is pakistani and indian accent the same?

[Icewolf]

Why are Pakistanis crazy to copy Lucknowi Urdu.

Just like you are crazy to copy Indus River name..

 

[INDIC]

Just like you are crazy to copy Indus River name..

Indus is a shared river.

 

[RazPaK]

Lol Punjabis can't speak urdu, specially the village folks, pashtuns can't, neither baloch. To bacha kaun bhai?

All educated class from any ethnicity can speak very good Urdu. Can you honestly understand Iqbal's poetry?

More genuine?
More refined?
WTF?

Ajmal's english seems to be from the heart. Whereas Dhoni seems to have gotten some training somewhere along the line. This is just my opinion??

 

[INDIC]

Lol Punjabis can't speak urdu, specially the village folks, pashtuns can't, neither baloch. To bacha kaun bhai?

I have seen many Punjabis and Pashtuns could not pronounce Urdu accent properly like gh,jh etc.

 

[Roybot]

All educated class from any ethnicity can speak very good Urdu. Can you honestly understand Iqbal's poetry??

Thats the point. Educated people(who are familiar with words and how they are pronounced) will talk in a more "posh accent". Thats how it is all around the world and every language. So there is no Pakistanis speak better Urdu/Hindi than India.

Besides Pakistani Punjabis, even the educated ones speak urdu with a weird punjabified accent. Javed Chaudhary is a prime example.(he pronounces it as chooodhary)

Urdu in its pure form is only spoken in Uttar Pradesh and Delhi, rest all you guys are just wannabes

 

[RazPaK]

I have seen many Punjabis and Pashtuns could pronounce Urdu accent properly like gh,jh etc.

If you take your sample from street folk then that may be the perception.

In Pakistan, more people can speak Urdu in Karachi than anywhere else, however in Islamabad more people can speak proper Urdu than anywhere else. My father is Punjabi, however his Urdu is flawless. In fact, If he talked to us in proper Urdu we could only understand 70-80% of what he saying.

 

[Icewolf]

Indus is a shared river.

Indian Occupied Kashmir is not your territory kid

 

[Hindustani]

Indian Occupied Kashmir is not your territory kid

Maps say otherwise. Try to come and get it.. oh wait you've already tried that. Which in the process you've lost more than half your land along with Siachen

 

[Joe Shearer]

All your accent questions are answered in this (politically incorrect) TV show.

The Sardar speaks like a south Indian.

 

[Icewolf]

Thats the point. Educated people(who are familiar with words and how they are pronounced) will talk in a more posh accent. Thats how it is all around the world. So there is no Pakistanis speak better Urdu/Hindi than India.

Besides Pakistani Punjabis, even the educated ones speak urdu with a weird punjabified accent. Javed Chaudhary is a prime example.(he pronounces it as chooodhary)

Urdu in its pure form is only spoken in Uttar Pradesh and Delhi, rest all you guys are just wannabes

Uttar Pradesh and Delhi Urdu is not true Urdu.UP's and Delhittes mix up Hindi with Urdu. They think there is no Z sound in Urdu. Tell me who speaks more pure Urdu and who doesn't?

 

[RazPaK]

Thats the point. Educated people(who are familiar with words and how they are pronounced) will talk in a more posh accent. Thats how it is all around the world. So there is no Pakistanis speak better Urdu/Hindi than Indians.

Besides Pakistani Punjabis, even the educated ones speak urdu with a weird punjabified accent. Javed Chaudhary is a prime example.(he pronounces it as choodhary)

Urdu in its pure form is only spoken in Uttar Pradesh and Delhi, rest all you guys are just wannabes

I appreciate your nationalistic fervor, however your argument with even Punjabis is incorrect.
I being a Punjabi have a hard time understanding other Pakistani Punjabi's dialects.


To say some Punjabis in India and Pakistan may have the same accent due to dialect is acceptable, but to group Punjabis altogether and say they all have the same accent is absurd.

 

[Icewolf]

Maps say otherwise. Try to come and get it.. oh wait you've already tried that. Which in the process you've lost more than half your land along with Siachen

Siachen is still ours. And 1971 is not related to Kashmir son

 

[INDIC]

If you take your sample from street folk then that may be the perception.

In Pakistan, more people can speak Urdu in Karachi than anywhere else, however in Islamabad more people can speak proper Urdu than anywhere else. My father is Punjabi, however his Urdu is flawless. In fact, If he talked to us in proper Urdu we could only understand 70-80% of what he saying.

I saw many Pakistanis writing condensed form of Urdu words on this form, means condensing a word into a smaller form looking more similar to Punjabi.

 

[Roybot]

Uttar Pradesh and Delhi Urdu is not true Urdu.UP's and Delhittes mix up Hindi with Urdu. They think there is no Z sound in Urdu. Tell me who speaks more pure Urdu and who doesn't?

Again, people need to be familiar with the word, the words mispronounced are mainly persian in origin. Its like Anglophones mispronouncing the French loan words.

 

[INDIC]

Siachen is still ours. And 1971 is not related to Kashmir son

On papers.