Indian Punjab is Self Destructing....Unlike Pakistan's Punjab

[KrimesKaster]

View attachment 814327

just two-3 cites of Central P (in a area with dozen more cites) or areas adjoining IP in PP have more GDP than entire state, this is heartland


Not that you ganga monkey should be talking about Punjab related anything

Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah.
No facts? Whats more to expect from 67% literate folks!

 

[Maula Jatt]

Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah.
No facts? Whats more to expect from 67% literate folks!

you can certainly expect better things than people with Iq 72 which is pretty much considered near retardation levels in most countries
So most countries in the world will actually consider average indian as near-retarted

 

[KrimesKaster]

you can certainly expect better things than people with Iq 72 which is pretty much considered near retardation levels in most countries
So most countries in the world will actually consider average indian as near-retarted

Whats the source of this 72 IQ claim? Your arse? Thats not good enough.

BTW, with 72 IQ if India has better economy, better health outcomes and better literacy rate than your beloved Pakistan and even Punjab, what does it tell you about Pakistan or even Pakistan Punjab?

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

Pak's Punjab rules....

India's Punjab serves....

Better to rule in the Heaven than to serve in the Hell....

 

[M. Sarmad]

Of course you lot were equally disgusted with the Afghans when they were saving your collective butts from the Sikh and Maratha menace

Nadir Shah Irani, Ahmed Shah Afghani, and Marathas etc were all alien marauders on our lands. ... A Muslim tyrant / invader is no better than a Hindu or Sikh tyrant .

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

Lol. Some posts here are laughable.

Firstly, I would like to inform the members here that not all analysis is based on religion. So if you are linking economics with religion, have some valid reason else its just communalism.


Anyway, Punjab growth stagnated since Punjab is essentially agriculture driven. During the green revolution, Punjab farmers went overboard with the reforms, which now has downsides. But its nothing like what is being portrayed here, Indian Punjab has still higher per capita GDP than Pakistani Punjab. And if you dont believe statistics for whatever reason, just open up google maps and check the sort of development on both sides of the border.

Pakistan cement production will reach 100mt/year in 2024. 80% of that comes from punjab. In 2021 Pakistan manufactured 24 million mobiles, I bet 70% were done in Punjab. IT investments and so on. India punjab on other hand just consume. No one invest there in manufacturing, IT etc and thats not going to change. That will happen only if Khalistan is separate country.

It remind me of west Bengal and Bangladesh situation, as soon as BD got its act together they left west bengal in dust and along with all of India in per capita. Pakistan too for must of its history had higher per capita then India.

 

[Maula Jatt]

Pakistan cement production will reach 100mt/year in 2024. 80% of that comes from punjab. In 2021 Pakistan manufactured 24 million mobiles, I bet 70% were done in Punjab. IT investments and so on. India punjab on other hand just consume. No one invest there in manufacturing, IT etc and thats not going to change.

It remind me of west Bengal and Bangladesh situation, as soon as BD got its act together they left west bengal in dust and along with all of India in per capita. Pakistan too for must of its history had higher per capita then India.

1979(or 70s ish) something richest province in whole subcontinent was PP (like biggest gdp) even though its not located on coast - of course to reach that level once again we as a nation needs to get our act together (especially our port regions, inward areas cant progress without port)

 

[satyamev]

Pak's Punjab rules....

India's Punjab serves....

Better to rule in the Heaven than to serve in the Hell....

how are you doing in usa ? amongst 1st class citizen or 2nd class ?
Option to return to Pakistan and rule in heaven , haha.

The video is pretty dead on. The victim mentality is also strong in punjab , especially some section of sikhs.
During early 90s , mohali in Punjab was amongst the first in India to hop on the electronics bandwagon. Much before Hyderabad.
But lack of focus, local corruption and unable to attract talent, its withered away.
Bangalore and Hyderabad had nothing on chandigarh (sister city of mohali) , wrt quality of life , in the 90s.

 

[.King.]

Pakistan cement production will reach 100mt/year in 2024. 80% of that comes from punjab. In 2021 Pakistan manufactured 24 million mobiles, I bet 70% were done in Punjab. IT investments and so on. India punjab on other hand just consume. No one invest there in manufacturing, IT etc and thats not going to change. That will happen only if Khalistan is separate country.

It remind me of west Bengal and Bangladesh situation, as soon as BD got its act together they left west bengal in dust and along with all of India in per capita. Pakistan too for must of its history had higher per capita then India.

If Khalistan is ever made, It will include most of Pakistani Punjab. All the holy sites are there.

Anyway, your figures are just made up. No source for how you decided that there was no investement in punjab. I gave figures, your per capita in punjab is 1.7k$, here its over 2k$. One member accepted, that since some parts of pakistani Punjab were backward, they brought the rest down. Sure, but it still means you are wrong her.

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

If Khalistan is ever made, It will include most of Pakistani Punjab. All the holy sites are there.

Anyway, your figures are just made up. No source for how you decided that there was no investement in punjab. I gave figures, your per capita in punjab is 1.7k$, here its over 2k$. One member accepted, that since some parts of pakistani Punjab were backward, they brought the rest down. Sure, but it still means you are wrong her.

Thats not how countries are made. Their best bet is making independent Khalistan/east Punjab where they form majority.

Pakistan GDP as of 2020-21 FY, $347b. Considering PP share 60% of GDP, it means $210b or $1900 per capita for Pak Punjab. Thats despite the fact our GDP toke a beating in nominal $ terms because of huge devaluation few years ago under IMF program. Also not everything is GDP. See how much Indian punjab make cars, mobiles, cement production, etc

Look how Indian IT boom helped Indian Punjab.

$500m exports vs $8b for Haryana and $6b for UP. Are they more competent then punjabis? These haryanvis now need quota system to get jobs in Haryana. Its all thanks to Indian state ignoring punjab on purpose. All the FDI is directed towards certain states.

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

"The exports from Punjab reached a figure of US$ 5.8 billion in 2017-18, down from exports valued at US$ 7.1 billion in 2013-14, registering a negave AAGR of 4.4%, during this period."

Its not just IT, all of exports are down. While India exports of goods and services experienced boom in last decade.

https://www.eximbankindia.in/Assets/pdf/research-on-states/Punjab.pdf

 

[satyamev]

Indian PDF members try to scare Pakistanis by saying this. Pakistani Punjab has 4 times higher population than Indian Punjab. Are Sikhs that they would want to live in Muslim majority country? Agar khalistan main Pakistani Punjab shamil karkay ussay Muslim majority banana ha to khalistan ka faida?

probably talking about land transfer again. For sikhs Lahore has a special place in their hearts. It was the capital of the sikh empire.
I don't see the sikhs in Punjab specifically asking for a khalistan at the moment, seeing the type of leaders they have in the present state elections. Imagine sidhu the kapil sharma show guy becoming the PM of khalistan. Too much infighting and ego in Punjab politics. They don't think about their state at all. All religious and identity politics in the 21st century.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Punjabi here as well. I don't agree with both of you and i am not alone.

Being a punjabi, I don’t even consider Lahoris punjabi, so how do you expect me to relate to sikhs and indian punjab?

 

[Maula Jatt]

Being a punjabi, I don’t even consider Lahoris punjabi, so how do you expect me to relate to sikhs and indian punjab?

put some respect on people from undroon shehr
We are pure and even we don't consider outside undroon Lahore- Lahore Punjab...

 

[Vapnope]

Being a punjabi, I don’t even consider Lahoris punjabi, so how do you expect me to relate to sikhs and indian punjab?

I don't know how to react to this statement. It is beyond silly.