India's per capita income rises 7.4% to Rs 93,293

[Nilgiri]

Dont need to name calling stupid. That will not increase your per capita. You think bd statistics dont take into account of all the factor?

When your vedic growth is busted you started dancing like headless chicken.

So lets see the BD published data like MOSPI has produced for India in their provisional estimate....clearly listing GNP, GDP, NNI etc. I could only find the GDP data from the 2014/15 which I already posted....which clearly correlates with the IMF estimate for the same period.

And yes you are very stupid to talk about something you have no clue about as though you do. A constant bad habit of yours.

Nothing about growth is even being discussed here (so how can it be busted?), we are talking about levels and what they represent as aggregates.

Lets hope BBS people are of higher caliber than you.

My 1.7 trillion was correct at constant price which the original reporter quoted.

Did you seriously apply a current exchange rate to a constant price figure of a non-US country? Such facepalm

 

[TopCat]

So lets see the BD published data like MOSPI has produced for India in their provisional estimate....clearly listing GNP, GDP, NNI etc. I could only find the GDP data from the 2014/15 which I already posted....which clearly correlates with the IMF estimate for the same period.

And yes you are very stupid to talk about something you have no clue about as though you do. A constant bad habit of yours.

Lets hope BBS people are of higher caliber than you.

Dude i am not going to debate with you.
Your govt published a report which clearly stated your per capita income. There is no cofusion in it.

Net national income (NNI) is an economics term used in national income accounting. It can be defined as the net national product (NNP) minus indirect taxes. Net national income encompasses the income of households, businesses, and the government.

There is nothing extra ordinary in NNI and every country take these into account one way or other. Its only India which fuzzed up things to show bigger growth to attract investment. But once a person look deep they will always find out

 

[Nilgiri]

Dude i am not going to debate with you.
Your govt published a report which clearly stated your per capita income. There is no cofusion in it.



There is nothing extra ordinary in NNI and every country take these into account one way or other. Its only India which fuzzed up things to show bigger growth to attract investment. But once a person look deep they will always find out

Tell me when you can find one report produced by BBS or any other authority in BD that has an NNI/NNP figure alongside GNP and GDP.

Put up or shut up.

When comparing between countries it has to be apples to apples, not apples to oranges.

You are just pissed that I have shown your stupidity regarding the different types of "income" that can be calculated for a country....and that you and that other nitwit were comparing apples to oranges.

BTW, no idea why you copied and pasted from google (I guess since you have no understanding):

"Net national income (NNI) is an economics term used in national income accounting. It can be defined as the net national product (NNP) minus indirect taxes. Net national income encompasses the income of households, businesses, and the government."

Thats the difference between product and income.

 

[TopCat]

Tell me when you can find one report produced by BBS or any other authority in BD that has an NNI/NNP figure alongside GNP and GDP.

Put up or shut up.

When comparing between countries it has to be apples to apples, not apples to oranges.

You are just pissed that I have shown your stupidity regarding the different types of "income" that can be calculated for a country....and that you and that other nitwit were comparing apples to oranges.

BTW, no idea why you copied and pasted from google (I guess since you have no understanding):

"Net national income (NNI) is an economics term used in national income accounting. It can be defined as the net national product (NNP) minus indirect taxes. Net national income encompasses the income of households, businesses, and the government."

Thats the difference between product and income.

You dont have to worry about bd per capita, accept the per capita of India published by your Avatar Modi Ji...

 

[LA se Karachi]

Wow you are a complete idiot....VERIFIED.

Net national income relative to Gross national income has no extra "foreign/domestic" component, both include net income from abroad (hence the word national and not domestic).

Net national income takes into effect depreciation (i.e spending/investment for depreciation is not included in Net national but it is included for Gross).

NNP/NNI will thus always be smaller than GNP/GNI (or maybe BD is some magical country where nothing depreciates and needs to be replenished).

The external income/investment from abroad is the difference between GDP and GNP/GNI stupid.

Simply put GDP is production within a country's boundary. GNP is production by a country's citizens (wherever their location). NNP ignores depreciation replenishment of GNP.

You can similarly have Net Domestic Product (which would be GDP taking into account depreciation of stocks/assets).

@Khan_21 @LA se Karachi @Bilal9 can you guys please back me up here. I feel I'm shedding grey matter talking to this nitwit.

There you go again confusing the issue with facts. How dare you. Are you obsessed with Bangladesh or something?

Kudos to you for delving into specifics and showing the differences between the various figures. I would have been too lazy. And all of that for this. I admire your persistence. It's a much needed refreshment on this forum.

This is what we had to deal with. You can never convince some of them. Everything you say to them is wrong; facts be damned.

 

[TopCat]

There you go again confusing the issue with facts. How dare you. Are you obsessed with Bangladesh or something?

Kudos to you for delving into specifics and showing the differences between the various figures. I would have been too lazy. And all of that for this. I admire your persistence. It's a much needed refreshment on this forum.

This is what we had to deal with. You can never convince some of them. Everything you say to them is wrong; facts be damned.

You the man....

 

[punit]

Finally the cat jumped out of the bag.Indian per-capita income is 74 dollar less than BD. Bangladesh have per capita income 1466 dollar in 2016. I always suspected, BD crossed India in per-capita income already,now Indian govt. is conforming statistically.I wonder, what has to say the Indian big mouth brigade here?

still pole vaulters are jumping in india braving BSF bullets !

 

[Nilgiri]

You dont have to worry about bd per capita, accept the per capita of India published by your Avatar Modi Ji...

I do accept it. NNI has its utility as does GNI and GDP. But its important to know how they are different to know this utility and only compare apples to apples.

But of course low-patent, low-science people will think NNI = GDP = GNI (apples, oranges and pears are all the same!) and also use recent exchange rates for direct conversion constant price figures from a different base year.....totally not realising that there is an inflation/exchange rate correlation factor (if they even know what that means, which is pretty doubtful).

There you go again confusing the issue with facts. How dare you. Are you obsessed with Bangladesh or something?

Kudos to you for delving into specifics and showing the differences between the various figures. I would have been too lazy. And all of that for this. I admire your persistence. It's a much needed refreshment on this forum.

This is what we had to deal with. You can never convince some of them. Everything you say to them is wrong; facts be damned.

It was a bit of a refresher for me too, and I hope others that are interested will learn a few differences in the terminologies.

I had a bit of a retro trip back to my high school economics when I asked the teacher why we dont use NNP/NNI instead of gross since its obviously better (I mean spending for depreciation is not really illustrative of quality income/consumption), and he said its pretty much the same reason why say the US still uses the imperial system instead of metric.....everyone gets used to one thing and it sticks as the convention.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

still pole vaulters are jumping in india braving BSF bullets !

95 percent of BSF bullet received by the cattle smugglers, they go to India to collect cow and return BD, not to live in your open toilet country.

 

[TopCat]

95 percent of BSF bullet received by the cattle smugglers, they go to India to collect cow and return BD, not to live in your open toilet country.

I think we should still let the Indian live in la la land.... No matter how much they try to fuzz the numbers, the truth will prevail.

And this idiot from India and a flase flagger @LA se Karachi think BD does not calculate NNI and its superpower India which is a special case in the world which calculated NNI.

To bust that myth, here is the 2014-15 data, I could not get the 2015-16. Dont make mistake we still using 2005-06 base year.

http://www.bbs.gov.bd/WebTestApplication/userfiles/Image/GDP/GDP_2014-15_Final.pdf

 

[Bilal9]

Guys 'open toilet' or not - one has to admit that there is a lot that is positive to emulate from India. There are talents and scientists in India too - just like everywhere else (including in Pakistan).

Our motherland, the land we call Bangladesh has always been open to better ideas, just look at our language. We can adopt the best of what India has to offer - or the best of Pakistan.

Not everyone in India is a Hindutva chest-beater and hater. And if they are, what is that to us? Let's not emulate or ape close-minded attitudes of others. Spread love (not hate) - you'll get love in return. Our Sufi philosophy teaches this well.

When we call a whole nation names (that alone a neighbor country and whose part we were in the near past) that only shows our horrible negative side. Is this what we want to be known for? Is our heart that narrow?

That is not what us Bangladeshis stand for...we are better than that.

If we earn a few dollars more or less than India, what does it matter?

Let us be better by being better human beings and not money, or material things.

That is the type of competition we want in this world.

 

[Nilgiri]

Guys 'open toilet' or not - one has to admit that there is a lot that is positive to emulate from India. There are talents and scientists in India too - just like everywhere else (including in Pakistan).

Our motherland, the land we call Bangladesh has always been open to better ideas, just look at our language. We can adopt the best of what India has to offer - or the best of Pakistan.

Not everyone in India is a Hindutva chest-beater and hater. And if they are, what is that to us? Let's not emulate or ape close-minded attitudes of others. Spread love (not hate) - you'll get love in return. Our Sufi philosophy teaches this well.

When we call a whole nation names (that alone a neighbor country and whose part we were in the near past) that only shows our horrible negative side. Is this what we want to be known for? Is our heart that narrow?

That is not what us Bangladeshis stand for...we are better than that.

If we earn a few dollars more or less than India, what does it matter?

Let us be better by being better human beings and not money, or material things.

That is the type of competition we want in this world.

Can we just make you the BD section mod? It would really help this forum I think.

@waz @WAJsal

 

[LA se Karachi]

I think we should still let the Indian live in la la land.... No matter how much they try to fuzz the numbers, the truth will prevail.

And this idiot from India and a flase flagger @LA se Karachi think BD does not calculate NNI and its superpower India which is a special case in the world which calculated NNI.

To bust that myth, here is the 2014-15 data, I could not get the 2015-16. Dont make mistake we still using 2005-06 base year.

http://www.bbs.gov.bd/WebTestApplication/userfiles/Image/GDP/GDP_2014-15_Final.pdf

False flagger? I'm Pakistani-American.

 

[Nilgiri]

False flagger? I'm Pakistani-American.

He has to distract from:

a) its the exact same report link I gave earlier (with the same malware warning courtesy of BD LDC status that @alaungphaya pointed out regarding their router password hack millions of dollar theft)

b) The report has absolutely no mention of NNI/NNP. No depreciation component anywhere, zilch.

Though it is interesting to note the definite positive difference between GNI and GDP for BD. Looks like BD is very reliant on its overseas diaspora income wise compared to India (where the difference is actually negative...i.e GDP is higher than GNI).

But still laughable he thinks you are a false flagger or whatever

 

[LA se Karachi]

It was a bit of a refresher for me too, and I hope others that are interested will learn a few differences in the terminologies.

I had a bit of a retro trip back to my high school economics when I asked the teacher why we dont use NNP/NNI instead of gross since its obviously better (I mean spending for depreciation is not really illustrative of quality income/consumption), and he said its pretty much the same reason why say the US still uses the imperial system instead of metric.....everyone gets used to one thing and it sticks as the convention.

It was for me too. I doubt most of the other people posting on this thread tried to understand what you were saying though. The only term I know off the top of my head, economically speaking, is GDP. The last time I payed attention to NNP, I must have been in college.

GNP vs NNP is an interesting topic. But keep in mind that different countries and firms use different rates of depreciation. This creates problems.

As an accountant, we often find the average payment of something over time (like rent), so that we can expense it at the same amount each month, and we start "expense-ing" when the business starts operations, regardless of when we begin paying. We do this because if we were to expense the exact payment amount, exactly when we payed, it would distort the financials of the firm a bit for reasons unrelated to business itself. Business activity might not have changed, but expenses would, for reasons unrelated to business. While the concept is a bit different, adjusting for depreciation may make the NNP amount for country fluctuate due to depreciation (reasons unrelated to economic activity itself), I believe. It could distort comparisons between years.

And most importantly, because of the differences between countries when it comes to calculating depreciation, it would make them more difficult to compare to each other.

He has to distract from:

a) its the exact same report link I gave earlier (with the same malware warning courtesy of BD LDC status that @alaungphaya pointed out regarding their router password hack millions of dollar theft)

LOL

b) The report has absolutely no mention of NNI/NNP. No depreciation component anywhere, zilch.

Even if it did, could he compare it to India or other countries? He should make comparisons within a single source. Unless of course a source that publishes NNI/NNP amounts by country also used the same figures in this report for their own Bangladesh NNI/NNP figures, allowing for a comparison.

But still laughable he thinks you are a false flagger or whatever

I wonder what country he thinks I'm from exactly.