What's new

India stops sharing hydrological data with Pakistan

Kailash Kumar

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 8, 2018
Messages
4,643
Reaction score
-1
Country
Suriname
Location
Netherlands
India stops sharing hydrological data with Pakistan

Vishwa Mohan

Aug 22, 2019

NEW DELHI: Taking the offensive, India has refused to renew its 1989 agreement of sharing hydrological data during flood season with Pakistan and told the neighbour that it would only provide information on “extraordinary discharges and flood flows”.

The agreement, a result of an earlier India’s goodwill gesture, was renewed every year. But the Indian position has changed, coinciding with heightened tensions over the abrogation of Jammu & Kashmir’s special status and the bifurcation of the state into two Union Territories. “This agreement was not renewed in the current year by us,” P K Saxena, Indian Commissioner for Indus Waters, told TOI on Wednesday. The decision, however, has nothing to do with the Indus Water Treaty signed between India and Pakistan in 1960 for sharing waters of the Indus system. “India as a responsible nation is committed to the provisions of the IWT,” said Saxena.

Referring to the 1989 agreement to share hydrological data during flood season between July 1 to October 10, he said, “This was the arrangement beyond the IWT provisions as a gesture of goodwill from India. This arrangement was being renewed every year since 1989 with modifications as and when required.”

Asked about IWT, he said, “Under the Treaty provisions, India is required to provide advance information in regard to ‘extraordinary discharges and flood flows’. This is being done whenever the extraordinary flows are reached.”

Though Saxena didn’t elaborate, the move clearly appeared a fall out of the Pulwama terror attack in February and current tensions. India communicated its move to Pakistan on Tuesday — the day Union Jal Shakti (water resources) minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat expressed the country’s intent to fully utilise its share of water from Indus river system within the IWT rather than allowing it to flow into Pakistan. India was working on how its share of water that flows to Pakistan could be diverted for use by its own farmers, industries and people.

“Work has already begun to stop the waters that flow into Pakistan (under IWT). I am talking about the water which is going to Pakistan, and I am not talking about breaking the Indus treaty,” Shekhawat was quoted as saying by a news agency in Mumbai. He said that the experts were working on the hydrological and techno-feasibility studies. Waters of eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas and Sutlej) are allocated to India while the country is under obligation to let flow water of the western rivers (Indus, Jhelum and Chenab) to Pakistan. India can even use the water from the western rivers for its domestic purposes, irrigation and generating hydro-electric power to an extent.

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=TOIDesktop
 
. . . .
India stops sharing hydrological data with Pakistan

Vishwa Mohan

Aug 22, 2019

NEW DELHI: Taking the offensive, India has refused to renew its 1989 agreement of sharing hydrological data during flood season with Pakistan and told the neighbour that it would only provide information on “extraordinary discharges and flood flows”.

The agreement, a result of an earlier India’s goodwill gesture, was renewed every year. But the Indian position has changed, coinciding with heightened tensions over the abrogation of Jammu & Kashmir’s special status and the bifurcation of the state into two Union Territories. “This agreement was not renewed in the current year by us,” P K Saxena, Indian Commissioner for Indus Waters, told TOI on Wednesday. The decision, however, has nothing to do with the Indus Water Treaty signed between India and Pakistan in 1960 for sharing waters of the Indus system. “India as a responsible nation is committed to the provisions of the IWT,” said Saxena.

Referring to the 1989 agreement to share hydrological data during flood season between July 1 to October 10, he said, “This was the arrangement beyond the IWT provisions as a gesture of goodwill from India. This arrangement was being renewed every year since 1989 with modifications as and when required.”

Asked about IWT, he said, “Under the Treaty provisions, India is required to provide advance information in regard to ‘extraordinary discharges and flood flows’. This is being done whenever the extraordinary flows are reached.”

Though Saxena didn’t elaborate, the move clearly appeared a fall out of the Pulwama terror attack in February and current tensions. India communicated its move to Pakistan on Tuesday — the day Union Jal Shakti (water resources) minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat expressed the country’s intent to fully utilise its share of water from Indus river system within the IWT rather than allowing it to flow into Pakistan. India was working on how its share of water that flows to Pakistan could be diverted for use by its own farmers, industries and people.

“Work has already begun to stop the waters that flow into Pakistan (under IWT). I am talking about the water which is going to Pakistan, and I am not talking about breaking the Indus treaty,” Shekhawat was quoted as saying by a news agency in Mumbai. He said that the experts were working on the hydrological and techno-feasibility studies. Waters of eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas and Sutlej) are allocated to India while the country is under obligation to let flow water of the western rivers (Indus, Jhelum and Chenab) to Pakistan. India can even use the water from the western rivers for its domestic purposes, irrigation and generating hydro-electric power to an extent.

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=TOIDesktop




Not a problem. india is not the only one who can play a water war.........:azn::

https://www.thequint.com/news/world...eapon-pakistan-river-mekong-brahmaputra-tibet
 
. .
WRONG
Fresh water source is the most precious thing on the planet, you cannot compare the two. If you look at the map India has many alternative routes, the routes that use Pakistans airspace journey time will just increase a couple more hours. Plus if you recall when Pakistan did shut its airspace, in febuary the country didn't exactly go in panic mode, it'll costs the airlines more sure, but with a large economy those costs can be absorbed with subsidies.
 
. .
WRONG
Fresh water source is the most precious thing on the planet, you cannot compare the two. If you look at the map India has many alternative routes, the routes that use Pakistans airspace journey time will just increase a couple more hours. Plus if you recall when Pakistan did shut its airspace, in febuary the country didn't exactly go in panic mode, it'll costs the airlines more sure, but with a large economy those costs can be absorbed with subsidies.

Thats if the large economy is doing well not when its starting to slump
 
.
“Work has already begun to stop the waters that flow into Pakistan (under IWT). I am talking about the water which is going to Pakistan, and I am not talking about breaking the Indus treaty,” Shekhawat was quoted as saying by a news agency in Mumbai. He said that the experts were working on the hydrological and techno-feasibility studies. Waters of eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas and Sutlej) are allocated to India while the country is under obligation to let flow water of the western rivers (Indus, Jhelum and Chenab) to Pakistan.

And sadly we are silent - Ravi band kareingey, bc saadi gorment wi laaza side maar jaavey na tey daaah hik mint sanu ravi aaliyan nu wi sabaz light devey mud wekhsaan ay kiraad kiwin band karday hen Ravi... chaagh banayee hoye hai dhi yaaveyaan...
 
.
Looks like the time of Ghoris/Aybeks/Hiljis/EbdAlis etc. is about to get “resurrected”!!! History repeats itself in a cyclic fashion....
 
. .
time to destry Indian dams.. it is now or never!!! such actions are attck on Pakistan's sovereignty
 
.
If they abide by the IWT then they can do anything they wish. They can keep all the water which is theirs according to IWT.

One thing should be made clear. U can keep ur water but that does not mean u can flood our rivers when u cant handle all the water. Pakistan should make it clear that any attempt to damage Pakistan with floods would be seen as act of war and responded accordingly.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom