What's new

Influential Cleric Tells Khamenei Iran's 'Current Situation Cannot Continue'

ziad goh nakhor. This just shows how little you know of Iran. The only reason minorities speaks Persian today is because bureaucracy and education is in Persian. Do you think all the soldiers recruited from the villages were educated and spoke Persian? Think with your brain not your ***
bebin bache kooni madarjende. if you claim something you need to back it up with facts. randomly burping out shit wont help your cause you kooni.
yes you illiterate, people who have never been to school or never had any education and could not write their names or people like you who are living in caves or are deaf and blind and speak their own minority language perhaps cant speak persian. but they fall in the extreme cases you kooni which you are trying to magnify.
 
.
That was not the Issue of this thread.

We were discussing a different thing. Btw, Persian is our National language and hence everyone with least literacy can easily write in Persian. Speaking Persian properly is not the case. Kastor failed to spell Persian words properly. We have different accents in the country, but someone that has learned English so well must be completely known to Persian anyway as his National language or mother tongue.
He was the one who brought it up. I am not going to sit here and ignore an ungrateful kid who doesn't even respect our martyrs
 
. .
bastard, there is nothing as ''persian'' in our language. we call our language as ''parsi'' or more commonly used as Farsi. how can a iranian not speak farsi in iran, tell me you smartass.
which martyrs who were iranian could not speak farsi !? stop being so unclear, bring up their names, tell us who they are. dont just claim something you POS


zer nazan kooni, to hamoon khaarkosde nabudi ke too thread mozakhraf 1 mah tamoom ba memberha tork dashti bekhatere yek zirpoosh bahs mikardi ? maye aberoo rizi hasti koonde. bejaye to budam khodamo miraftam khaak mikardam.

yalla herri koonde.
ziad goh nakhor. This just shows how little you know of Iran. The only reason minorities speaks Persian today is because bureaucracy and education is in Persian. Do you think all the soldiers recruited from the villages were educated and spoke Persian? Think with your brain not your ***
Guys, cool it. You are making mistake to fight among yourselves.
 
.
He was the one who brought it up. I am not going to sit here and ignore an ungrateful kid who doesn't even respect our martyrs
kos nagoo madarjende. miduni kooni hasti

Guys, cool it. You are making mistake to fight among yourselves.
be ehterame dadashi ke bashi in akharin poste man khahad bud. khak bar saresh konan hichi balad nist.
bikhial dadash.
 
.
to ke az zan ha badet miad bache kooni. mage be hame nagofti ke doost dari dare koone pedaret va baaghiye marda bezari ? LMAO
Sharmande. Man faghat ba madaret erza misham.

upload_2020-6-28_21-55-13.png


Here you have facts. Our literacy rate in 1976 was under 40% Which means most of the minorities who fought in the Iran-Iraq war didn't know Persian. Is this is too hard for your brain to understand?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
i told my friend i wont reply to you anymore but one more thing. being illiterate in writing doesnt mean you cant communicate in persian you dumb ****. you think all those soldiers who couldnt write were talking in what language ? gorilla language ?

you got exposed madarjende khaarkosde. i am out of this.
 
.
Gutsy letter....but he's right.

https://en.radiofarda.com/a/influen...rent-situation-cannot-continue-/30693992.html

One of Iran's most high-ranking and politically prominent clerics has warned the Islamic Republic's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei that his regime's popularity and legitimacy has been seriously damaged mainly because of injustice as well as economic and cultural problems.

In a letter to Khamenei on Saturday June 27, the 79-year old cleric from Qazvin, Ayatollah Seyyed Mohammad Mousavi Khoeiniha said that "What many people think and say, and their living standards are not consistent with a political system known to the world by its Islamic nature."

Khoeiniha, a former Prosecutor General, and an ex member of the Majles and the Assembly of Experts, is known for masterminding the seizure of the U.S. embassy in Tehran in 1979 and taking over 50 U.S. diplomats hostage for 444 days.

Khoiniha said he is sharing the letter with the nation, hoping that his account of the country's situation would prompt Khamenei to contemplate and do something good for the people.

He said in the letter to Khamenei, which was published by Ensaf News and re-run by many other Iranian websites on Saturday, "Increasing inflation and declining incomes have created backbreaking problems for the people that have led to abnormal behaviors and have given way to many concerns for the people about the future of their children."

"At the same time, many others are also unhappy about the country's political and cultural situation which are marked by undeniable injustice," said Khoeiniha.

Characterizing Khamenei as "the main player" in Iran, Khoeiniha implicitly pointed at Khamenei's responsibility over problems and shortcomings, adding that the current problematic situation are not simply the outcome of decisions made by managers who are transitional.
He stressed that "From the point of view of the people”, the highest authority is the main player in all or most of the country's affairs, adding that the continued that "the current situation cannot continue."

Khoeiniha said elsewhere in his letter that that "the people believe the highest authority in the country's management should have prevented the cultural, economic and social chaos the country is facing today."

Khoeiniha said at the end, "If the current way of running the country's affairs is based on conventional calculations and known views about governance, there are numerous other experts who should be allowed to criticize this method of government and call for reforming it without fearing possible consequences."

Despite the criticism, Khoeiniha wrote that "if decisions made in recent decades are based on a knowledge only certain individuals are bestowed with, then what is happening to the country and its citizens is an inevitable destiny to which I shall succumb and surrender."

The call on Khamenei to allow critics voice their concerns comes while almost everyone who has openly criticized Khamenei, including 14 well known dissidents, ended up in jail in 2019.

On the other hand, Khamenei has shown that criticism does not influence his decisions. Saturday morning, during a teleconference with Judiciary officials in Tehran, he praised former Chief Justice Sadeq Larijani who has been widely criticized for financial corruption charges faced by his former deputy and many have also implicated Larijani in the case.

Regardless of the extremely polite tone of Khoeiniha's letter, it is still not known what kind of reaction awaits him. He is a die-hard left wing cleric and the leader of the left wing Militant Clerics Association and a seasoned politician who used to have a following among Iranian left wing students.

When his newspaper, Salam, which was highly critical of the government, was shut down in 1999, thousands of students took to the streets in protest which led to the biggest clash between the police and students in Iran's history as well as leading to one of the biggest political crises the Islamic Republic has ever faced during the past four decades.

Our Supreme Leader has done all he can and more for our nation. And Iran is lucky to have his guidance and leadership. I understand the concerns and all that, but it was anyone but the supreme leaders fault. 99.99% of the problem that Iran faces today is manufactured by external criminal empire. They have pushed Iran to the edge of endurance and yet Iran still endures and resists. It’s not a wise letter. The end justifies the means. And the only end that justifies the means is for Iran to overcome these external unfair constraints placed on it. Only then can the nation move forward. This guy is 79 yrs old and a very respected and wise person ofcourse, but I don’t think he sees the greater picture here. It’s traitors like Rouhani that is to blame. It’s the anti resistance, west appeasing forces that is causing a gap in Iran’s progression. Iran must follow the great leader’s way of resistance put up a total resistance economy, resistance culture, resistance society, resistance everything. Rouhani and moderates shud never be allowed to get into power again. What value does liberty has if it comes at cost of wrongdoing? Long live Khamenei
 
.
i told my friend i wont reply to you anymore but one more thing. being illiterate in writing doesnt mean you cant communicate in persian you dumb ****. you think all those soldiers who couldnt write were talking in what language ? gorilla language ?

you got exposed madarjende khaarkosde. i am out of this.

wrong. language is nr.1 in identity.

what do you mean ''we had martyrs who didnt knew persian'' ? if they did not speak persian then they were foreigner

as far as i know everyone in iran can speak persian

how you can be a iranian and not know your own language ?

Fek konam enghad ke shabha jighaye madarete shenidi vakhtike gozashtan too kosesh, ke roo maghzet badjoori tasir karde.

There were thousands of Iranians who didn't know Persian back then. There still are thousands of older generation Iranians who doesn't know Persian today. I have met plenty myself who I couldn't communicate with because they didn't know Persian. Instead of coming up with stupid insults only worthy of 10 year old kids. Admit when you are wrong. You lack any kind of knowledge of how your own country is, yet you dare point finger at others.
 
Last edited:
. .
I have read a few pages in the thread and its reduced to ' i know better than you' kind of arguments.

I have a couple of Irani friends here. They always talk about unrest and corruption in Iran. They say there are people closer to regime who are rich thru influence while the rest of Iran suffers under heavy weight of this pretended Islamic identity.

I m not aware of Irani politics but I would like to know what Irani leadership should do to improve lives of the people of the country.

Are there any classes or segments of Irani society which are unaffected by economic conditions?
 
.
what you are saying is total bullshit. a iranian in iran that can not speak farsi.
HAHA! thanks for the laugh troll.
guys keep an eye on this troll @Hack-Hook he is potentially a false flagger or a MEK troll.
if you man enough ore even an iranian , you prove me wrong . you are not Iranian and you have never been to Iran as you don't knew anything about Iran

bastard, there is nothing as ''persian'' in our language. we call our language as ''parsi'' or more commonly used as Farsi. how can a iranian not speak farsi in iran, tell me you smartass.
because you have the missconception that an Iranian is a Parsi. no he may be kurd , he maybe lor , he maybe Baluch , he maybe Azeri , he maybe Arab , he maybe Gilak or perhaps a Parsi
 
.
Wow
bastard, there is nothing as ''persian'' in our language. we call our language as ''parsi'' or more commonly used as Farsi. how can a iranian not speak farsi in iran, tell me you smartass.
which martyrs who were iranian could not speak farsi !? stop being so unclear, bring up their names, tell us who they are. dont just claim something you POS


zer nazan kooni, to hamoon khaarkosde nabudi ke too thread mozakhraf 1 mah tamoom ba memberha tork dashti bekhatere yek zirpoosh bahs mikardi ? maye aberoo rizi hasti koonde. bejaye to budam khodamo miraftam khaak mikardam.

yalla herri koonde.
Wow, you're in the unstable side too
 
.
That was not the Issue of this thread.

We were discussing a different thing. Btw, Persian is our National language and hence everyone with least literacy can easily write in Persian. Speaking Persian properly is not the case. Kastor failed to spell Persian words properly. We have different accents in the country, but someone that has learned English so well must be completely known to Persian anyway as his National language or mother tongue.
the problem is one person here say if you don't knew persian language you are not iranian
we say 93% of iranian are literate .that mean 7% illiterate .the question is what we consider literacy ?many of our elderly literate only learned alphabet to read Quran , and can 't understand newspapers. are they not Iranian ? are they not Literate ? On other hand A tajik or Afghan will understand and talk persian is he considered Iranian ?

section 976 of Iran Civil Code state who is Iranian and believe me nowhere in it it's stated that you must speak persian to be considered an Iranian.
https://www.wipo.int/edocs/lexdocs/laws/en/ir/ir009en.pdf
BOOK 2
Concerning Nationality
Article 976 - The following persons are considered to be Iranian subjects
1 - All persons residing in Iran except those whose foreign nationality is established; the foreign nationality of such persons is considered to be established if their documents of nationality have not been objected to by the Iranian Government.
2- Those born Iran or outside whose fathers are Iranian.
3 - Those born in Iran of unknown parentage.
4 - Persons born in Iran of foreign parents, one of whom was also born in Iran.
5 - Persons born in Iran of a father of foreign nationality who have resided at least one more year in Iran immediately after reaching the full age of 18; in other cases their 93 naturalization as Iranian subjects will be subject to the stipulations for Iranian naturalization laid down by the law.
6 - Every woman of foreign nationality who marries an Iranian husband.
7- Every foreign n who has obtained Iranian nationality Note - Children born of foreign diplomatic and consular representatives are not affected by Clause 4 and 5 of this Article.

i told my friend i wont reply to you anymore but one more thing. being illiterate in writing doesnt mean you cant communicate in persian you dumb ****. you think all those soldiers who couldnt write were talking in what language ? gorilla language ?

you got exposed madarjende khaarkosde. i am out of this.
you think why there was platoons from one province
 
.
the problem is one person here say if you don't knew persian language you are not iranian
we say 93% of iranian are literate .that mean 7% illiterate .the question is what we consider literacy ?many of our elderly literate only learned alphabet to read Quran , and can 't understand newspapers. are they not Iranian ? are they not Literate ? On other hand A tajik or Afghan will understand and talk persian is he considered Iranian ?

section 976 of Iran Civil Code state who is Iranian and believe me nowhere in it it's stated that you must speak persian to be considered an Iranian.
https://www.wipo.int/edocs/lexdocs/laws/en/ir/ir009en.pdf



you think why there was platoons from one province
in my opinion a tajik in dushanbe speaking persian is as much persian as someone in shiraz or esfahan.
thats not the issue. the issue here is that some people claim that most of martyrs couldnt speak farsi. probably the illiterates couldnt write persian, yes. but verbally they could and did unless that person was living in caves or extremely remote villages that has not been seen or touched by any farsi zaban. i doubt such villages even exist and if they exist then its due to lack of any connection in terms of culture or infrastructure.
you are mixing writing with verbal farsi. even the most illiterate person in iran can speak farsi. wtf, this is no brainer.

if you man enough ore even an iranian , you prove me wrong . you are not Iranian and you have never been to Iran as you don't knew anything about Iran


because you have the missconception that an Iranian is a Parsi. no he may be kurd , he maybe lor , he maybe Baluch , he maybe Azeri , he maybe Arab , he maybe Gilak or perhaps a Parsi
zer nazan baba, who says you are even a iranian ? you are probably a zionist spy, who knows ?
no dumbass, i never claimed a iranian is only a iranian if he is a ''parsi''. what the hell does that even mean ?
i claimed to you and other illiterate asses here that there are no cases of ''martyrs who couldnt speak farsi'' LOL.. in what language they communicated then? with the base, soldiers, frontline people ?
just a few questions like that breaks down your whole fucked up and time wasting nonsense.
man this discussion is really time wasting and useless. see ya.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom