What's new

India-France missile development plan in troubled waters

illusion8

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
12,232
Reaction score
-20
Country
India
Location
India
NEW DELHI: An India-France proposed joint venture expected to be worth around Rs 30,000 crore to develop short range air defence missiles seems to have run into rough weather as Indian Air Force feels that its requirements could be met by indigenous Akash surface-to-air missile weapon system.

The Akash air defence missile system has already been developed by the DRDO indigenously and its development trials were completed successfully by the agency in Odisha recently.

The SR-SAM is also planned to be a project in the same class, highly placed sources said here.

The IAF feels that when the indigenous system meets the requirements of the force, then there is no requirement for importing or co-developing a similar system, they said.

As per the proposed SR-SAM project, the IAF had to induct 49 Missile Firing Units (MFUs) of the co-developed missiles.

image_658_151876.jpg

India's mobile surface-to-air missile defense system 'Akash' is displayed during a press day of the Seoul International Aerospace and Defense Exhibition. (Photo: AFP/Getty Images)


The IAF has already placed orders for eight squadrons of the Akash surface-to-air missile and it would require to place orders for another 25 squadrons of the weapon systems to meet its complete requirement of air defence missiles of this range, the sources said.
The induction would also save a lot of foreign exchange and help in expanding the indigenous missile production industry in view of the large orders to be placed, they said.

Rs 30,000 crore India-France missile development plan in troubled waters - The Times of India

30,000 crores getting pumped into indigenous defense industry = good news all around. :agree:

@cirr, @Abingdonboy, @sancho.
 
Last edited:
. . .
Good,,but they should try to add some quick reaction capabilities to Akash SAM system which are essential for SR-SAMs.
 
.
Check out the TOI headline - they made it sound as if it was a major policy faux pas and not a plus for the local defense market. They almost seem to blame IAF for nixing the deal. :lol:

Wonder who funds TOI?.

Certainly not the Grammr nashis have you red some os thier articel
 
.
if IAF says so,there is no problem.I'm happy to see that they're relying on Akash than future co-developed missile.but I'm agreeing with @Juggernautjatt .we need quick reaction missiles as well as point defence one.
 
.
akash is not quick reaction period.

The guy is comparing apples to oranges.god save journalist.

Indo french uses trust vectoring smokeless and is light weight.Itz like comparing ambassador to Ferrari.


maintenance of akash will cost a bomb.
 
Last edited:
.
Stupid article :
How can Akash and Maitri be same ? Maitri is Quick reaction short range with active homing-head.
IAF don't need Maitri because they have similar and capable SPYDER SAM (108 launchers).
Maitri is must for Army and Navy (successor to Barak 1)
It has been a requirement since days of trishul.
 
Last edited:
.
Stupid article :
How can Akash and Maitri be same ? Maitri is Quick reaction short range with active homing-head.
IAF don't need Maitri because they have similar and capable SPYDER SAM (108 launchers).
Maitri is must for Army and Navy (successor to Barak 1)
It has been a requirement since days of trishul.
Barak 1 has range upto 10km and Barak 8 of upto 70kms, IN will not induct Maitri
Indian Army is also inducting akash Surface-to-Air Missile Akash Completes Validation Trials -The New Indian Express
 
.
Barak 1 has range upto 10km and Barak 8 of upto 70kms, IN will not induct Maitri
Indian Army is also inducting akash Surface-to-Air Missile Akash Completes Validation Trials -The New Indian Express
Barak 1 is called point defence and Barak 8 is medium range.Both are different class.
To replace Barak 1 Navy need Maitri,They are getting desperate and just send out RFI for CIWS with missiles.

Yes,Akash is filling requirement of medium range SAM for Army.This is quick reaction short range SAM.
 
. . .
30,000 crores getting pumped into indigenous defense industry = good news all around. :agree:

Not a good article, since it's mixing up things. Akash is not comparable to Maitri SAM, that's that where 2 different indigenous projects and the only reason for a joint development was the failure of DRDO to develop it alone.
IAF also has the quick reaction SAM field covered mainly, since they had bought the Israeli SPYDER SAM long ago, which servers other purposes as the Akash systems they have, so no relation to Maitri development here either.
 
.
Barak 1 is called point defence and Barak 8 is medium range.Both are different class.
To replace Barak 1 Navy need Maitri,They are getting desperate and just send out RFI for CIWS with missiles.

Yes,Akash is filling requirement of medium range SAM for Army.This is quick reaction short range SAM.

@Kaalapani

MF-STAR radar used on the jointly developed naval defence system
The MF-STAR radar will provide mid-course guidance updates for the missile initially after the launch from the ship. MF-STAR is a multifunction surveillance track and guidance radar for modern naval ships.

The radar uses multibeam, pulse Doppler and electronic counter-counter measures (ECCM) techniques to detect fast moving and low-RCS targets, even in complex environments / conditions and jamming environments.

The radar system provides 360° degree coverage and allows interception of incoming missile as close as 500m away from the ship. During the terminal phase, the second motor will be fired and active radar seeker will be activated to home on to the target.

Naval Barak-8 Missiles, Israel - Naval Technology

Barak 8 is multi-purpose, hence there is no real need for Maitri, it can eleminate targets from 500 meters to 70 kms
Barak 8 can be modified for army to if i am not wrong
 
.
Not a good article, since it's mixing up things. Akash is not comparable to Maitri SAM, that's that where 2 different indigenous projects and the only reason for a joint development was the failure of DRDO to develop it alone.
IAF also has the quick reaction SAM field covered mainly, since they had bought the Israeli SPYDER SAM long ago, which servers other purposes as the Akash systems they have, so no relation to Maitri development here either.
Since the astra is developing in good pace, isn't a good idea to develop one, easy since astra is already getting fast tracked.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom