What's new

Is India cutting ‘off its nose to spite its face’ on OBOR?

GlobalVillageSpace

Media Partner
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
993
Reaction score
1
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Is India cutting ‘off its nose to spite its face’ on OBOR?
Global Village Space |


News Analysis |

India has not sent an official delegation to attend the “Belt and Road Forum” in Beijing and instead criticized China’s global initiative, warning of an”unsustainable debt burden” for countries involved.

President Xi has conceived and is currently advocating what China formally calls the “One Belt, One Road” or OBOR initiative to build a new Silk Road. This route will link Asia, Africa, and Europe, and is a landmark program which will lead to the investment of billions of dollars in infrastructure projects including railways, ports and power grids.

“Connectivity initiatives must follow principles of financial responsibility to avoid projects that would create unsustainable debt burden for communities,” Baglay said.

The initiative is tipped to perch China on a pedestal where it will be able to expand its power profile. By contrast, India has boycotted the event despite Chinese attempts to cajole them into coming and telling them it as in harmony with Modi government’s ‘Act East Policy.’ Chinese State Daily, Global Times, has termed Indian transigence to join OBOR as regrettable but said it would not hamper ‘the trend toward cooperation in infrastructure development among its neighboring countries at all.’

Read more: “We can think about renaming CPEC” China offers India

Indian concerns on OBOR
MEA spokesman Gopal Baglay explained India’s absence from the well-attended event as India could not accept a project that compromised its sovereignty.

“No country can accept a project that ignores its core concerns on sovereignty and territorial integrity,” Baglay said.

Ostensibly, India is concerned that CPEC passes through a region in what it calls as Pakistan Occupied Kashmir (Azad Kashmir), which is an infringement of its sovereignty. This 70 years long unresolved Kashmir dispute is now becoming part of another fast-developing conflagration.

The MEA spokesman, also while stressing on the need for regional connectivity criticized the sustainability of debts.

“Connectivity initiatives must follow principles of financial responsibility to avoid projects that would create an unsustainable debt burden for communities,” Baglay said.

The Global Times rebuked Indian expression of fears for its neighboring countries and wrote ‘It is strange that the onlooker is more anxious than the players. While India cares about its neighbors’ debt burden, the neighbors appear willing to take on more.’

Read full article:

Is India cutting ‘off its nose to spite its face’ on OBOR?
 
.

The Global Times rebuked Indian expression of fears for its neighboring countries and wrote ‘It is strange that the onlooker is more anxious than the players. While India cares about its neighbors’ debt burden, the neighbors appear willing to take on more.’


India is making an International embarrassment of itself.
 
. .
Indian themselves are not worried so much about being left, but our dear neighbors are more concerned, what is this Brotherly Love ??:o:
Who wants to miss one of the worlds largest market;). The main aim of China with OBOR is to further develop it's export driven economy. Their total exports to the west are declining they are looking for new farming grounds.
 
.
Who wants to miss one of the worlds largest market;). The main aim of China with OBOR is to further develop it's export driven economy. Their total exports to the west are declining they are looking for new farming grounds.
'biggest market in the world', that also has the largest amount of poor people living below the global poverty index anywhere in the world.
1 in 3 of the poorest people in the world is an indian
 
.
True India is large but its economy is just 20% the size of China, it's manufacturing is just 14% of China. Its steel production is just 10% of China, and its exports is also 15% of China. China exports were 2000 billion USD last year, India was around 260 billion USD.

China per capita income is 5 times that of India and India per capita is equal to Pakistan, unlike the perception. In HDI India ranks 131 in the world. In per capita it ranks 140 in the world....so lot of catching to be done.

Car sales in China was 25 million last year, in India it was 2 million, not even 10% of car sales of China. So light year difference between India and China. Lot of India indices are much closer to Pakistan actually than it is with China.
 
Last edited:
.
India population is 1.3 billion or 130 crore and Pakistan is 200 million or 20 crore, so India population is 6.5 times that of Pakistan or Pakistan population is just 15% of India's.

So if India economy is 7 times that of Pakistan so is it's population, if its cars sales are 2 million and for Pak it is 2.85 lacs, that is 6 times less than India, so is it's population. The per capita income of India and all per capita indices are same, between India and China the difference is of light years...

But in the case of India and China, the population of India and China is same, very minor difference, 1.3 billion for India and 1.4 billion for China, BTW India will be ahead of China in 2022, but only in population.

So this is the main point, all the indices of India and Pakistan are very similar. All the indices of India and China are all very different.
 
.
The Chinese want to funnel their products into all the third world countries and completely dominate them. Who in their right mind will participate?

And this is not even considering that CPEC will be going through Indian territory without Indian permission.
 
.
True India is large but its economy is just 20% the size of China, it's manufacturing is just 14% of China. Its steel production is just 10% of China, and its exports is also 15% of China. China exports were 2000 billion last year, India was around 260 billion USD.

China per capita income is 5 times that of India and India per capita is equal to Pakistan, unlike the perception. In HDI India ranks 131 in the world. In per capita it ranks 140 in the world....so lot of catching to be done.

Car sales in China was 25 million last year, in India it was 2 million, not even 10% of car sales of China. So light year difference between India and China. Lot of India indices are much closer to Pakistan actually than it is with China.
Don't start compare India with Pakistan :lol: It gets wider than India-China.
 
.
China has ended/abolished the one child policy three years ago or so, how did you missed this important news. They knew about the populace getting mature if not older and calculated the right time about abolishing the one child restriction.

About the young population bulge in India, it is more about the demographic dilemma than it is about the demographic dividend India.

China and India are different when it comes to work ethics, China is a one nation, centralized, controlled government, India not. China follows the Mao, Tao's , Confucius philosophy, India is divided between caste and creed, region and religion, the difference is big. But as it is said it's the region which prospers and develops, if India develops it helps Pakistan even the trade is very low, same with China and India.
 
.
I read a lot of Indian media and I can say with conviction that many media house like TOI, Zee news, Hindustan times, doesn't appears to run independently...specially when it comes to news about Pakistan/Kashmir and news related to China, clearly looks concocted, fudged and doctored if you compare the news with independent media.

Only 'the Hindu' and NDTV occasionally seems to be independent to quite an extent. IBN live which partners with CNN also seems partially independent.

PDF is an open forum and much better...
 
.
So this is the main point, all the indices of India and Pakistan are very similar. All the indices of India and China are all very different.

There is a 5 times difference between India and China today.

By 2030, it would have fallen to about 2 to 2.5 times.

By 2040, it would be about the same.

By 2050, India would have surpassed China while continuing to maintain twice the growth for the next 20 to 30 years after 2050.

You are completely ignoring India's potential.
 
.
PAKISTAN LACKS TECHNOLOGY- EVERYTHING DEPENDENT- now dependent on China to manufacture clothing, shoes,
to build schools and mosques, highways and byways; ports and factories. Pakistan economy is smaller than many Indian states.Also dependent on China to fight neighbouring states like India, Iran and Afghanistan. Atom bombs and missiles have made in China Tag. AS A RESULT CPEC (BRI) looks tantalising- grap it fast and let the future generation pay for it. May ......

You are brainwashed by your Indian media which concocts and gives doctored news about Pakistan. Just to make India look good they will portray Pakistan in bad light. The reason is to prove that look since Pakistan got separated from India and they made a wrong decision and India is better...controlled and fudged Indian media is fooling the Indian nation.

How can be they so naive and gullible in this age of 'information explosion'...
 
.
OBOR is disaster for India both economically and sovereignty.
All Indians are happy for this decision.
But why pakistanies and Chinese have problem with Indian decision? After all we are enemy nation.
 
.
There is a 5 times difference between India and China today.

By 2030, it would have fallen to about 2 to 2.5 times.

By 2040, it would be about the same.

By 2050, India would have surpassed China while continuing to maintain twice the growth for the next 20 to 30 years after 2050.

You are completely ignoring India's potential.

Yes this woulda, shoulda, coulda is not relevant in this fast moving world.

...and you are assuming that China will stand idle and its economy will not grow an inch, BTW China economy is 5 times that of India and a 6.5% GDP growth means 4.5 times higher growth than India.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom