunately there isn't one religious scholar I could name who can take Pakistan forward or lead the people. After seeing the scholars one over the other made clips to support what Mumtaz Qadri did will further encourage lawlessness and movements against the muslim state and government. We have never seen anyone of these people make a video to discourage taliban or their actions. Unfortunately these so called Muslim scholars are the very reason violent movements against the government and the people are taking place in our country and the sole reason that these mufsideen don't feel remorse for their actions is they are never denounced by the scholars. This sense of taking up arms against the mushrik government and the people is endorsed by these groups apparently not by India or Saudia or Iran. This is home grown venom.
Secondly the issue of Salman Taseer. Let me make it clear I did not like Salman Taseer but that doesn't mean I was in favor of how we was murdered. He was too liberal and secular and I did not agree with majority of his ideas for the country. But he was not entirely wrong about the law of tauheen e risalat. To start one thing to understand is this law is man made and isn't taken from Qur'an nor Sunnah. This is something that has been decided by our people. So calling the law a black law does not constitute blasphemy. Secondly this law has been misused most of the time than being used productively either to settle personal enmities or get the minority killed lawfully.
The implementation of this law is another dilemma. I was reading a news once where a non muslim was prosecuted because he said that Muhammad is not the messenger of Allah (God Forbid). But that is something very logical to hear from a non muslim. If he/she believes that Muhammad (S.A.W) was the prophet that would obviously make him a muslim. Another distinguishing factor we need to make is what constitutes insult or mockery of the prophet and what is counter questioning his actions to find answers to Islam. If the live debates that happens between different religions is held in Pakistan, all the questioners will be prosecuted. Here we are dealing with the status of the prophet and no one loved him more than his companions. He has suffered with more than what bad is said about him now in his lifetime. He never ordered to kill anyone because of that. Allah did not order anyone to be killed because of that. Who loves the prophet more than Allah? We should be lenient if someone who has committed any such act willingly or not and seeks pardon for the first time. This can also help us the show the mercy in Islam and bring them closer to the religion. If he is adamant on what he did or repeats then should be punished with whatever the law dictates.
What Mumtaz Qadri did is a shame for a muslim and Islam stipulates a punishment for that. May Allah forgive him and grant him jannah as he has paid for what he did in his lifetime. These are the people who will be dragged towards jannah on the day of judgement given there other deeds are good. Islam doesn't allow anyone to be the judge and jury. No one has the right to punish anyone based on his own intellect. The government is responsible for that after proper investigation and even if the government doesn't we will not be questioned. What Mumtaz Qadri did under the influence of our so called scholars who claimed for him the right to be killed should be ashamed because if their ignorant guidance and actions of the Mumtaz Qadri we have probably lost a good citizen. There is nothing wrong in punishing if a righteous man commits zina and the same applies here no matter how good Mumtaz Qadri was he should be punished for murder. Whoever claims otherwise does not have a clue about the religion.
Secondly the issue of Salman Taseer. Let me make it clear I did not like Salman Taseer but that doesn't mean I was in favor of how we was murdered. He was too liberal and secular and I did not agree with majority of his ideas for the country. But he was not entirely wrong about the law of tauheen e risalat. To start one thing to understand is this law is man made and isn't taken from Qur'an nor Sunnah. This is something that has been decided by our people. So calling the law a black law does not constitute blasphemy. Secondly this law has been misused most of the time than being used productively either to settle personal enmities or get the minority killed lawfully.
The implementation of this law is another dilemma. I was reading a news once where a non muslim was prosecuted because he said that Muhammad is not the messenger of Allah (God Forbid). But that is something very logical to hear from a non muslim. If he/she believes that Muhammad (S.A.W) was the prophet that would obviously make him a muslim. Another distinguishing factor we need to make is what constitutes insult or mockery of the prophet and what is counter questioning his actions to find answers to Islam. If the live debates that happens between different religions is held in Pakistan, all the questioners will be prosecuted. Here we are dealing with the status of the prophet and no one loved him more than his companions. He has suffered with more than what bad is said about him now in his lifetime. He never ordered to kill anyone because of that. Allah did not order anyone to be killed because of that. Who loves the prophet more than Allah? We should be lenient if someone who has committed any such act willingly or not and seeks pardon for the first time. This can also help us the show the mercy in Islam and bring them closer to the religion. If he is adamant on what he did or repeats then should be punished with whatever the law dictates.
What Mumtaz Qadri did is a shame for a muslim and Islam stipulates a punishment for that. May Allah forgive him and grant him jannah as he has paid for what he did in his lifetime. These are the people who will be dragged towards jannah on the day of judgement given there other deeds are good. Islam doesn't allow anyone to be the judge and jury. No one has the right to punish anyone based on his own intellect. The government is responsible for that after proper investigation and even if the government doesn't we will not be questioned. What Mumtaz Qadri did under the influence of our so called scholars who claimed for him the right to be killed should be ashamed because if their ignorant guidance and actions of the Mumtaz Qadri we have probably lost a good citizen. There is nothing wrong in punishing if a righteous man commits zina and the same applies here no matter how good Mumtaz Qadri was he should be punished for murder. Whoever claims otherwise does not have a clue about the religion.
