What's new

India working to make Bangladesh a desert

We have certain national traits. One of them is to blame others for our own difficulties, but we also do not do our home works adequately. After saying that, we must also understand that international river flows cannot be diverted or its water withhold unilaterally by the upper riverine country.

India has always been doing this. It would build dams a few km above the border without consulting BD. Farakka and Teesta are only two such examples. India does things that harm BD ecologically, financially, economically and psychologically. India seems to connive our sentiments, but then try to ease out things by making strong relationship with the Awami League leaders.

To solve its own water problem, India can perhaps build vast reservoirs at the upper end of rivers like Ganges/Padma and Teesta, get supply from them during winter, and free most of the water for use by BD.

In case of BD, it can build a number of barrages. One such barrage can be located across the Padma near Bhola. Sluice gates can be built across the entry and exit points of all the distributories from the Padma, and 5m (?) high earthen levies can be built along both the banks of this river.

This is how the entire Padma and almost all its distributories will become a vast water reservoir. Winter farming can be supplied with water from this system. It is sure that not all the farms can be connected directly to this network, but when water is available in the river system, the ground water table will rise. This will cause to pump up underground water for irrigation at low cost.

Water is very precious now a days, because countries have to produce more and more foods to feed the ever expanding population. Nature alone is not able to feed this huge population any more. So, not a single drop of water should be allowed to flow freely to the sea. About 3 acre-foot (it means an acre of paddy land will require 3 feet high water) of water is needed in average for each acre of winter paddy crop.

A person can calculate the total requirements of irrigation water in the country and then again calculate the volume of water that can be retained in all the rivers and haors. He will find that BD has enough water resources available to support quite a marvellous GREEN REVOLUTION that can feed 400 million mouths.

Therefore, a comprehensive water management programme must be evolved by our engineers and scientists.

I agree to what you are saying. BD has to keep the water sharing issue at the headlines level all the time. My point is what BD is doing about it. Even if India didn't have those dams, we would still have to deal with flood.

Facts

1) India built and/or building dams.

2) We do have plenty of water in mansoon

3) In winter the rivers run dry.

As you mentioned, we have to create barrages, build reservoir, dredge rivers, and possibly dig irrigation canals to mitigate the threat. Just talking about it won't change the state of the major issue. And the major issue is water/river management in BD, Indian dams are just one of the variables of a giant equation.
 
The New Nation - Internet Edition

Rivers dry up, millions become unemployed: GK Project facing closure

Shamsun Naher from Rajshahi

All the eight major rivers passing through the greater Rajshahi district have almost been dried up. The navigation through these rivers have remained suspended for years while more than three million people who used to depend for their livelihood direct on these rivers have also become unemployed and displaced.

The rivers are the Padma, the Mohananda, the Boral, the Pagla, the Punorbhova, the Atrai, the Karotoa, and the Chhoto Jamuna. The river of Padma has lost its navigability from Shibganj point in Chapainwabganj district to down stream Nagarbari in Pabna district due to withdrawal of water through Farkka Barrage, West Bengal, India. Sand dunes in the form of shoals have emerged in the middle of the river due to stoppage of natural flow of water. Some where in the river there is only spec of water flow while in other places there is knee-deep water. Thousands of people, mainly fishermen and boatmen who used to maintain their livelihood on this river, have become totally unemployed.

People of Rajshahi, Natore, Pabna and adjacent districts beside the river Padma have forgotten the impact of flood, erosion and the devastation created by the turbulent rush of water. Now, even during the Monsoon (rainy season), more than fifty percent of the river bed remain dried up. To feed her rivers and canals, India does not release water as per the water sharing treaty through Farakka barrage. The truth is that, occasionally, when Farakka is unable to contain a huge pressure of water during flood and monsoon, all the gates of Farakka are let open and thus creating a widespread flood in Bangladeshi.

The water level of the river Padma near Shibganj of Chapinawabganj, at Rajshahi and at Paksey Hardinge Bridge points, remained ever low. In many places there is no water to measure. In Rajshahi, the danger level of water of Padma is 18.5 feet. But for the last ten years, the water level never crossed over nine feet. The condition is far worrying at the foot of Hardinge Bridge, the water level being reduced drastically. Absence of water for ages under Hardinge Bridge may cause severe damage for the guarders as sands use to erode the concrete structure of the guarders and the other structures of the bridge, informed sources working for maintaining the bridge at Paksey.

Moreover, the Ganges-Kobadak Irrigation Project (GK Project) which uses to irrigate thousands of hectares of land in the greater Kushtia and Jessore districts is facing closure due to scanty or no water at the source of the project. Due to scarcity of water, the pump houses situated beside the river have been shifted several times and part of river has been dredged but still only 30 to 35 percent of the total capacity of GK project being used for irrigation purposes. It is apprehended that the GK project might face closure within next few years if no flow of water is increased in Padma.

The conditions of all other river flowing through greater Rajshahi is almost similar.
 
The New Nation - Internet Edition

Fall of water level in the Teesta




ACCORDING to a report received in Dhaka from Lalmonirhat, water level of river Teesta has fallen sharply this season disrupting navigation and irrigation of agricultural lands. Last year during this season the flow of the river had reached lowest ever levels. Environmentalists fear this would bring a 'disastrous situation' for navigation, fisheries, agriculture and forestry. The abnormal fall in the Teesta is attributed to the unilateral withdrawal of water by the upper riparian neighbour at the upstream like the adverse effects of Farakka Barrage on the Ganges has been felt acutely in the southwestern part of the country. People living on both sides of the Teesta have already started bearing the brunt.

If the present trend of fall in water level continues, environmentalists and experts apprehend, the Teesta river may not continue to flow. Shoals have already emerged along vast areas of the riverbed creating obstacles to plying of river vessels on different routes. Bangladesh Water Development Board sources say, the declining trend in the flow of the water has been noticeable for the last ten years. Experts of the Joint Rivers Commission of Bangladesh and India had in the recent past come close to some understanding about sharing of water of this common river. Of late messages are being fed attributing reduced flow to decline of water availability at its source.

While diversion of water continues from the Gazaldova Barrage at upstream many hand tubewells in Lalmonirhat and adjacent areas along the river have dried up. Similarly, hundreds of shallow tubewells used in irrigation have become inoperative. Farmers in the Teesta Irrigation project areas are of the view that the deep tubewells, used to irrigate the farmlands, might fail to lift sufficient water due to fall of ground water table posing a threat to agriculture.
 
What's this video about???
Didn't understand half of their language...(coz i don't watch indian movies :D)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
What's this video about???
Didn't understand half of their language...(coz i don't watch indian movies :D)

YouTube - Save Assam Save India

Its a boogyman video. India doesn't want to commit funds to NE. I read in a BR forum that India doesn't want China to have use of infrastructural facilities in case of a Chinese incursion.

The issues of NE are a lot like pre 1971 Pakistan. These need to be addressed politically. Blaming the boogyman will just make history reappear as a ghost of 1971 on the Indian NE.
 
To solve its own water problem, India can perhaps build vast reservoirs at the upper end of rivers like Ganges/Padma and Teesta, get supply from them during winter, and free most of the water for use by BD.

Boro Vhai,

How do you suppose that India will pay out again huge extra dollar$ to reserve water by building new reservoirs inside Indian territory to supply/facilitate water flow towards our Bangladesh in winter and summer since they can easily solve their water problems just by their damn dams?!
Moreover, building reservoirs in India may be will not solve the problem in rainy season to check over flow of water which India leaves to BD in rainy season. Also if we will produce more food then India will loose more food market in BD.
But BD can invest by its own money in India to make reservoir inside India if India will agree and if it will help BD as you suggested.
 
Are you serious bro? You have that much trust in bharat?

But BD can invest by its own money in India to make reservoir inside India if India will agree and if it will help BD as you suggested.


That's why I said that "as you (He/East Watch Bhai) suggested". I'm more or less sure that India will not allow BD to make water reserver inside India even by BD's money. Or if they will allow then somehow those reservoirs will not work!!

But his suggestions about inside BD could solve the problems more or less.
 
Last edited:
India is 1st country who fought war with his all neighbors.

Are you suggesting the Pak & China are ALL the neighbors India has ? A look at an Atlas will show Nepal, Bhutan, Myanmar who share a land border. SL too is a neighbor.

BTW, take a re look at history on the highlighted part above ..hint : Israel, Germany to name a few.
 
India is 1st country who fought war with his all neighbors.

It seams you have no knowledge about India..
India has only fought wars against pakistan and china
India is most friendly neighbour of all countries
 
hawk73 you must not write anything which is baseless and out of logic
 
Dhaka expecting interim
Teesta deal with Delhi
Shahidul Islam Chowdhury

Dhaka is trying to make an interim arrangement on sharing of waters of Teesta river with New Delhi until the two countries can strike a long-term agreement reducing their 蘇uge gap・in water-sharing claims.

The government is expecting an interim agreement on Teesta water sharing to be reached at the ministerial-level meeting of the Joint Rivers Commission scheduled to begin in New Delhi on Wednesday, the water resources minister, Ramesh Chandra Sen, told New Age on Wednesday.

糎e are expecting an interim agreement for sharing Teesta waters during the upcoming talks,・said the minister, who will lead the Bangladesh side at the three-day JRC meet being held after five years.

Differences including India痴 爽nwillingness・to give Bangladesh half of 80 per cent waters of Teesta after reserving 20 per cent waters as environmental flow are yet to be narrowed down for reaching a long-lasting accord.

When asked if Dhaka received any indication about Delhi痴 叢olitical decision・in this regard, Sen referred to the joint communiqu・issued by the prime ministers of Bangladesh and India during Sheikh Hasina痴 tour of India in January. The two prime ministers reportedly expressed their political commitment to concluding talks on the sharing of Teesta waters 粗xpeditiously・

The Joint Rivers Commission, constituted in 1972, is the highest forum for resolution of disputes on sharing of waters of 54 common rivers between the two countries.

However, the water resources ministers of the two countries failed to hold JRC talks in the past five years, due to Delhi痴 unwillingness although the JRC charter says at least two such meetings should be held every year. The 36th minister-level meet of JRC was held in Dhaka in September 2005.

The two prime ministers also directed their respective water resources ministers to JRC talks in the first quarter of 2010 to discuss issues of waters of Feni, Manu, Muhuri, Khowai, Gumti, Dharla and Dhdhkumar rives, according to the joint communiqu・

The water resources secretaries of Bangladesh and India will hold the expert-level meeting on March 16 to resolve technical issues of water-sharing. The water resources ministers, at the three-day meeting from March 17, are likely to take 叢olitical decision・on reaching an agreement, JRC sources said.

Meanwhile, the sources added, the Bangladesh authorities unofficially communicated to their Indian counterparts their expectations of a possible agreement on the Teesta water sharing.

Bangladesh wants that the two countries agree to keep 20 per cent of Teesta waters as environmental flow and share the rest on a 50-50 per cent basis.

But, the Indian side is unwilling to give Bangladesh the proposed share of 40 per cent of the Teesta flow, the sources said.

The Teesta on Bangladesh side almost dries up in March, as India allegedly holds waters at Gajoldoba barrage point.

In February and March ・the leanest period for the Teesta in Bangladesh ・ the flow of waters comes down to less than 1,000 cubic feet per second from 5,000 cubic feet per second in November.

Signing of an agreement on the Teesta river requires intervention from the highest political levels of the two countries, Pinak Ranjan Chakravarty, a former Indian high commissioner in Dhaka, told reporters before Hasina痴 visit to New Delhi.

Asked why Dhaka is expecting only an interim agreement, the water resources secretary, Sheikh Wahid-Uz Zaman, said, 羨 full-fledged agreement on sharing of river requires adequate hydrological data. Sharing of Teesta river waters is our top priority at the JRC meeting. We are working on getting adequate hydrological data for signing a long-term agreement. But we cannot wait for long for an agreement on the plea of non-availability of adequate data,・he said.

The two countries collect river flow data at Gajoldoba point in India and Dalia and Kawnia points in Bangladesh.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Back
Top Bottom