MMRCA ....what's your choice????

[MAFIAN GOD]

you cant rule out SH. seeing the way the things have changed recently...instead two I would count all three EF,rafale and F18 on the same page.

But this is mrca competition.
SH is better in a2g.We should only consider it if we want to replace Mig-27.

 

[sancho]

When is it expected.

Anyway a new poll is a refreshing thing..

Its good to talk on defense in a defense forum .. we have seen enough of everything else here..

The problem is, that we keep discussing about the same things in several different threads, which makes it confusing. Would be better to keep discussions in the dedicated thread, don't you think?

 

[shineonyoucrazydiamond]

Paul octopus came in my dream and he said F 22 raptor will win the MRCA...

 

[Mirza Jatt]

But this is mrca competition.
SH is better in a2g.We should only consider it if we want to replace Mig-27.

No..thats wrong to say..f/a 18 SH is much advanced multi role fighter than the older f18 hornet...and moreover keeping in mind the requirements by IAF, it features all the multirole features...and thats the reason why it has cleared the tests.

 

[SpArK]

The problem is, that we keep discussing about the same things in several different threads, which makes it confusing. Would be better to keep discussions in the dedicated thread, don't you think?

Dude.. there is nothing new to discuss apart from what u guys have already debated in that thread.. Only occasional speculations comes every now and then of possible winners in various medias.. A new poll is indeed refreshing.. Its good to reinvent the "defense talk" back in this forum..

Just imagine this thread as an effort to bring people back on discussing real defense related matters instead of highly volatile heated discussions we see every day here on the same topics..

And dont forget to click that damn rafale button on the polls.. or else i will haunt you forever.

 

[Ammyy]

The problem is, that we keep discussing about the same things in several different threads, which makes it confusing. Would be better to keep discussions in the dedicated thread, don't you think?

There is no thread which allow us to poll

I am also dnt want to feed troll ...just want to know opinion of Indian friends ...

 

[shineonyoucrazydiamond]

Who all cleared the test and who all are already out of the race?

can we get 126 EF in 11 BUSD?

 

[MAFIAN GOD]

No..thats wrong to say..f/a 18 SH is much advanced multi role fighter than the older f18 hornet...and moreover keeping in mind the requirements by IAF, it features all the multirole features...and thats the reason why it has cleared the tests.

SIR ji,the best 'requirement fulfiller' for IAF is RAFALE i guess and EF.
This is beacuse SH can only carry A2G weapon load greater than those two and RAFALE and EF are better in A2A than SH.
GO through MRCA thread.

 

[shineonyoucrazydiamond]

Many new members here... New thread is a good Idea to involve them in discussion, we can also learn something and irritate our keyboard for once at least..

 

[SpArK]

oops... i forgot to add. Rafale is the only fighter among these which can carry a nuclear bomb/missile.

 

[Vajra_Yuddh]

You know if any of us few were there in MRCA selection board, I think by now we would have got all the 200 fighters in including additional orders . Wonder what the babus are doing....

 

[MAFIAN GOD]

Thinking of starting RAFALE FANATIC CLUB in

Hey BENNY and SANCHO wanna join?

 

[rockstarIN]

I saw benny's points abt |Rafele

Will anybidy add the same way abt EF?

 

[Mirza Jatt]

SIR ji,the best 'requirement fulfiller' for IAF is RAFALE i guess and EF.
This is beacuse SH can only carry A2G weapon load greater than those two and RAFALE and EF are better in A2A than SH.
GO through MRCA thread.

well, its not about requirement fulfiller only..if you see my previous post, I have clearly mentioned my choice isonly EF...but seeing the currnt intense lobbying...SH is very much in the same league as EF and rafale..apart from that its a great fighter..no less than EF or rafale.

anways to the bolded part...SH is a an advance fighter aircraft ..it has both A2A and A2G weapon load.

 

[SpArK]

I saw benny's points abt |Rafele

Will anybidy add the same way abt EF?

Yeah.. Just reverse what all i have said..

And most importantly. instead of 1 partner we get 4 partners... kewl naa.. 4 > 1