Last edited by a moderator:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
When @dabong1 mentioned about Khalistan in his POST, I wanted to know his POV on Current Khalistan Movement and asked questions from him. Further, I shared understanding of other Pakistani Members, including you. However, your eyes could not read my POST and you are again back with your GIBBERISH.
1. In 1947, WEST/EAST PAKISTAN were BORN mainly for MUSLIMS, so that they can LIVE PEACEFULLY. However, WORLD knows the deeds of WEST PAKISTAN which lead to creation of BANGLADESH.
When Pakistani Army surrendered to INDIA in 1971, then where were your CHITTARS?
3. Everyday US violates SOVEREIGNTY of your country as if it is a Childs play and kills scores of your citizens, then where were your CHITTARS?
4.US KILLED Pakistani Army PERSONNEL and Pakistan didnt do jack, then where were your CHITTARS?
5.US citizen Kills Pakistanis and Pakistan allows him to leave for US, then where were your CHITTARS?
6. When US marines hovered near your army headquarters, killed OBL and took his body safely with them, then where were your CHITTARS?
7. Everyday Pakistanis are killing each other in Bomb Lasts and Sectarian Violence, then where were your CHITTARS?
8.When Taliban Beheads your Soldiers, then where were your CHITTARS?
MILITANTS were GUNNED DOWN and MILITANCY in Punjab was HAULTED . Currently, Punjab is one of India's most PROSPEROUS and PEACEFUL STATE and SIKHS ARE AMONGST THE WEALTHIEST COMMUNITIES IN INDIA. Sikhs have integrated in India and world has moved to July 2013. Our current prime minister from 9 years is Sikh Dr. Manmohan Singh, our chief economy advisor is Sikh Montek Singh Ahluwalia and our army chief is Sikh Bikram Singh. However, some Pakistanis are still leaving in 1980s.
@dabong1, have the original conditions for a plebiscite met? if yes then there will be one, and if no then there will not be one.
@dabong1 According to OUR CONSTITUTION, we held Elections in Jammu and Kashmir. You can view the result by visiting the below link:
Omar Abdullah to take oath as J&K CM before Jan 6 : Elections 2008: Jammu and Kashmir, News - India Today
We will hold the referendum as soon as you fulfill the first condition for that i.e. Pakistan's withdrawal from Pakistani Kashmir. Do that, and then talk about referendum.
And by the way, the notion of a referendum is now outdated, because Pakistan pumped in non Kashmiri Pakistanis (Punjabis, Sindhis etc) into Kashmir all these years. Send them all back and then talk about a referendum.
As opposed to that, India gave special privileges to Kashmiris that no non Kashmiri can settle in Indian Kashmir. Other than the horrible exodus of Kashmiri pundits by Islamic militants, no ethnic changes happened in Indian Kashmir. So if a referendum is held across Kashmir today, in Pakistani Kashmir it will be Punjabis and Sindhis voting, not Kashmiris. We kept our promise to Kashmiris, you didn't.
If you want referendum, fulfill the first condition - withdraw all Pakistani forces from Pakistani Kashmir, and hold a referendum under UN mandate. What are you so afraid of, why aren't you doing it?
Its calls for non kashmiris to leave and that pakistan can leave a force to keep the security until the results of the election are made......we did that decades ago but you instead of reproaching increased your force.
I have a question for you. Why doesn't Pakistan take AKASI CHIN back? Dont you think, in future, it will help in resolving Kashmir Issue, as third country will be out of it? I also fail to understand, why PAKISTANI AND INDIAN KASHMIRI Freedom Fighters doesn't raise the issue of AKASI CHIN, Dont THEY LOVE IT AND CONSIDER IT AS LEGITIMATE PART OF KASHMIR???
This is what I was trying to Convey, Well keep on Running in Vicious Circle in which we are running from 65 Years with no Result. You send them; we will kill them and dump them in unmarked graves.
At the moment, Uncle SAM COMPLETLEY Withdrawing from AFGHANISTAN is mere Prediction JITNE MUH UTNI BAATEIN. I recently saw Predications of Many Nostradamus from Pakistan going wrong on PDF. My Best wishes are with you but still ILL RATHER WAIT AND WATCH.
WE DONT NEED UKS AID
Look who is talking about giving aid
SIKH COMMUNITY IS ONE OF THE WEALTHIEST COMMUNITIES IN INDIA. THEREFORE, WE DONT REQUIRE $$$. MY COMMENT WAS ONLY SPECIFIC TO KHALISTAN PIPE DREAM MOVEMENT.
So if someones point of view is not the same as your its "GIBBERISH".
Indias invasion of west pakistan led to the creation of bangladesh.
Pakistan gave permission to the US to attack targets in the tribal region.......no violation of SOVEREIGNTY.
Well we closed there land routes and attacked the US forces in Afghanistan using the taliban.
The US paid compensation and the families of the dead dropped the case.
Just like the drone attacks where denied by pakistan as anything to do with them turned to be false, we will see in the near future evidence of pakistan involvment in the killing of OBL.
Coming from an indian its laughable at the least.
We attack indian interests in Afghanistan......The TTP are basically your guys and once the US cover is removed they wont last long.......the TTP will vanish from pakistan and you indians will vanish from Afghanistan.
Well first of all lets get this right...... sikhs are classed as a sub division of the hindus according to the indian consitution and its strange how you miss out on the massacre of sikhs and the desecration of your golden temple.
And according to the international community they mean as much as saddams election did in iraq.
Condition where met years ago.
Only kashmir residents are allowed to vote in elections in AJK.......at least do some basic homework before you start ranting the indian media line.
The same in AJK......non residents are not allowed to buy land-vote ect.........The indians changed the demographics of jammu by killing the muslims and settling hindus there, you tried to do the same in the valley but where chased out by the fighters.
Sad what has happened to the kashmiri hindus but notthing compared to the million+ kashmiri muslims made refugees.
We had a border agreement with the chinese and swapped territory to there was a more natural border.We actually ended up with more terrority and did not end up with a border dispute with the chinese by being stubborn about keeping british made borders that where there to lead to conflict, a bit like what happening with the indian sand the chinese now.
I think you will find that its mostly innocent villagers you indians kill and stage encounters that are buried in unmarked graves.
You fail to mention the prediction that the taliban will not be destroyed but will get stronger every year and come back.
The real "pipedream" is that you indians think kashmir is part of india.
I've decided that I am not going to Discuss Kashmir Issue. However, we are debating on it from almost a month. That is why I am replying you...
The same International Community says many Rosy things about State of Freedom in Azad Kashmir. Do you take it as a Nectar or as Constipated Conspiracy Theories??? .It's courtesy of Islamic Terrorism they don't pay heed towards Kashmir Issue
Question1.Did the Government of Pakistan removed its forces from the State of Kashmir as per UN Resolution of 1948?
[/QUOTE]2.The Government of Pakistan will use its best endeavour to secure the withdrawal from the State of Jammu and Kashmir of tribesmen and Pakistan nationals ..
Question 2.So, The UN agreed that pashtun tribal who were not a part of Kashmir were fighting along with army regulars you agree?
Question 3.When the UN commission decided that Indian forces are to be kept to maintain minimum law and order did Pakistan vacate *** as per instructions of the United Nations?
4..When the Commission shall have notified the Government of India that the tribesmen and Pakistan nationals referred to in Part II A 2 hereof have withdrawn
Question4. Has Pakistan notified the UN or Party to dispute India about tribesmen and Pakistani nationals withdrawing from Kashmir?.
IF PAKISTAN MET THESE CONDITIONS PROVIDE THE PROOF
Apparently, not as the tribesmen and Pakistan nationals never Withdrew, if they did...Provide an INTERNATIONAL SOURCE........at least do some basic homework before you start ranting the Pakistani media line.
I've answered the Bold part above and seeking answer from you.... Any International source for the Remaining RANT . Indeed what happened to Kashmiri is sad and Pakistan is equally Responsible for it.
How can one sign agreement for the Part of Land which is disputed Internationally. I've read the Pak-china Border agreement and apparently, the FREEDOM FIGHTERS TOO. That is why they don't Shed there Blood for Aksai Chin .
India is always willing to settle the Kashmir issue, as per the WILL of people of Jammu and Kashmir and UN Resolution Guidelines..That is why it didn't divide Jammu and Kashmir Like the Pakistan did i.e G & B and gave separate Autonomy to Leh and Ladakh.......
Humko maloom hai jannat ki haqueeqat, par, dil ke behlane ko ghalib, yeh khayal accha hai
Apparently, its other way around...It;s mostly Pakistani Non State Actors aka...... are Killed by Indian Army and get dumped into unmarked graves....
I don't believe in Predictions and this is what I mentioned about your Taliabni in my previous post which you didn't address:
Where they were before USA came? Fighting India, or their own people?
Anyway, send your worst. All the Lashkars, Mujahideens, Talibs and other primitive lunatics will be sent to the same unmarked graves that their predecessors went to. India will not tolerate their nonsense, because they won't find sympathizers in India, like they do in Pakistan (you, for example).
The Pakistani army itself, with all its tanks and artillery and air support cannot challenge Indias might.
Your bearded gunmen cannot do much either. I know it hurts to hear this, but it is true. Just because they have a beard and a Kalashnikov and a medieval ideology, does not mean that they can do jack against a stable, pluralistic nation like India with a professional military and police.
Even your Pakistani army cannot dream to take anything from India,
so your bearded lunatics won't dream to dream. "Let America leave, then we will declare victory and conquer India" might be the latest motivational pamphlets the talibs distribute, while hiding in their caves until America leaves. Such threats may scare a rabbit.
So from pakistan wanting a just resolution on kashmir you take to the extreme "Pakistan wants to conquer India".
Exactly, We think other way around....
What confidence you show......why don't we put it to the Kashmirs and see what they want?.....thought not
PS. please stop with color coding-smileys..........
When i talk of "International Community" i refer to the UN in specific, The UN resolutions are still there.
Yes
so your bearded lunatics won't dream to dream. "Let America leave, then we will declare victory and conquer India" might be the latest motivational pamphlets the talibs distribute, while hiding in their caves until America leaves. Such threats may scare a rabbit.[/COLOR]
So from pakistan wanting a just resolution on kashmir you take to the extreme "Pakistan wants to conquer India".
What confidence you show......why don't we put it to the Kashmirs and see what they want?.....thought not
PS. please stop with color coding-smileys..........
PART II
You cannot get it no matter what you do.
Why are you destroying your country for this state?
Your country was split apart,
Your country got its cover blown after 1999.
You're still struggling from WOT which indirectly has a hand of those elements that were against us. It has trashed your economy and your country.
Daily your nationals are dying of bomb blasts and attacks in different parts despite all being of the same religion that you claim so much in unity's fervour.
What have you gained from attacking us?
What is all this for?
Have you even looked at the roadmap of where these generals are taking your country into?
Their power remains as long as you point your fingers at us.
Don't go down this way and destroy yourself using your own people.
@dabong1 in Post # 52 you answered this in YES: "Question1.Did the Government of Pakistan removed its forces from the State of Kashmir as per UN Resolution of 1948?"
Would you be Kind Enough to Provide an International Source??
@dabong1 After reading the Resolution and having clear understanding on it, I posted it. Instead of playing with words, please provide answer to the following:
PART II: TRUCE AGREEMENT
1. (l) As the presence of troops of Pakistan in the territory of the State of Jammu and Kashmir constitutes a material change in the situation since it was represented by the Government of Pakistan before the Security Council, the Government of Pakistan agrees to withdraw its troops from that State.
In POST # 52, You said Pakistan removed its forces from the State of Kashmir as per UN Resolution of 1948
Please provide International Source to PROVE IT.
2. The Government of Pakistan will use its best endeavour to secure the withdrawal from the State of Jammu and Kashmir of tribesmen and Pakistani nationals not normally resident therein who have entered the State for the purpose of fighting.
Please Provide an International Source to Prove that Tribesman and Pakistani withdrew.
You provide me with proof that they have not......maybe some international source.