Is China erasing the Hui Muslim identity?

[El Sidd]

Well thing is, Persians and Kurds are not typically fans of Pan-Turkism and commonly despise it. So this Iranian national might be from a Turkic ethnicity.

I am not going to indulge myself in identity crisis plaguing Iranians. It's the exploitation of the crisis by Iranian government to stoke conflicts which i strongly oppose.

 

[ThunderCat]

I am not going to indulge myself in identity crisis plaguing Iranians. It's the exploitation of the crisis by Iranian government to stoke conflicts which i strongly oppose.

No but try to understand the social/ethnic dynamics. We also have similar mentalities in Pakistan depending on the ethnicity.

With the multi-ethnic Muhajir upperclass and their Sindhi upper class stooges being typically pro-Indian/Bangladeshi types out of hatred for Punjabi hegemony.

You won't find too many Pakhtuns, West Punjabis, Kashmiris praising the imaginary progress of India & Bangladesh. These usually come from upper class Muhajir & Sindhi self-loathing leftists.

 

[Muji.Iqbal]

And these are not Uighur Muslims!

Hui Muslims are ethnic Hans, so this narrative that the Chinese Kuffar are only acting against Uighurs and not against Muslims in general is a pure lie!!!

Just imagine Israeli Kuffar destroying Palestinian mosques and making them look like synagoges, what an outrage this would cause....

Or Hindu Kuffar destroying Kashmiri mosques and making them look like Hindu temples, how Pakistanis would go nuts....

But if Chinese Kuffar do this oppression to Hui Muslims (and not just to Uighur Muslims!!!)....nothing, just pure silence....

"Patriotism is a part of faith"....WHAT?!! Since when??!
A marxism banner inside a mosque....unbelievable!!! Just imagine Israeli or Hindu Kuffar doing such things....

Well, it is clear that Muslim governments will not protest, but also the Muslim masses couldn't care less about the Muslim oppression (not just Uighur oppression!) in China, yet barking 24/7 about how Muslims are mistreated in the West

The Palestinian and Kashmiri oppression are totally irrelevant as long as Muslims ignore the Muslim oppression in China!!!!!

I find this post kind of silly.

China is Pakistan's closest ally.

Secondly this is China's internal affairs.

 

[Muji.Iqbal]

And these are not Uighur Muslims!

Hui Muslims are ethnic Hans, so this narrative that the Chinese Kuffar are only acting against Uighurs and not against Muslims in general is a pure lie!!!

Just imagine Israeli Kuffar destroying Palestinian mosques and making them look like synagoges, what an outrage this would cause....

Or Hindu Kuffar destroying Kashmiri mosques and making them look like Hindu temples, how Pakistanis would go nuts....

But if Chinese Kuffar do this oppression to Hui Muslims (and not just to Uighur Muslims!!!)....nothing, just pure silence....

"Patriotism is a part of faith"....WHAT?!! Since when??!
A marxism banner inside a mosque....unbelievable!!! Just imagine Israeli or Hindu Kuffar doing such things....

Well, it is clear that Muslim governments will not protest, but also the Muslim masses couldn't care less about the Muslim oppression (not just Uighur oppression!) in China, yet barking 24/7 about how Muslims are mistreated in the West

The Palestinian and Kashmiri oppression are totally irrelevant as long as Muslims ignore the Muslim oppression in China!!!!!

Secondly Kashmir is a territorial dispute according to the United Nations.

Xinjiang is not a territorial dispute according to the United Nations and is an integral part of China.

 

[El Sidd]

No but try to understand the social/ethnic dynamics. We also have similar mentalities in Pakistan depending on the ethnicity.

With the multi-ethnic Muhajir upperclass and their Sindhi upper class stooges being typically pro-Indian/Bangladeshi types out of hatred for Punjabi hegemony.

You won't find too many Pakhtuns, West Punjabis, Kashmiris praising the imaginary progress of India & Bangladesh. These usually come from upper class Muhajir & Sindhi self-loathing leftists.

Bangladesh as former East Pakistan will get a political mention. It's not driven by any tribal code of conduct or racial prejudice.

These people just forget that Pakistan has direct people to people contact and connectivity with Eastern China. China does not have a problem with any of its immediate neighbouring countries barring India.

India getting a mention internally in Pakistan is driven by contempt not appreciation.

 

[ThunderCat]

India getting a mention internally in Pakistan is driven by contempt not appreciation.

Exactly the same for Bangladesh. Those Muhajir neo-liberal zealots are "praising" it out of frustration. Likewise for upper class leftist Sindhis.

But all know it's complete nonsense.

 

[Leishangthem]

This american snake with typical deceptive anglo scum talking style that think propaganda in a hype tone is more convincing,it really got on my nerves.
This american snake thought she found something like other states such as Indonesia don't literally make mosque as local or experimental architecture.

Why should asian state adopt arabic architecture?The dome is nothing but eyesore of foreign influence to local aesthetics.

I can't imagine paying to travel china to be met with arabic architecture instead of local chinese. I don’t wanna seee fkn arabic architecture in east/southeast asia period.

Like letting foreign religion to thrive wasn't enough,religion are nothing but cancer,useless and hinders .
development & give leeway to criminals.
No nation should allow religious retards undermine national stability,local culture, tradition .
Foreign religion are the main reason for local culture genocide of native tradition on earth.lt has killed so much indigenous culture.
Islam,buddhism,Christianity,even hinduism aren't local or traditional culture ,these are simply the most powerful religious culture imports with most diligent preachers.

 

[MH.Yang]

1, The Hui ethnic group is a mixed race of Arabs and Han Chinese. Their ancestors were Arab merchants who settled in China from the 7th century to the 17th century, Arab Empire soldiers who were captured by the Tang Dynasty emperor, and Arab soldiers who attacked the Song Dynasty with the Mongolian emperor.

2, The Hui people have lived in China for over a thousand years, and for thousands of years, they have been intermarrying and living together with the Han people. The relationship between the two ethnic groups is very good.

3, The Hui ethnic group is the leader of all Muslim ethnic groups in China, a staunch supporter of the central government throughout history, and a fanatical Chinese nationalist.

4, The Hui ethnic group once spontaneously organized troops to participate in the China Japanese War and the Korean War, and they were an important component of China's military power.

5, The Hui ethnic group is our brotherly nation, and we will always protect the interests and status of the Hui ethnic group.

 

[ARMalik]

And these are not Uighur Muslims!

Hui Muslims are ethnic Hans, so this narrative that the Chinese Kuffar are only acting against Uighurs and not against Muslims in general is a pure lie!!!

Just imagine Israeli Kuffar destroying Palestinian mosques and making them look like synagoges, what an outrage this would cause....

Or Hindu Kuffar destroying Kashmiri mosques and making them look like Hindu temples, how Pakistanis would go nuts....

But if Chinese Kuffar do this oppression to Hui Muslims (and not just to Uighur Muslims!!!)....nothing, just pure silence....

"Patriotism is a part of faith"....WHAT?!! Since when??!
A marxism banner inside a mosque....unbelievable!!! Just imagine Israeli or Hindu Kuffar doing such things....

Well, it is clear that Muslim governments will not protest, but also the Muslim masses couldn't care less about the Muslim oppression (not just Uighur oppression!) in China, yet barking 24/7 about how Muslims are mistreated in the West

The Palestinian and Kashmiri oppression are totally irrelevant as long as Muslims ignore the Muslim oppression in China!!!!!

China is not eradicating anyone. The fact is Iran has a history of eradicating its minorities.

 

[etylo]

1, The Hui ethnic group is a mixed race of Arabs and Han Chinese. Their ancestors were Arab merchants who settled in China from the 7th century to the 17th century, Arab Empire soldiers who were captured by the Tang Dynasty emperor, and Arab soldiers who attacked the Song Dynasty with the Mongolian emperor.

2, The Hui people have lived in China for over a thousand years, and for thousands of years, they have been intermarrying and living together with the Han people. The relationship between the two ethnic groups is very good.

3, The Hui ethnic group is the leader of all Muslim ethnic groups in China, a staunch supporter of the central government throughout history, and a fanatical Chinese nationalist.

4, The Hui ethnic group once spontaneously organized troops to participate in the China Japanese War and the Korean War, and they were an important component of China's military power.

5, The Hui ethnic group is our brotherly nation, and we will always protect the interests and status of the Hui ethnic group.

Hui enthnic group is not a nation, China should and will never allow nations within the Chinese nation, be it in the form of religion or enthnicity, to exist, otherwise, China is asking for trouble. Religious practice in China especially collaboration with the outside should be curtailed, no extremism of religion should be allowed to exist.

 

[beijingwalker]

Hui people are Chinese, not a single Hui person believes otherwise, throughout their 1,000 history, not a single Hui person wanted to create another state outside China, and Hui have been always the most adamant defender of China, espeicially in securing Xinjiang and Tibet, Huis were also one of the sigificant force to fight Japan during China anti Japanese war.

On the banner it says : " Fight Japan, save our country ( China)".

 

[beijingwalker]

I don't know about Muslims in other countries, but for Hui Muslims, it's always China first, all other things come later.

 

[Song Hong]

1, The Hui ethnic group is a mixed race of Arabs and Han Chinese. Their ancestors were Arab merchants who settled in China from the 7th century to the 17th century, Arab Empire soldiers who were captured by the Tang Dynasty emperor, and Arab soldiers who attacked the Song Dynasty with the Mongolian emperor.

2, The Hui people have lived in China for over a thousand years, and for thousands of years, they have been intermarrying and living together with the Han people. The relationship between the two ethnic groups is very good.

3, The Hui ethnic group is the leader of all Muslim ethnic groups in China, a staunch supporter of the central government throughout history, and a fanatical Chinese nationalist.

4, The Hui ethnic group once spontaneously organized troops to participate in the China Japanese War and the Korean War, and they were an important component of China's military power.

5, The Hui ethnic group is our brotherly nation, and we will always protect the interests and status of the Hui ethnic group.

You are not right in the context of whole China. Most Hui are Han converts and Han per se.

The Hui that exhibit central Asians are those in Ning Xia.

I dont see why China need a Hui race. Even Hui leaders Ma Bufang said 只有回教 没有回族 (there is only Islam religion and no Hui race).

 

[beijingwalker]

Mosques in China were always with Chinese architecture style in the history, only recent newly built mosques got influenced by the middle eastern architecture style.

 

[Song Hong]

Hui Y chromsone Haplogroup over entire China. The Ningxia Hui is different.