The first claims were the marriage was arranged, then the girl claimed in court that, she met him through matrimonial.
It should have been totally a
Non Issue for the court if it was an arranged marriage or the love marriage. When the girl herself witnessed in the court that it was not a forced marriage, then such issues have absolutely no value.
Also, she did something stupid by ,marrying that guy while under the guardianship of the HC without the knowledge of HC. She could've reported it to the court. This all made the situation bad for her.
No, she was not under the supervision or guardianship of Hight Court at the time of marriage. She married earlier, after which his father filed a case against the boy, and only then the case went to the high court. And high court didn't practised it's guardianship upon her, but simply sent her to her's parent and she is not allowed to leave the apartment, and she is also not allowed to meet the people according to her own will (it is like a prison for her, where her freedom has been usurped).
Another stupidity happened which might have angered the court is especially supreme court, the SDPI where the guy is a member, went on to make a procession in front of HC by calling out the Christian and Hindu jidge by names and kind of verbally abusing them.
All this made SC to order NIA investigation.
This is against the Spirit of Justice if the court (especially high court and even the Supreme court) let them influenced from such external events. You cannot punish a girl for such external events.
If they have really let that happened, then I am afraid that high court and supreme court have to pay the price.
The better way of handling it, was to summon the protesters and filing a case against them for insulting the judiciary.
And to be honest, I don't thing these external events played any significant role, but main issue is this that Hindu Extremists were for long trying to give life to their Love Jihad conspiracy, and the high court and the supreme court only played in their hands to give life to this drama.
And this is the main cause of concern. Judiciary should be above all this and out of reach of any politics or religion. If Indian judiciary will also play wrong, then even the Normal Muslims are going to join the ranks of the extremist Islamists in big number. This is a win win situation for the Muslim Extremists.