AUSTERLITZ
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2008
- Messages
- 6,025
- Reaction score
- 175
- Country
- Location
Shivalik class are very capable but it can't considered near about destroyer because it has limited ground attack capability & air defence for self defence not for escort. Talwar class have same power punch as Shivalik with less weight but Shivalik class are upper hand due to one additional rotorcraft, LM2500 gas turbine propulsion, advance combat managdment system, crew friendly etc.
Shivalik class frigrates are made for ASW & anti surface combatant warfare
True,they are primarily ASW and anti surface combatants.But u underestimate their AAW capabilities,shtil-1 is excellent MRSAM and barak-1 is probably world's best QRSAM after aster-15.barak-1 is slightly better than seawolf[the same missile that shot down exocets in falklands].Plus there is ak-630 CIWS.
The shivalik are much more capable than talwars due to additional Helicopter plus layered AAW capability.But its not air defence destroyer.Its multi role platform.