Indian double standard on Kashmir issue. From Kashmir to Junagarh

[Rank]

If I were the PM of India in 1947, I would have allowed Junagarh's accession to Pakistan because that is how all 500 odd princely domain have acceded either to Pakistan or India. Now time passed...as I said move on.



But why this obsession with a tiny patch of land called Kashmir? You lost BD, you forgone development, you build many bombs and given unbridled power to your military that your have become a security state, you created environment for many terror group to inflict thousand cuts on India. now the same snake is biting you. May I ask is it a Muslims thingy just because majority of Kashmiris are Muslims?

Continously listening this BS again and again... the people whom you call "same snake is biting you" is literally non-sense... the snakes which are busy in terrorism inside Pakistan was created by YOU. Established Facts even US commanders and defence secretary officially said not only them on top of it your Monkey aka Yadev kuta bila red handed captured and exposed badly!

 

[Stephen Cohen]

If I were the PM of India in 1947, I would have allowed Junagarh's accession to Pakistan because that is how all 500 odd princely domain have acceded either to Pakistan or India. Now time passed...as I said move on.

It was NOT yours to give away

The Hindus of Junagarh wanted to be with India ; and Indian ARMY fulfilled their wishes

And people of India wanted KASHMIR ; so again Indian Army fulfilled their wish

In matters of territory ; there are NO bloody sentiments ; only power and strength matters

 

[Khan_21]

It was NOT yours to give away

The Hindus of Junagarh wanted to be with India ; and Indian ARMY fulfilled their wishes

And people of India wanted KASHMIR ; so again Indian Army fulfilled their wish

In matters of territory ; there are NO bloody sentiments ; only power and strength matters

And and Half of kashmir and Gilgit baltistan is with us. If you are so powerfull come get it. Oh wait you guys havent tried to get it once in 69 years. Lets test your powers again like we tested it in 2002 and 2008.

 

[Tamilnadu]

http://nation.com.pk/blogs/05-Dec-2...e-a-part-of-pakistan-a-historical-perspective

First read some history then comment

Did you read some history or atleast the link.

 

[dray]

The ruler of Junagarh State signed instrument of accession to Pakistan. The state was taken over by India on religious majority grounds as it's population was pro-India. Compare this to Kashmir and you will see double standard at it's fullest.

What is Kalat? Pakistani double standard, no?

 

[HAIDER]

What is Kalat? Pakistani double standard, no?

no.

 

[dray]

no.

Right, Kashmir acceded to India legally, Kalat was appropriated by Pakistan forcefully.

 

[HAIDER]

Right, Kashmir acceded to India legally, Kalat was appropriated by Pakistan forcefully.

Again no, you need to read the Khan of Kalat decision and Afghan role. But nice try. Again one more Hyderabad occupation and massacre in Hyderabad.

 

[CHD]

India illegally occupied Hyderabad too after it refused to join hindus

 

[jetray]

What is Kalat? Pakistani double standard, no?

True , India refused kalats accession request. It seems pakistan is only interested in aggrandizement of territory rather than looking at whether it can become viable to run a state. They have no concern for the people whatsoever.

 

[HAIDER]

India illegally occupied Hyderabad too after it refused to join hindus

Hyderabad 1948: India's hidden massacre
By Mike Thomson Presenter, Document, Radio 4

In September and October 1948, soon after independence from the British Empire, tens of thousands of people were brutally slaughtered in central India.


At a number of places members of
the armed forces brought out Muslim
adult males... and massacred them
Sunderlal report

http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24159594

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Hyderabad 1948: India's hidden massacre
By Mike Thomson Presenter, Document, Radio 4

In September and October 1948, soon after independence from the British Empire, tens of thousands of people were brutally slaughtered in central India.


At a number of places members of
the armed forces brought out Muslim
adult males... and massacred them
Sunderlal report

http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24159594

How many Hindus are left in Pakistan

We have 17 Crore Muslims in India

 

[dadeechi]

And and Half of kashmir and Gilgit baltistan is with us. If you are so powerfull come get it. Oh wait you guys havent tried to get it once in 69 years. Lets test your powers again like we tested it in 2002 and 2008.

Be assured that when India tries it, there won't be any failed attempts.

 

[jetray]

Hyderabad 1948: India's hidden massacre
By Mike Thomson Presenter, Document, Radio 4

In September and October 1948, soon after independence from the British Empire, tens of thousands of people were brutally slaughtered in central India.


At a number of places members of
the armed forces brought out Muslim
adult males... and massacred them
Sunderlal report

http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24159594

Oh you are welcome to selectively choose what you want.

Members of the powerful Razakar militia, the armed wing of Hyderabad's most powerful Muslim political party, were terrorising many Hindu villagers.

The investigation team also reported, however, that in many other instances the Indian Army had behaved well and protected Muslims.

The backlash was said to have been in response to many years of intimidation and violence against Hindus by the Razakars.

 

[wiseone2]

The ruler of Junagarh State signed instrument of accession to Pakistan. The state was taken over by India on religious majority grounds as it's population was pro-India. Compare this to Kashmir and you will see double standard at it's fullest.

it is a double standard.

it is a minor anomaly compared to partition of punjab and bengal. creation of west & east pakistan was a bigger anomaly too.