Indian Def Minister Rules our Sichen Breakthrough

[third eye]

No withdrawl without authentication & signatures - Thats what has been India's stand all along.

Indian defence minister rules out Siachen breakthrough – The Express Tribune

NEW DELHI: Virtually dismissing overtures made by Pakistan for a peaceful resolution of the Siachen issue, Indian Defence Minister AK Antony on Friday cautioned India against expecting any breakthrough when defence secretaries meet in Islamabad later in June.

Antony said “no dramatic announcement or decision” should be expected, thereby by virtually dismissing any hope that the meeting offered.

“Don’t expect dramatic announcement or decision on an issue which is very very important for us, especially in the context of national security… From one discussion, you can’t expect a dramatic announcement,” Antony said.

Interacting with reporters, Antony said Defence Secretary Shashikant Sharma will explain India’s stand during the talks with Pakistan.

India’s Cabinet Committee on Security met on Thursday and discussed the Siachen issue. The gist was that the stumbling blocks remain the same: authentication of the current military positions of the two sides.

Earlier this year, Pakistan Army Chief Gen Ashfaq Pervaiz Kayani had said there should be a peaceful resolution of the Siachen issue, which had risen hopes that a negotiated settlement to demilitarise the area might be on the anvil. However, India, which had initially welcomed Kayani’s comments, sought authentication of military positions to which Pakistan was opposed to.

During a visit to Siachen in 2005, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had said that the two countries should work to convert the highest battlefield into a mountain of peace.

The Siachen troop withdrawal issue has gained prominence in Pakistan following a massive avalanche which buried an entire Pakistan army forward operating base on April 7, resulting in the death of 129 soldiers and 11 civilian contractors.

 

[SamantK]

And Pakistani posters seems to say that Indian army was forcing the govt to not take any decision on Siachen... Was it possible they were wishing India to follow their example?

 

[third eye]

India unwilling to change stance on Siachen issue | DAWN.COM

India unwilling to change stance on Siachen issue

NEW DELHI: Indian Defence Minister A.K. Antony cautioned on Friday against expecting a breakthrough in the Siachen Glacier talks being held in Islamabad next week.

“Don’t expect dramatic announcement or decision there on an issue which is very very important for us, specially in the context of national security,” Mr Antony was quoted as saying on the sidelines of a public function here.

He did not spell out India’s proposed stand at the Monday-Tuesday talks between the two defence secretaries, but local reports said Mr Antony was apparently referring to Delhi’s demand for a proper authentication of current troop positions in Siachen by both the countries.

“Our stand is there and the defence secretary will explain the stand there,” Mr Antony said. He stressed that India has a `clear cut position’ on the Siachen issue.

“They (defence secretaries of both the sides) are going to have the discussion there. But we have already discussed this in detail. We have very clear cut position, since discussions are going to take place, I don’t want to reply it here,” he said.

Mr Antony’s comments appeared to dampen the hope offered by Pakistan’s High Commissioner Shahid Malik who was quoted as saying that both countries would benefit from demilitarisation in the world’s highest battlefield.

India’s Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) met on Thursday and reports said it was decided to stay with the country’s known position on the authentication of troops. India sees it as the first step towards the ultimate objective of demilitarisation.

India wants Pakistan to agree to authenticate the troop positions and demarcate the Actual Ground Position Line (AGPL) on the map before taking steps to demilitarise the Siachen. However, Pakistan has refused to do so.

Armies of both the countries are deployed there since 1984 and are observing ceasefire since 2003.

In a farewell interview to the United News of India, Mr Malik said there was a consensus in his country to resolve all outstanding issues with India.

Pakistan Army Chief General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani talked of demilitarisation of Siachen when hevisited the glacier in the aftermath of burying alive of 139 Pakistani soldiers in an avalanche in April.

Mr Malik, who leaves India after five years of service here, said Kashmir and confidence-building measures among other issues will be on the agenda of foreign secretary level talks between the two countries to be held in New Delhi on June 29.

Indian Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna is expected to visit Islamabad next month and a breakthrough on Siachen and Sir Creek could facilitate a visit to Islamabad by Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.

 

[SamantK]

See no one is answering now, I wonder what their argument will be.

The argument that since India is a larger country it should do more than Pakistan seems outdated.

 

[Ignited Mind]

Finally someone in this govt. is talking sense.