Kannada Scholar MM Kalburgi Shot Dead; Police Suspect Role of Hindutva Outfits

[dravidianhero]

1. Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was from quraish tribe so please do not come up your half-baked stories

2. The Prophet was from the same tribe and he was immensely honest so they know about his good character

3. His opponents that is quraish tribe majority of were NOT at all tolerant. They prosecuted everyone who followed Muhammad (PBUH), and expelled them from their land for many years.

4. This thread is about killing of a man in India alledgly by Hindu extremists for saying things against hindu gods, and not about Pakistan, Islam or Muhammad (PBUH), so better stick to topic and do not try to hide your own faults.



if you are not ok with abusive language then be honest do not come up with selective opinion. nobody here is advocating killing at all but only those hindu extremists who were firing crackers over killing of this man

I know about Muhammad and his character better than you..I only brought him into the debate as he was also against idol worship just like the person that was murdered...let us not get into who prosecuted whom and who indulged in unethical plundering and killing of caravans and who broke treaties and who killed hundreds of jews and who raped tens of girls who were taken as war spoils...leave it.

 

[Spring Onion]

I know about Muhammad and his character better than you..I only brought him into the debate as he was also against idol worship just like the person that was murdered...let us not get into who prosecuted whom and who indulged in unethical plundering and killing of caravans and who broke treaties and who killed hundreds of jews and who raped tens of girls who were taken as war spoils...leave it.

the only unethical character here in this thread is you and let us also not talk about tense of hundreds of girls being rapped as temple dasis

 

[dravidianhero]

the only unethical character here in this thread is you and let us also not talk about tense of hundreds of girls being rapped as temple dasis

Done...leave it

 

[Samudra Manthan]

Whats the difference between the bloggers killed in Bangladesh and now the trend is starting in India.
This is real bad.

And I find it shocking enough Indian posters not condemning the violence. This is a worrying trend.

Do not rationalists and liberals say we are all the same. How all religions are the same. How all countries are the same. So why surprised when same behavior is displayed. People are just making true the liberal's claims.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

there is no difference between promotion of hate speech and hate and getting killed anywhere

Any dog can bark. But getting killed for hate speech is beyond me.

 

[Spring Onion]

Any dog can bark. But getting killed for hate speech is beyond me.

it is result of two intolerant groups in other words in my opinion both are examples of two extremes.

 

[crimemaster_gogo]

R.I.P

Saddening incident.

 

[Spring Onion]

R.I.P

Saddening incident.

banned members can post?????????????

 

[crimemaster_gogo]

banned members can post?????????????

Only CRIMEmaster gogo can.

 

[Makaramarma]

Any dog can bark. But getting killed for hate speech is beyond me.

People have been killed for much less........ all over the world.

BTW where is the evidence he was killed for hate speech ? ..... or did you just pull that out of your @ss ?

 

[Mike_Brando]

Many of us Lucknowis want freedom from India. We realize it is home to only sick minded hindu radicals who run the place. Muslims are slowly but surely realizing that they are not wanted in this "Ïndia" and thus reclaiming their original identity. i want my Lucknow merged with Pakistan

Mr.Sultan,for Heaven's sake,stop pretending to be an Indian coz you aren't one in reality.You and your entire family ceased to be Indian citizens the day you decided to leave this country for Pakistan and accepting it's citizenship automatically make your Indian citizenship invalid as stated in Art.-9 of the Indian Constitution.So for the sake of Jesus criticize India and Indians as much as you want but stop claiming something which you are not in reality(Now you can give me as many negative ratings as you want but you know in your heart that i have spoken the truth)!!

 

[jamahir]

Scholar killed by hardcore extremist Hindus for distasteful remarks against Hindu gods.

not at all distasteful.

what he did was question the concept of idolatry and also the superstitions that undeniably form a big part of hindu culture, whether or not from beginning.

another thing is that sanghi organizations find support from a large population in karnataka state... one must remember the "ram sena" group which in 2009 gained notoriety by attacking ladies in a disco in mangalore city and has been since doing "moral policing" in that state.

it is sad that sanghi terrorism is being allowed to continue... the maoist guerrillas are being hunted down in the jungles of india and many innocent muslims are being jailed but sanghi terrorism continues... sad.

reactionaries from every religion should be punished.

 

[Parul]

Rest in peace to dead! Sickular forces at work.

 

[coffee_cup]

The big quetion is:

Will India punish these extremists or will the police and prosecutors go "soft" on them as instructed by the extremist leadership sitting in the govt?

Latter seems to be the most probable outcome.

 

[jamahir]

Rest in peace to dead! Sickular forces at work.

who do you mean??