What's new

Indian companies robbing millions from Bangladesh

Taxicabs worth Tk 80 crore turn into junk
Cheap Indian cars are to blame

Taxicab operators are now counting the cost of their wrong choice of vehicles that forced them to pull 90 per cent of cars out of service much before their average lifetime expired
.
Their association estimates that return on their Tk 200 crore investment in the nascent service in last six years was much less than expected as light vehicles with low engine capacity lost their resale value. Cars worth more than Tk 80 crore turned into junks.

The blame goes to cheap Indian cars with low capacity engines, which made their way into Dhaka’s streets due to cost-cutting exercise of operators and promotional prices offered by local car dealers.

Affected cab operators now point their finger at the government’s wrong policy that paved the way for low quality Indian cars and forced more than a half of taxicab companies to fold within years of operation.

The insolvent operators are now avoiding the commercial banks which invested in taxicab services. Some others have their garages filled with junk cars and scraps. In 2003, the communications ministry gave permission to 10,000 taxicabs to ply in the city, opening the floodgate for poor quality Indian cars. Initially these taxicabs were given 8-year road permit which was later extended to 10 years. But within five years, taxicab operating companies which invested crores of taka through bank loans realised that their investment went down the drain.

‘Indian made cars are not viable for taxicab service,’ said Mannan Chowdhury, president of Bangladesh Association of Taxicab Operators. The realisation is, however, late and proved costly as more than 70 operators lost about Tk 80 crore in taxicab business.
Only 1,000 taxi cabs are in operation in the capital while the rest are turned into scrap, he added. Anudip Auto Ltd, which got permission to run the highest number of nearly 1600 taxicabs, is now guarding two yards of scraps of Indian cars — one at Mirpur and the other in the outskirt of the capital.

Cab Express (BD) Ltd. Cab One, Cab Bangla Ltd, Cab Salida Ld, Cosmo Cab (Pvt.) Ltd, Nihon Taxi Cab, Cosmo Cab (Pvt.) Ltd, Yellow Lines Ltd and Orion Texi Cab (Pvt.) Ltd were among the companies which pressed low-quality Indian cars into service and suffered losses.
Out of 70 operators, 40 have already folded their business and distanced themselves from banks after failing to repay loans.

Banks and leasing companies like Islamic Bank, UCBL, ICB Islamic Bank formerly known as Oriental Bank, AB Bank, Phoenix and Uttara Finance and Investments Limited, which provided the loans, are planning to file cases against the loan defaulters. An official of the Islamic Bank on condition of anonymity told New Age they are following rules and regulations to realise their loans as they found many taxicab companies ‘simply unresponsive’ despite repeated reminders.

Taxicab operators last week at a press conference demanded waiver of bank loan interest. They have been urging the communications ministry for the last couple of years to intervene into the matter for the protection of their business. Some operators including Navana Tax Cab and Nippon, however, stood out from the rest, and they are doing well with Japanese cars.

Navana manager Ainul Kabir Chowdury told New Age that his company operates around 400 cars, all Japanese, to run their cab business since 2000.

Lack of feasibility study to determine whether the Indian cars were viable for running such business was the main reason for the present debacle, he pointed out. He said the government has of late realised the mistake and decided to allow cars with engine capacity of above 1300 cc for taxicab services from the current fiscal year.

http://www.newagebd.com/2009/aug/04/front.html

The author of this article seems to have overlooked what the News paper had to write with the photograph of few crumbled vehicles.

"Junk cars lie in a dumping ground in front of Aftab Auto Centre at Gabtali in Dhaka on Monday. In the absence of proper maintenance, taxi cabs, bought at a high price, become junk soon.
— Sanaul Haque "

I emphaise in the absense of proper maintenance by the cab operators.
 
.
The author of this article seems to have overlooked what the News paper had to write with the photograph of few crumbled vehicles.

"Junk cars lie in a dumping ground in front of Aftab Auto Centre at Gabtali in Dhaka on Monday. In the absence of proper maintenance, taxi cabs, bought at a high price, become junk soon.
— Sanaul Haque "

I emphaise in the absense of proper maintenance by the cab operators.

Finally we have someone talking some sense.....:cheers:
 
.
I emphaise in the absense of proper maintenance by the cab operators.

When there is nothng left of indian junk car product after 2-3 years and everything falling apart, there is nothing to maintain.

But offcourse indian junk logic will try to pain that over.

And those who spread its Maruti car that became junk knows very little about Bangladesh. There are TATA, Maruti and other model as well. Bottom line is india produced cars are junk and thats the reality.
 
.
This is not the first time indian companies robbed from Bangladesh. Junk quality of indian cars are known for years but with piling losses victims of Indian companies highway robbery are speaking out. This is not one off robbery case by indian companies, off late one other indian owned but proxy Bangladeshi owner trying to con people in stock market with falsified income statements and ownership proportion.

Four years back indian TATA tried to pull multi billion dollars ‘highway robbery’ under guise of investment but was unsuccessful.
 
.
Spot on.....if you buy a Mule and expect it to run like a Derby horse ...whose fault is it..... its for you to decide what you want to buy...

M800 is not a car to be used as a Taxi....

Take a look...

This is a M800..


Do you think that this car has the potential to run as a taxi.....to clock a 200 KM each day for 5 to 6 yrs.....our family owns an M800...and in the last 10 yrs it has only done 30000 KM because we use it for local short trips...not as a taxi...

And this is a Toyota Premio

1b1f014b996d36f583bdaa6ff0f9b1bb.jpg

Any car from India with the kind of specs would take the stress of being run as a taxi....our office runs Tata Indigos as cabs and the cars have doe 50000 KM in one yr..

The more money you are willing to spend the better quality you will get...
Now a days many Japanese taxicab companies run 660cc cars. There are big cars like Crowns or Presidents as taxis. 660cc taxis are used now-a-days in Japan because of oil efficiency. By comparison, Maruti is 800cc.

It means the quality of India made cars is very low. About 60 years ago Japanese cars were also of low quality, but they have improved. India should go for good quality if it wants to capture regional markets.
 
.
Mahindra Logan, Tata Indigo, Tata Indica and Toyota Corolla are commonly seen in metropolises in India

So basically it was wrong taxis selected. Maruti Suzuki is not viable for commercial use and it is just for Home use.

This is nothing big deal as many Chinese products sold in India are junk and if we start posting in the forum, it will also be a junk. I am really sorry for those who lost money because of this.
 
.
Now a days many Japanese taxicab companies run 660cc cars. There are big cars like Crowns or Presidents as taxis. 660cc taxis are used now-a-days in Japan because of oil efficiency. By comparison, Maruti is 800cc.

It means the quality of India made cars is very low. About 60 years ago Japanese cars were also of low quality, but they have improved. India should go for good quality if it wants to capture regional markets.

I dont think the regional markets for the Indians have demands for high quality at the moment :disagree: The folks are poor and the oil pricey! These markets need cheap vehicles :agree: I'm not talking about Bangladesh or Pakistan but I rather mean India, Burma, Nepal, Bhutan, and some Southeast Asian countries:agree:
 
.
It means the quality of India made cars is very low. About 60 years ago Japanese cars were also of low quality, but they have improved. India should go for good quality if it wants to capture regional markets.

Brother, Maruti Suzuki is run by Suzuki Motors which is fully subsidiary of the Japanese Suzuki. Also, see the design of the Maruti Suzuki 800 and the other Taxi Cab. There is a lot of difference in that.
 
.
When there is nothng left of indian junk car product after 2-3 years and everything falling apart, there is nothing to maintain.

But offcourse indian junk logic will try to pain that over.

And those who spread its Maruti car that became junk knows very little about Bangladesh. There are TATA, Maruti and other model as well. Bottom line is india produced cars are junk and thats the reality.

You are comparing a Rs.2 Lakh car ( Maruti 800)with Rs. 10 Lakhs car (Toyota). You get a product for the price you pay. This is a cheap car for families not very suitable for taxi business. Your understanding the car's is very low, what els can I say.

If your only intention is show how low the quality of the Indian made cars are thenatleast try to make a reasonable comparision. Compare apples with apples and oranges with oranges not apples with oranges.

Compare a Rs. 2 lakh car with a similar one in bangladesh.

Most importantly, I dont think indian government had forced those cars on innocent bangladeshi's.
 
.
People, for the Anti-Indian guys here Maruti 800 is crap but Suzuki Mehran is a great car.
 
. .
Brother whether you purchase from Pakistan or Japan, if you are purchasing the 800 cc car with the following model, it is not viable to use it for taxi cab.

For Taxicab you have to pay around 3-4 times more. So, basically it was feasibility test which was never conducted by your government of other people. Even we purchase one ship from the Russia but we cannot complain that.
 
.
For Taxicab you have to pay around 3-4 times more. So, basically it was feasibility test which was never conducted by your government of other people. Even we purchase one ship from the Russia but we cannot complain that.

I completely agree. I have never seen a 800 as a taxi in India, its common sense if your a pulling 4-5people with a 800cc engine on a daily basis expect regular maintenance, its sad BD taxi operators didn't have that fore sight. Given the price of the car and its fuel efficiency it would make sense to have it as a city taxi but you also need a network to maintain it. In India, this car is so popular that it can be repaired in any remote village by any mechanic due to its simplicity. if BD cdn't build such a network or a plan why blame it on India? For all the noise some people make why can't BD build its own small car that can help your people out. We in India are car crazy and if you can make a sweet small car thats efficient we will buy it!!! and obviously we also know how to maintain our cars..sorry bro ur just blaming ur inefficiency on India..
 
.
Most importantly, I dont think indian government had forced those cars on innocent bangladeshi's.

It was the other way around,as Eastwatch sir have rightly pointed out.


Originally posted by Eastwatch:

The very nationalist and patriotic BNP govt manipulated everything to fill their own pockets and to please the Indian DADAs. It was something like this:

1) BNP limited the licensed taxi importers to a few, 2) The importers were instructed to import only certain brands of Indian taxis, and 3) The taxi companies were instructed to purchase the imported Indian shoddy taxies only.

.
 
.
All these Maruti800s filling the streets because the authority allowed it to.Why didn't the Anti-India(?) BNP govt. stop this back then?Because they had their share in it.

Now about TATA,well TATA buses and trucks are running well.In fact TATA buses which are used in Dhaka,is way better than Chinese buses,which break down so often.That's from my personal experience of commuting from one end to the other end of Dhaka regularly.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom