What's new

Is Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan better than Lata Mangeshkar?

It indeed is a benchmark,,,,we have almost all the big names participating in it and still our version sucks.

Our generation is fed on honey singh,,,u are fooling urself
probably you are too young thats why you think listening to honey singh is waste. Its the age thing, even in our time we too had our bally sagoo, sharon prabhakar, baba sehgal or anaida and even then people used to say that indian music is dying. But here I am talking to you about Pandit bhimsen joshi as being the greatest singer India ever had. Its only an age thing, as this generation of Honey Singh matures, they will start to find the beauty of Indian musicians and their art. By the way, you wont find any Indian musician, worth listening, performing for a late night tv show, unless you are watching a 80's doordarshan's late night 'Sangeet ka Akhil Bhartiya Karyakram'.
 
.
Its natural for indians to deny greatness for a pakistani singer............probably pakistanis will always deny greatness of sachin too.
So its expected,,,,we need to rise above this phenomenon
i dont like nusrat.. overrated fat singer with a squeaky voice..
hate sachin too.. :wacko:
 
. .
Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan: The singing Buddha

Published: November 17, 2013

Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan: The singing Buddha – The Express Tribune
630929-fatha-1384268047-443-640x480.jpg

NFAK giving a passionate performance during the 1980s. PHOTO: DR PIERRE-ALAIN BAUD

Hearing Nusrat is not just music, it is an act of worship. There seems to be a consensus amongst those who heard the maestro as he breathed life into notes. Defying the conventional genres that melodies are usually neatly stacked into, he would transcend to a level of rhythmic devotion that was lost on ordinary minds. Immersed in the spiritual, he never lost grip over any note or any tremor, his tehreek, mutki, phanday — nothing short of perfect. As the music washed over your senses and your pulse vibrated to the beat, you ached to fade into his mystical abyss, fully aware that what you were experiencing was not ordinary.

This was the magic of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan.


At Bidi Studio, Paris for a recording in 1993.

Pakistan did not have a Bocelli or Pavarotti at the time, neither did we have our own version of the Beatles or Led Zepplin, but it did not matter because we had Nusrat. Born in Faisalabad, he inherited a 600-year-old tradition of qawwali from his forefathers and went on to become the Shahanshah-e-Qawwali or the The King of Kings of Qawwali. But his genius was not just limited to qawwali. His collaborations with renowned musicians like Peter Gabriel and Eddie Vedder saw a marriage of the electric guitar and the tabla, producing some of the richest fusions of the time.

group members rehearsing at Bidi Studio, Paris.

Unsurpassed in his musical range, his knack for improvisation and the sheer intensity of his chords made him one of the most significant voices from the region. While millions revered the musician, few knew Nusrat — the man. Dr Pierre-Alain Baud, a researcher, academic and author of his biography Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, the messenger of Qawwali, spent several years in Nusrat’s company. In an interview during his recent visit to Lahore, he recounts his experiences with the melodic enigma.

1. What was your first exposure to Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan’s qawwali music?

The first concert I attended took place in Paris in 1985 at Theatre de la Ville. It was organised by Soudabeh Kia, a French-Iranian lady. She was the first person to introduce Nusrat to non-resident Pakistani audiences, the same year as Peter Gabriel.

fatha-041.jpg

Featured in the 1997 issue of TIME magazine.


In 1985, Nusrat was still completely unknown in France, apart from some Sufi or South-Asian music aficionados. A major part of the audience that evening was Pakistani or Indian and the response was just like in Pakistan; people standing up from their seats and going down (Theatre de la Ville hall is very steep) to the stage to offer ‘vel’ (donations) or requesting him to sing such or such an item; a couple of sensitive listeners went into a trance.

2. And your response?

Oh, it was an astonishing discovery, widening my knowledge of Sufi music in a huge way. And Nusrat was such a presence. He had the Beloved floating in the air…

A-ma-zing, really a-ma-zing!

3. What can you tell us about your first meeting with Nusrat?

After this 1985 shock (as a mere lay listener among a 1,000 people), I heard him again live in 1988 or maybe was 1989. I had been listening again and again to his recordings. But the encounter moment came in autumn 1991. I met him when I was en route to attend his concert at an old French monastery. It was an autumn morning. We were at the Railway station in Tours, France. He was there, the ‘Singing Buddha’ from the Theatre de la Ville in Paris, waiting for the connection that would take him and his musicians to Fontevraud Abbey for his last concerts of the year in France. We, members of the enthralled audience who had already seen him perform thrice in Paris the week before, were going to the Abbey too, to witness the incredible freedom of his voice once again.

A group performance at Chergourg, France in 1993.

The shock this meeting produced was scorching. Uncertain, trembling words started a conversation, which slowly grew into a dense dialogue in the shade of the priory. Generous exchanges [were] interrupted by unexpected vocal demonstrations, stunning silences [and a] fiery look…Years later, having accompanied him on numerous international tours, I remained a spectator stunned by his vertiginous voice: I do not fully understand the mystery of his song, but an intimate resonance intrigues and unnerved me as soon as he sat down, cross-legged on the stage and hurled out his mad love song to the Divine.

4, This meeting at Fontevraud was the beginning of your association with Nusrat?

Yes. After the few days we spent together at Fontevraud, he invited me to follow him on his tour to Italy, and then to meet him at his home in Pakistan. From that point of time, I accompanied him for over five years, on a number of his international tours, in the capacity of an assistant of his major promoter. For the past 30 years, [Kia}on behalf of Paris municipal Theatre de la Ville, has been promoting numerous Pakistani artists worldwide.

fatha-06.jpg

Performance at Lok Virsa, Islamabad.

I went with him to a number of European countries, Brazil, Tunisia, and was with him in New York. I followed him to dozens of places in Pakistan and went wherever he was going. He has been a great institution for me [with] respect to the Pakistani
society.

5. Say more about Nusrat the man.

He had innumerable facets: enigmatic and innocent, colossal and peaceful, inspired and ordinary, all parts of the same person who inflamed myriads of spectators in Lahore, Paris, Florence, Tokyo or New York, crossing linguistic and cultural, generational and social barriers with the greatest of ease. To further elaborate, I will quote myself from a fragment of the portrait I sketched about him in my biography foreword:


NFAK with his troupe.

Singing Buddha in Tokyo, Quintessence of the human voice in Tunis, The Voice of Paradise in Los Angeles, The Spirit of Islam in London, Pavarotti of the East in Paris, Shahenshah-e-Qawwali in Lahore . Over the space of about 15 years, this chosen singer, one of God’s madmen, one of God’s sweetest, shot to planetary fame. And then he disappeared, too early…leaving a thousand footprints behind.

A man of superlatives: weight (impressive), octaves (six, supposedly), albums (125 at the beginning of the 1990s according to the Guinness book of records, maybe twice that many by now), videos that can be consulted on the Internet site YouTube (over 2,000, certain of which have been viewed a million times in a single year), concerts (by the thousands), Google references (hundreds of thousands), cassettes and CDs ( by the millions).



PHOTO: REUTERS

And yet a man of deep simplicity. His all-consuming mission was to spread a message — the kind and beautiful words of the Sufi poets, mystics, permeated by an Islam reflecting love and union.

A man outside of time, bewitching us with the madness of his declarations of love addressed to the Divine. A man truly of his times too, open to all kinds of experiments, all kinds of fusion. Rooted and universal. Committed and free.”

6. Who were the people around Nusrat?

Well, in Pakistan, basically his close family members, though I would say, at the same focal level, his qawwali party men, which included his younger brother, Farrukh, and for a long time his cousin-brother, Mujahid Mubarak, as well as his bother-in-law and other cousins.



In fact, he was spending much time with his party, always rolling from one concert venue to another, from a recording to a class, spending a huge amount of time travelling. He had hectic tour schedules.

7. I heard Nurat ate maybe 25 parathas for breakfast. Is that true? What was his favourite dish?

As far as I know, no! He was definitely a good eater (as we say in French). He appreciated eating but not [upto] this point. I am not sure [what his favourite dish was] but the most common one he was eating was roti and meat, the basic menu of Punjabi middle class men, no?


8. I heard Nusrat live in Central Park, New York, in the late 1990s. The impact of hearing his qawwali live is unforgettable. But when I hear Nusrat on CD it does not carry the same inspiration?

In the old days, the LP’s and records carried the full range of the singer’s voice — from the lowest to the highest pitch. Now CDs use stabilisers and other devices (for recording) and only capture the middle range of highs and lows. So you don’t get the full drama, power and passion of the vocalist.

fatha-111.jpg

As a bridegroom.

9. Did your time spent with Nusrat change you in any way?

Definitely. He has been a major go-between, between my French European contemporary identity and my larger Sufi/spiritual/mystic individual soul, projected towards the Universal, the One.

fatha-12.jpg


fatha-13.jpg




fatha-01.jpg

At Rishi Kapoor’s wedding ceremony, Mumbai.
 
.
Coke Studio Pakistan is indeed a benchmark. A different thing. Though recently it was losing some grip but still its a hugely differfent thing
yes thats what im saying., that Coke Studio Pakistan is a benchmark for Pakistani singers and not for everyone from the sub continent. No doubt CSP does feature some great music from Pakistan, but it cant be necessarily mean its the same benchmark in India too.,
 
.
Lata is the only indian female singer whom i listen a lot and i don't think its fair to have comparison of singers. Its like comparison of different foods which bring their own unique taste. Lata is filmi singer while nusrat got popular because of qawaali or sufi singing. Listening lata old songs give you this romantic feelings while listening nusrat give you this spiritual feelings and i guess they boht are important depend on moods. :)
 
.
yes thats what im saying., that Coke Studio Pakistan is a benchmark for Pakistani singers and not for everyone from the sub continent. No doubt CSP does feature some great music from Pakistan, but it cant be necessarily mean its the same benchmark in India too.,

:) the benchmark for India currently is bollywood songs item ones included so indeed Coke Studio Pakistan is a different thing for a different planet
 
.
Only nusrat and jagjit singh had such talent for live show in whole subcontinent,,,,,uncomparable
Jagjit is ghazal singer and have same calm soothing slow style of singing in almost all his ghazal except difference in lyrics..comparison of Jagjit should be with ghulam ali not with nusrat ..Nusrat has this advantage that he sung almost everything from ghazal to qawali to filmi etc
 
.
:) the benchmark for India currently is bollywood songs item ones included so indeed Coke Studio Pakistan is a different thing for a different planet

Don't be naive,,we have produced many legends.
Its not only bollywood in india

Jagjit is ghazal singer and have same calm soothing slow style of singing in almost all his ghazal except difference in lyrics..comparison of Jagjit should be with ghulam ali not with nusrat ..Nusrat has this advantage that he sung almost everything from ghazal to qawali to filmi etc

Sorry dude.........jagjit is a stalwart in his own right.
Ghulam ali though good,can never compete with jagjit,not in a million years.

Just listen to his ghalib renditions,,,no one can justify ghalib like he did
 
.
Don't be naive,,we have produced many legends.
Its not only bollywood in india

READ again i said "Currently" amnot talking about golden era of music/singers in India.




Sorry dude.........jagjit is a stalwart in his own right.
Ghulam ali though good,can never compete with jagjit,not in a million years.

Just listen to his ghalib renditions,,,no one can justify ghalib like he did

both are great :)

Ghulam Ali is called King of Ghazal in India
 
.
Sorry dude.........jagjit is a stalwart in his own right.
Ghulam ali though good,can never compete with jagjit,not in a million years.

Just listen to his ghalib renditions,,,no one can justify ghalib like he did
Dont need to be sorry. We all have our own taste of music and have like or dislike based on our own taste of Music. I personally like few ghazal of Jagjit for example hontoo ko sho loo tum and kaghaz ki kashti and few others popular but rest of them all look same to me..his style of singing is same..even if you listen 10 of his ghazal non stop you will feel like its one ghazal because of same style...Similarly i like few famous ghazal of ghulam ali, abida parveen and some others..but i dont like every single ghazal of these singers
 
.
Dont need to be sorry. We all have our own taste of music and have like or dislike based on our own taste of Music. I personally like few ghazal of Jagjit for example hontoo ko sho loo tum and kaghaz ki kushi and few others popular but rest of them all look same to me..his style of singing is same..even if you listen 10 of his ghazal non stop you will feel like its one ghazal because of same style...Similarly i like few famout ghazal of ghulam ali, abida parveen and some others..but i dont like every single ghazal of these singers

Let me break ur perception ,,just listen to first 20 minutes.
Its live


READ again i said "Currently" amnot talking about golden era of music/singers in India.






both are great :)

Ghulam Ali is called King of Ghazal in India

Jagjit>ghulam

Not even a debate.:D
But mehndi hassan was probably the best
 
.
:) the benchmark for India currently is bollywood songs item ones included so indeed Coke Studio Pakistan is a different thing for a different planet
madam ,, that same bollywood is providing bread n butter to many Pakistanis like Atif, Rahat fateh ali khan, adnan sami and many more. And you cant deny that real recognition for even NFAK, came when he got popular in India, till then even not many Pakistanis knew about him.
 
.
actually .. jagjit stole some gazal from ghulam @he-man
although i like jagjit's style.. and use of modern instrument (not harmonium)
 
.
actually .. jagjit stole some gazal from ghulam @he-man
although i like jagjit's style.. and use of modern instrument (not harmonium)

There is nothing stolen man...........anyone can attempt a ghazal from any shair.
But after death of his only son,jagjit had a pain in his voice which is a rarity man

He sang from his heart
 
.
Back
Top Bottom