is pakistani and indian accent the same?

[SHAMK9]

Watch media news from both sides and you will find out.

 

[RazPaK]

Ajmal's accent is more genuine, while Dhoni's is more refined, but people can still note the difference.

 

[Hulk]

not sure, but the indians outside when they speak english usually have the same generic accent.

That is where Pakistanis get it wrong. Indians living overseas mostly come from south, the north Indians are not that large in number. Some people take that ratio as ratio of population in the country. That is why some people like BATMAN think he is different than most Indians.

People overseas are mostly from AP, TN and Karnataka. The rest are in minority.

 

[harpoon]

That is where Pakistanis get it wrong. Indians living overseas mostly come from south, the north Indians are not that large in number. Some people take that ratio as ratio of population in the country. That is why some people like BATMAN think he is different than most Indians.

People overseas are mostly from AP, TN and Karnataka. The rest are in minority.

What about Gujuratis & Punjabis?

 

[Bhairava]

I agree. If you watch Indian CNN their journalists pronounce India as Ennndia.

Pakistani journalists will just say India.

Minor thing that I have noticed.

Just like how goras call Pakistan as Paeck-istaen while South Asians pronounce it properly as Paakistaan.

Actually if you look at how Obama and Hilary pronounce it, you will get the difference.

People overseas are mostly from AP, TN and Karnataka. The rest are in minority.

You forgot Gujjus and Punjabis...Infact I would order it as AP,Punjabis,Tamils, Gujjus and rest.

 

[Hulk]

What about Gujuratis & Punjabis?

Don't get into technicalities, I mean that ratio is not same.

 

[Developereo]

All your accent questions are answered in this (politically incorrect) TV show.

 

[Edevelop]

I agree. If you watch Indian CNN their journalists pronounce India as Ennndia.

Pakistani journalists will just say India.

Minor thing that I have noticed.

Kind of true

I actually hear some say Enndia or aindia with the punjabi accent... lol

 

[Shardul.....the lion]

I dont know about Indian and pakistani accent.

But I can see difference in accent easily between Punjabi or bengali or tamilian or bihari or malyali or maharastrian accents. So how Pakistani posters define Indian accent dont know? But

But I agree with them since Pakistan is placed in middle east much closer to arabs hence their accent is much more refined while so called Indian accent is more of desi subcontinental type accent. Funny enough.

 

[RazPaK]

I dont know about Indian and pakistani accent.

But I can see difference in accent easily between Punjabi or bengali or tamilian or bihari or malyali or maharastrian accents. So how Pakistani posters define Indian accent dont know? But

But I agree with them since Pakistan is placed in middle east much closer to arabs hence their accent is much more refined while so called Indian accent is more of desi subcontinental type accent. Funny enough.

Actually your example is inaccurate.


Just do a comparison of Pakistani urdu speakers and Indian urdu speakers. The accent difference can be pin pointed right from there.

I will tell you that Indians use the letter J instead of Z. Some Pakistanis, mostly the eldar folk from Punjab can sometimes do that to.

But generally, Indians using the letter J instead of Z makes them sound like jahil or ******(village folk).


That's how it is perceived.

 

[Roybot]

Actually your example is inaccurate.


Just do a comparison of Pakistani urdu speakers and Indian urdu speakers. The accent difference can be pin pointed right from there.

I will tell you that Indians use the letter J instead of Z. Some Pakistanis, mostly the eldar folk from Punjab can sometimes do that to.

But generally, Indians using the letter J instead of Z makes them sound like jahil or ******(village folk).


That's how it is perceived.

Majority of Pakistanis speak Urdu like this. No point denying it, its far from perfect.

 

[RazPaK]

Majority of Pakistanis speak Urdu like this. No point denying it, its far from perfect.

The majority of Bihari or muhjair people may speak like this. But the majority of Pakistani people?

 

[INDIC]

Actually your example is inaccurate.


Just do a comparison of Pakistani urdu speakers and Indian urdu speakers. The accent difference can be pin pointed right from there.

Why are Pakistanis crazy to copy Lucknowi Urdu.

 

[Roybot]

The majority of Bihari or muhjair people may speak like this. But the majority of Pakistani people?

Lol Punjabis can't speak urdu, specially the village folks, pashtuns can't, neither baloch. To bacha kaun bhai?

 

[Joe Shearer]

Ajmal's accent is more genuine, while Dhoni's is more refined, but people can still note the difference.

More genuine?
More refined?
WTF?