Indian Muslims upset after PM Modi sends greetings to Muslims

[Ehsan]

Indian Muslims upset after PM Modi sends greetings to Muslims | Rabwah Times

In an odd move Indian Muslim leaders have criticized Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi for sending greetings to Muslims.

In a letter written on 21st December 2015 Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi praised Ahmadiyya Muslim Community for its religious tolerance and universal brotherhood. He wished success to ‘Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya Centenary’ celebrations which are taking place in Qadian this month. Thousands of Pakistani Ahmadis are also taking part in the celebrations.

In his letter PM Modi said:

“It is a matter of pleasure to know that Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya Centenary will be celebrated at its headquarters Qadian Dist. Gurdaspur, Punjab and a souvenir is being published to mark the occasion. I wish success to the centenary celebration”.

Indian Muslim leaders which include Member of the Indian Legislative Council (MLC) have criticized Modi for congratulating the Ahmadiyya Muslims. Hafiz Peer Shabbir Ahmed, MLC and President of Jamiat Ulama Telangana and Andhra Pradesh in a statement said:

“This has hurt the sentiments of Indian Muslims. If Modi thinks Ahmadiyya’s are Muslims then he has to correct himself. Ahmadiyya’s are not Muslims and it is the decision of Muslims world over”

Hafiz Shabbir (MLC) added:

“This is strange. In the last two years Prime Minister Modi has never issued any congratulatory message to Muslims on the occasion of Eid and other Muslim festivals. But, he has sent a letter wishing success to Ahmadiyya community”

India has a huge Ahmadiyya Muslim population which is spread across Kerala, Rajasthan, Odisha, Haryana, Bihar, Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, and in Qadian, Punjab.

Mainstream Muslims consider Ahmadiyya Muslims to be heretics and in neighboring Pakistan they were declared non-Muslim in 1974, However under Indian Law the Ahmadis are regarded as Muslims.

In April this year a delegation from Ahmadiyya Muslim Community also met with PM Modi in New Delhi.

 

[jung41]

If they practise muslim religion and respect holy quran they why are they not considered muslims?

 

[Jai Bharat]

If they practise muslim religion and respect holy quran they why are they not considered muslims?

They aren't violent enough like the Sunnis that attack them to be considered as Muslim.

 

[HRK]

If Modi thinks Ahmadiyya’s are Muslims then he has to correct himself. Ahmadiyya’s are not Muslims and it is the decision of Muslims world over”

 

[ranjeet]

Take it or leave it. Ahmadiyyas are Muslims according to Indian Law and If anyone got a problem with it they can move to someplace where their self certified Muslims are in majority.

 

[Nair saab]

Muslims Should stop behaving like Children and emotionally challenged people getting upset on small, remote, non-issues actually on everything going around the world which related or not related to Muslims...

There is world beyond their self-obsession ... and no one in the world gives a Damn about what they think ...


they must sit and think where they are leading their community to... they putting 2 billion muslim population around the world on the path of self destruction...

 

[Super Falcon]

Muslims Should stop behaving like Children and emotionally challenged people getting upset on small, remote, non-issues actually on everything going around the world which related or not related to Muslims...

There is world beyond their self-obsession ... and no one in the world gives a Damn about what they think ...


they must sit and think where they are leading their community to... they putting 2 billion muslim population around the world on the path of self destruction...

Children u act like children we are not stupid if i kill ur kid and sdnd u greeting on diwali how u fell


This modi is mass murderer of muslim in babri masjid whole world knows it and uncle SAM banned him to enter usa do u forget it

And u say we accept greetings of murderet of our community

 

[Xzok0]

not a smart move but who cares what indian muslims think in INDIA certainly not the gov

 

[Nair saab]

Children u act like children we are not stupid if i kill ur kid and sdnd u greeting on diwali how u fell


This modi is mass murderer of muslim in babri masjid whole world knows it and uncle SAM banned him to enter usa do u forget it

And u say we accept greetings of murderet of our community

Perfect I was addressing people like you... get beyond this victim card...

 

[ranjeet]

We do not want greeting from murderer of Muslims.

 

[Xzok0]

Perfect I was addressing people like you... get beyond this victim card...

exactly now show those indian muslims how those childish victims should be treated by real INDIANS

We do not want greeting from murderer of Muslims.

people living in the worlds largest democracy shouldnt complain about being maltreated it makes them seem like victims and it hurts the secular hindu india's sentiments

 

[911]

Is it really possible to denounce other as non-muslims when he considers himself one? What if they do that back to them? Who has copyrights over Islam anyways?

 

[rockstar08]

If they practise muslim religion and respect holy quran they why are they not considered muslims?

Its not as simple as you think
to be a Muslim there is a criteria which one has to fulfill , ISIS and AQ also claimed to be Muslims but we all know what kind and how much they know about Islam ..

 

[Nair saab]

exactly now show those indian muslims how those childish victims should be treated by real INDIANS

We Indians must show those Indian Muslims what that is real muslim's , and what that is to be treated childish so that the Duplicated Indians face the real Indian and the so called Indians face the muslims of all types this must the motto of every common muslims and the real Indian but not the Duplicate Muslims and the original Indians...

 

[dadeechi]

If they practise muslim religion and respect holy quran they why are they not considered muslims?

What I always found interesting is how the oldest religions Judaism and Hinduism have evolved/branched.

Judaism doesn't recognize Christianity
Christianity doesn't recognize Islam and Mormonism
Islam doesn't recognize Ahmadiyyaism

On the other hand Hinduism recognizes and considers Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism as part of Hinduism but these religions consider themselves otherwise.