Japan troops won’t get involved if China invades Taiwan, PM Yoshihide Suga says

[bshifter]

Again, why do Chinese PDF posters think only China will be the one doing the firing?

If USA and Japan join in, 100,000s of thousands of Chinese families bloodlines will cease to exist when the old die due to single male child. Taiwan fighting alone some 10,000s of Chinese will suffer the same fate.

This is not a video game as some think.

You have a lot of time writing BS regarding Taiwan all the time. Got nothing else to do? You are a silly person. Go to Taiwan and defend with your own life instead of faking your bravery. You are not righteous or brave, you are just silly

 

[925boy]

Peaceful unification is not agaisnt Japan's policy. Only a forceful is.

can u explain how thats Japan's business? i'm really curious..you guys also have savior cop complex like US?

Taiwan is not part of PRC's sovereignty.

- Japan and US opinion

Taiwan is part of PRC's sovereignty.

- China opinion.

I saw a pic showing ALL of Japan's naval vessels, wow , it was so impressive, but it seems you guys have the fatal problem US has now - you are afraid to die so you wont fight most people that can kill you. WIth such a huge navy and this comment, Japan has basically left US alone to fighting China...when CHina entered Senkakus with fleet of vessels Japanese vessels always stay away.. you guys are currently afraid to lose your entire economy from getting beat up from a country you used to humiliate. smh. you will see surprises soon. screenshot that.

 

[FairAndUnbiased]

Again, why do Chinese PDF posters think only China will be the one doing the firing?

If USA and Japan join in, 100,000s of thousands of Chinese families bloodlines will cease to exist when the old die due to single male child. Taiwan fighting alone some 10,000s of Chinese will suffer the same fate.

This is not a video game as some think.

How do Taiwanese fighting alone kill 10,000s of Chinese when they're being bombed with incendiaries and cluster munitions from 5000+ meters?

If any foreign enemies join in, they should be prepared for their navy to be regarded in historical terms only and for decades worth of hardware buildup to be sitting on the bottom of the ocean.

 

[zhxy]

because the Japanese govt wont be able to give good reasons to the Japanese people as to why Japan entered that war. the govt will look stupid and like a traitor.

If Japan had equal and greater military power than China, it would certainly seek to defend Taiwan and weaken China. But Japan's military-economic prowess is currently not as good as China's, so they will find a worthy excuse - that their constitution does not allow them to do so.

 

[925boy]

If Japan had equal and greater military power than China, it would certainly seek to defend Taiwan and weaken China. But Japan's military-economic prowess is currently not as good as China's, so they will find a worthy excuse - that their constitution does not allow them to do so.

LOL.....i think you're right. If you take a look at their naval ships....you will be amazed..the Izumo, etc..they have ALOT of good advanced equipment, but for whatever reasons, they're morale to take on China now is clearly low...i think they're also worried about being seen as Nazi Japan, which is their sad history for allying with Hitler...so they probably dont want that reputation again..smh.

 

[UKBengali]

You have a lot of time writing BS regarding Taiwan all the time. Got nothing else to do? You are a silly person. Go to Taiwan and defend with your own life instead of faking your bravery. You are not righteous or brave, you are just silly

Why don't you stick to the facts rather than getting personal as the cold,hard truth clearly agitated you.

China is not in a position to risk the ending of the bloodlines of 100,000s of thousands of Chinese due to its one-child policy over Taiwan. CCP cares about its survival and will not jeopardize that.

I am not the one beating the drums of war but clearly immature Chinese PDF posters.

Now only reply if you can stick with the actual points.

 

[bshifter]

Why don't you stick to the facts rather than getting personal as the cold,hard truth clearly agitated you.

China is not in a position to risk the ending of the bloodlines of 100,000s of thousands of Chinese due to its one-child policy over Taiwan. CPC cares about its survival and will not jeopardize that.

I am not the one beating the drums of war but clearly immature Chinese PDF posters.

Now only reply if you can stick with the actual points.

Why would i feel agitated by a silly person? You keep repeating BS and i call you out being a silly. You want to talk about facts? I gave it to you already Chinese leadership has already revealed it will reunite with Taiwan. But what do you do? keep talking about Japan and US will rescue Taiwan, talking as if China dare not use nukes. These are not facts as you have already said you only voice your opinion. Do not mistake your silly opinion with facts coming directly from Beijing.

 

[Whizzack]

You think just becos you fired the first nuke and we cant nuke US back? Try nuke a underground bunker 200m deep.

Not to mention SSBN on patrol. Once they received news of China being nuke. You will get it...

I didn't say that China won't retaliate after being nuked, China certainly will... however the possibility that a nuclear exchange begins with a Chinese first (nuclear) strike is lower than the possibility that it begins with a US first strike... This is because China had a "No nuclear first" policy, while the US does not... Basically this means that as long as the opponent does not use / have nuclear weapons, China will not use nuclear weapons first.. This is different to the US that has stated that they may retaliate with nuclear weapons even if the opponent doesn't use / have nuclear weapons, if they consider the attack against them or their allies is significant enough...

 

[UKBengali]

Why would i feel agitated by a silly person? You keep repeating BS and i call you out being a silly. You want to talk about facts? I gave it to you already Chinese leadership has already revealed it will reunite with Taiwan. But what do you do? keep talking about Japan and US will rescue Taiwan, talking as if China dare not use nukes. These are not facts as you have already said you only voice your opinion. Do not mistake your silly opinion with facts coming directly from Beijing.

You are agitated as you are getting personal. Please calm down as this is only a forum dude.

Anyway no need to waste any more time with you as you are not here to be constructive but to beat a false nationalistic drum and get emotional.

 

[bshifter]

You are agitated as you are getting personal. Please calm down as this is only a forum dude.

Anyway no need to waste any more time with you as you are not here to be constructive but to beat a false nationalistic drum and get emotional.

Mister, you have issues here. I do not get personal with anyone here i only express opinion and facts and jokes, there is no reason to get emotional with Indians, Americans, Viets or any other race. You fail to see how obsessed you are about Taiwan, look at yourself. You are not Chinese, not a citizen of Taiwan and yet you keep constantly talk about it. If this is not some unhealthy obsession i don't know what is.

 

[Han Patriot]

The article doesn't mention the 2014 reinterpretation of the constitution that resulted in new defense laws which include "collective self-defense".

Both Japan and Taiwan want good relations with China but China is not correct in seeing unification with Taiwan as a correct path.

'reinterpretation' depends on interpretation, now this current administration has got another interpretation. Don't argue with me mate, argue with that article. The PM already said they won't they involved. And we know why. Why should Japan get annihilated for a Chinese island? It doesn't matter if Japan likes Taiwan, the KMT which represents the military killed Japanese during the war. So?

Just accept reality mate, he just said Japan won't and it means just that, no matter hw much yindoo twisting. Lol

 

[Suika]

'reinterpretation' depends on interpretation, now this current administration has got another interpretation. Don't argue with me mate, argue with that article. The PM already said they won't they involved. And we know why. Why should Japan get annihilated for a Chinese island? It doesn't matter if Japan likes Taiwan, the KMT which represents the military killed Japanese during the war. So?

Just accept reality mate, he just said Japan won't and it means just that, no matter hw much yindoo twisting. Lol

New defense laws were passed and put into effect on the basis of the reinterpretation. Those new laws can't be undone without some new bills to undo them.

PRC is not entitled to controlling the island. From the strategic posture, it forms the mid link in the first island chain. If the PRC had that, then that would give the PRC military much better ability to operate in the open Pacific which is Japan's underside. Japan depends much more on the sea since it is an island country while the PRC has land routes. If Taiwan wanted to join the PRC willfully, then Japan's strategic posture doesn't matter. But since Taiwan doesn't want to be part of the PRC, then Japan is in the right to help Taiwan with the additional benefit of securing open ocean security. Because of the claim on the Senkaku islands, 9 dash line, and claim on Taiwan.. PRC attitude presents itself as something that cannot be trusted.

And he said "pressuppose". You guys really hang your conclusions on these SMCP articles too much.

 

[Han Patriot]

New defense laws were passed and put into effect on the basis of the reinterpretation. Those new laws can't be undone without some new bills to undo them.

PRC is not entitled to controlling the island. From the strategic posture, it forms the mid link in the first island chain. If the PRC had that, then that would give the PRC military much better ability to operate in the open Pacific which is Japan's underside. Japan depends much more on the sea since it is an island country while the PRC has land routes. If Taiwan wanted to join the PRC willfully, then Japan's strategic posture doesn't matter. But since Taiwan doesn't want to be part of the PRC, then Japan is in the right to help Taiwan with the additional benefit of securing open ocean security. Because of the claim on the Senkaku islands, 9 dash line, and claim on Taiwan.. PRC attitude presents itself as something that cannot be trusted.

And he said "pressuppose". You guys really hang your conclusions on these SMCP articles too much.

Don't do a yindoo speak on me man, lol. What do you mean reinterpretation needs new laws, the friggin thing is enshrined in the constitution. Interpretation depends on the individual governments. And since when does a yindoo represent the Japanese government and interprets the law for them? The PM JUST FRIGGIN SAID HE WON'T FIGHT. WHAT PART OF IT YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND? Lol

Whether we are entitled to Taiwan, its a different matter, the UN and US recognizes 1 China and Taiwan is part of it. Whether PRC or ROC, it doesn't matter. There is only one China, even Japan recognizes it.

 

[War Thunder]

I highly anticipate Japan to be an aggresive power in the future. They are aggresive people who always want more land. Thats why throughout history they are always invading Korea and CHina has to come and save their little korean brothers. The moment Japan is unleashed from the US, Japan is going to try and take easy land from papua new guinea etc. Japan has just been neutered by the US but one day they will be released.

They "were" an aggressive people.
Now they are just mere slaves with shackles...

 

[j20blackdragon]

US like Rome is not sustainable in peace ,either US constantly remains at war or she perish.

Incidentally, the Plague of Justinian is estimated to have killed 25 to 60% of the population of the Late Roman Empire, essentially depopulating the “known world” at the time and accelerating the transition to a backward “Dark Age” period lasting nearly 1,000 years. It basically extinguished “antiquity” in Western Europe.