Is MMS the worst PM ever? He refused to take briefings from intel agencies

[Rajaraja Chola]

He is the worst of the worst. He even puts morons like gowda, morarji, ik gujral, charan Singh, VP Singh to shame.

He is not worse than them. He was better. MMS is respected all over the world. I believe he was decent and honest.
His performance in 2nd term was poor due to coaliation compulsion and Sonia eagerness to put her idiotic son to be the future PM. He deserves criticism but not like this, honestly.

 

[livingdead]

Ok mate, as Indian law doesn't prohibit this than why not simply bring back QE-II to rule India??? After all they have been in India for 250 odd years (4 times Sonia's entire lifetime).........whats WRONG in that???

& don't talk BS, I belong to Sindhi community, according to your argument my entire community is not Indian on the first place....I take serious OFFENSE to that.

no, its the same argument that you made, I never said LKA or MMS should not be PM, did I?
No matter where they come from, if they accept Indian citizenship they are eligible to fight election and get highest position.
Imagine a party specifically targetting people of pakistani origin and threatening to pass a law to bar them from highest position. How does it sound?
Now I know you will say, but she is white. she is firangi. how can she be one of us? right?

If queen accepts Indian citizenship (she has to abjure british one) and fights election and majority of MPs want her as PM, she will be PM. what is so difficult to understand.

 

[arp2041]

no, its the same argument that you made, I never said LKA or MMS should not be PM, did I?
No matter where they come from, if they accept Indian citizenship they are eligible to fight election and get highest position.
Imagine a party specifically targetting people of pakistani origin and threatening to pass a law to bar them from highest position. How does it sound?
Now I know you will say, but she is white. she is firangi. how can she be one of us? right?

Partition is an EXCEPTION, apart from that show me ONE country (rule or not) where a person born outside that country can take the HIGHEST POSITION.

& why din't you counter my British raj argument??

& You are making foolish arguments..........this never was about RACISM, don't know why are you so inclined to make it one.

 

[livingdead]

Partition is an EXCEPTION, apart from that show me ONE country (rule or not) where a person born outside that country can take the HIGHEST POSITION.

& why din't you counter my British raj argument??

& You are making foolish arguments..........this never was about RACISM, don't know why are you so inclined to make it one.

what british raj argument? I did not get that. queen can accept indian citizenship > fight election > get majority MPs to support her > become ruler of India. Its all so simple. Same for sindhis. Same for bengalis.
This is Indian law as it stands even now, and BJP's threat to change the law just for 1 person is pathetic racism.

 

[JanjaWeed]

MMS may have had all the good intentions when he entered the politics. Maybe he thought he would be able to cleanse the system from within by being part of it. But unfortunately he himself got sucked into that quagmire & ended up being one of the worst ever PMs India has seen. All that good works he has done in early 90s as Finance minister or his productive UPA 1 tenure will all be forgotten & he will ever be remembered as the one who headed the most incompetent & the most corrupt ever government in the history of independent India.

 

[Dem!god]

He is a dark spot on the name of Sikhs. We Sikhs are really ashamed of him.

u are sikhini....here is another...meet @Sidak

 

[dray]

As an individual he is one of the most humble & qualified person in Indian politics, but as a PM he was the worst because he was never in control of his government, he was governing nothing, no other PM ever diluted the position & sanctity of the post like him, that's just sad and sets a very very bad precedence for the future.

 

[Angry Bird]

just so you know you dont own the pm just because you are sikh. you can be ashamed of anybody you want who cares.

I started my first post as we sikhs not as we Indian. Advice for you read the post carefully before answering it.

 

[livingdead]

I started my first post as we sikhs not as we Indian. Advice for you read the post carefully before answering it.

ah after reading carefully it all makes sense. cheers.

 

[ExtraOdinary]

Did Prime Minister Manmohan Singh use Sanjay Baru's book to set record straight? | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis



for me it's Indira than ABV

Pre-emptive strike by Singh, if he loses (which seems highly likely) be rest assured the dynasty will put all the blame on him. The Queen mother is a heartless creature

 

[arp2041]

what british raj argument? I did not get that. queen can accept indian citizenship > fight election > get majority MPs to support her > become ruler of India. Its all so simple. Same for sindhis. Same for bengalis.
This is Indian law as it stands even now, and BJP's threat to change the law just for 1 person is pathetic racism.

Till 1947, even Pakistan was India, so whoever came to this side of the border is a natural Indian citizen, I would happily except your argument if Italy was part of India till 1947 or till when Sonia came to India.

Now I am really sorry to say, you are really making a foolish argument (even if there is no rule, but no self respected country will allow a citizen of foreign origin to sit on it's highest chair). THERE IS NO NO RACISM AT ALL.

 

[dray]

Morarji desai would be the worst. Best PM's we have had would be our dear poet ABV, LB Shastri and to some extent I Gandhi

Why not PVN Rao? I think he was far better than Indira Gandhi, she barely has anything positive to show other than 1971 war, and the list of negatives would be long.

 

[vicky sen]

As an individual he is one of the most humble & qualified person in Indian politics, but as a PM he was the worst because he was never in control of his government, he was governing nothing, no other PM ever diluted the position & sanctity of the post like him, that's just sad and sets a very very bad precedence for the future.

Thats just it. No one is questioning Dr. Singh as a person, but his PMship. He is the highest authority in the country, and when he allows himself to be controlled by someone outside the govt, I would call it cheating of the high office that he holds.

 

[Friei Indien]

I have told you before I was born, and bred in Europe.

bred??? are u cattle?

 

[arp2041]

@hinduguy I will not blame you...........actually SLAVERY ki adat padh gyi hai hamey (don't take it personal, i have made this argument n no. of times in political thread)..........first it was Mughals, than Britishers than an Italian born lady..............