What's new

Indian Tricolor projected on the Matterhorn in Swiss Alps

Simply can change poverty measurement norms and definitions for things like "malnutrition"....they vary from country to country, UN, GHI, UNESCO, UNICEF all acknowledge that.

So when you do broadband measurement of poverty:

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/indi...o-lead-world-bank.598776/page-4#post-11129373

For south asia the MPI scores (headcount * intensity) are (lower is better):

India = 0.121 (2015-2016)

Bangladesh = 0.194 (2014)

Pakistan = 0.228 (2012-2013)

By pure headcount only (during the respective survey years):

India = 27.5% = 364 million people

Bangladesh = 41.07% = 66 million people

Pakistan = 43.9% = 80 million people


Seems "twice more poverty" is flipped around when you actually measure it properly with enough scope.

Or when you do concise measurement of it (there is no disputing a dead child, unless you become a totalitarian state and can hide even that too):

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.IMRT.IN?locations=IN-PK

Can one really credibly attack India on these things, while being 15 years behind it on infant mortality? What would the infant mortality being this behind suggest about the actual malnutrition (when compared on hypothetical equivalent basis) of the countries too?

They just hate this reality surfacing more and more each year, and what it means to the precious hollow ego they built up and nurtured this long.
Right on the next page:

That's MPI indeed which uses a broader concept of poverty than income and wealth alone.

http://www.pk.undp.org/content/paki...istanis-live-in-multidimensional-poverty.html

But if its income and wealth alone the figures are very different.


Pakistan as per the world bank 2015 the MPI percentage is 24.3% on 197,000,000 people (2017)

https://data.worldbank.org/country/pakistan

There's another thread running on it;'

top_image_1-png.535329


Pakistan doesn't have 80 million people in poverty as they would have been on this data from the World Bank.
 
.
Right on the next page:

Yes I said broadband for reason.

Means not much to the poor person if he earns 2 dollars instead of 1 dollar of another poor person in another country.....if the 2 dollars buys/achieves less well-being for him compared to the 1 dollar of the other guy.

Comparing "income poverty" now gets you ridiculously low numbers anyway for most developing countries (in Asia):

https://worldpoverty.io/

The standard for (absolute) income poverty is largely irrelevant for even developing countries now, we must move onto tackling more persistent relative poverty (that materialise in such things as health, education and sustainable livelihood/skills)...and set standards there.
 
.
Yes I said broadband for reason.

Means not much to the poor person if he earns 2 dollars instead of 1 dollar of another poor person in another country.....if the 2 dollars buys/achieves less well-being for him compared to the 1 dollar of the other guy.

Comparing "income poverty" now gets you ridiculously low numbers anyway for most developing countries (in Asia):

https://worldpoverty.io/

The standard for (absolute) income poverty is largely irrelevant for even developing countries now, we must move onto tackling more persistent relative poverty (that materialise in such things as health, education and sustainable livelihood/skills)...and set standards there.
Whats the definition of poverty in india? 1.20 dollars?
 
. . . . . . . .
Whats the definition of poverty in india? 1.20 dollars?

There are a fair few measures, estimates and standards (mix of income and consumption based) if you are interested:

https://www.drishtiias.com/to-the-points/paper3/poverty-estimation-in-india

The World bank one (in use internationally for absolute income poverty) is 1.90 PPP per day (though consumption is somewhat intrinsically plugged into this given its PPP):

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...ut-in-number-of-poor/articleshow/67705787.cms

I would say its out of date conceptually now for the region.

MPI as mentioned before is the one I tend to follow now, since it looks at larger scale relative poverty too rather than just income and consumption:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/niallm...poverty-in-a-decade-infographic/#57a42fbb2284
 
.
You sound like open defecation is unknown in Pakiastan when in fact 49 million of you defecate outside slums where you live.

"
More than 40m Pakistanis defecate openly: Unicef"

Dawn
Ahhhhh. Ok.

LOL We are more than 3T $ econimy and with 550 Billion in forex reservation. You think we cann't live without aid.

You know we got 4 billion dollors of aid last year.
And bought mobile phones from China worth 8 billion dollars. Size dekh ke bat karo.


It sounds so hallow when Pakistan's Human Development Index is 22 position below India.
So if you can live without aid....why dont you? Surely you would like that money to go to deserving people.... oh the indian bullshit tamasha.
3 Trillion economy....didnt your numbers come into questions recently that for years you commerce has done nothing but lie.
My dear 3T economy and still poor in the open...stop talking sh1t....pun intended

Size edkh ke bat karo....BBC talked about your size. Standard condom too big for an indian. That's size? Why are you taking aid from china. You hate then and then beg from them? That's just one example of BS

Talking to you is like talking to a frog.
 
.
I will bet these are non-muslims.
In the last 70 years you have for all practical purposes wiped out all non-muslims.

India is the only country in South Asia which has GROWN its minorities by hundreds of millions.The only country where the percentage of minorities has INCREASED. If India was as bad as the fantasists here endlessly talk about, then they would have walked across borders as they have in Iraq Iran Syria Libya Egypt Sudan etc etc etc.
Notice the ONLY places Muslim's run from are other Muslim countries, and they ALL want to end up in non-muslim countries.
That's the real state of Muslim run countries and their, tolerance of minorities.
 
. .
People like you remind me of the sh!tty BJP video in which a gora "migrates" to India. And becomes a beggar.
India isn't some tiny insignificant debt ridden country.
It's the most populous country and leader of the developing world. We don't need to hire Goras for PR purpose.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom