What's new

India - 84-Year-Old Activist Stan Swamy Dies In Hospital Waiting For Bail

Shameful. This will be beginning of Modi's downfall.

It is shameful indeed. There is also Professor GN Saibaba who is also accused of having ties with the leftist Naxal / Maoist guerrillas and has been jailed for life. This despite him being paralyzed from waist down due to polio that he contracted at a young age.
 
All communists who have links to naxals should meet the same fate .
A time will come, when even Mr Modi will meet the same fate.
The real rulers of India were people from UP and Behar, and that will be eventually...

Nafrat ki koi intaha nahi hoti..
 
Was he criminal or not? No charge was proved by the authority. He was old, sick, and got covid, but still not granted bail. Prgya Thakur was baile don medical ground but not him.

So it is actually a loss of empathy in the government/system for its citizen, to whom they consider anti-national/dangerous for the system.

He wasn't given a sipper. Come on !! where did your cultural values go ?

I can just wonder what Kashmiri go through !!!
 
Please read my point #4 above. And there is a precedent for this. The FARC leftist guerrilla movement of Columbia also started around the same time as the Naxals in India and some years ago the Columbian government had dialogue with FARC though a bit later the government reneged on its promises. But for the dialogue the Columbian president got a Nobel Peace Prize.

Why can't such a thing happen in India ?

Yes no harm in a dialogue, we had it with Hizbul also I believe. But that doesn't mean activities with Hizbul or liaison with them or any banned organization will become kosher
 
Yes no harm in a dialogue, we had it with Hizbul also I believe. But that doesn't mean activities with Hizbul or liaison with them or any banned organization will become kosher

Agreed but Father Stan had no verifiable links with the Naxals.
 
This court is NIA's court, not the regular court, and NIA seems to lean to the Right. From your article :
Advocate Sharif Shaikh and advocate Kritika Agarwal filed Fr Swamy’s bail on the grounds that the prosecution has failed to establish how he had in any way taken part or committed or incited the commission of any unlawful activity. Hence, Section 13 (punishment for unlawful activities) of UAPA, cannot be applied.


OTOH there is the Sadhvi Pragya case where in contrast to Father Stan the Sadhvi had terrorist charges dropped by the NIA and she was released on "health" grounds. @Goenitz said this above :
Was he criminal or not? No charge was proved by the authority. He was old, sick, and got covid, but still not granted bail. Prgya Thakur was baile don medical ground but not him.


So what should one make of the NIA ?
 
So what should one make of the NIA ?
Brother, it is your country, but we don;t even believe your supreme courts. They are the one who validated emergency.
Then they hanged Afzal Guru on "collective conscience of the society " basis..
Then they awarded RSS madnir by putting burden of proofs on Muslims, and not on Ram akahara/trust whatever..

There are many other examples.

However, in this era, courts are totally handicapped and just an extension of government policing.
 
This court is NIA's court, not the regular court, and NIA seems to lean to the Right. From your article :

OTOH there is the Sadhvi Pragya case where in contrast to Father Stan the Sadhvi had terrorist charges dropped by the NIA and she was released on "health" grounds. @Goenitz said this above :

So what should one make of the NIA ?

Sadhvi Pragya was in jail for 9 - 10 years before getting bail and was tortured physically, Stan Swamy not even 10 months with no sipper and the whole anti-modi eco-system building sympathy and trying to save his @ss . Be it NIA or regular courts or supreme court, when they give a verdict which one likes then they are fair, when they don't (like Ram Temple verdict) they lean right, left or elsewhere.
 
He was old and long suffering from some health issues, his time was mostly up anyway.

He was also under arrest on some very serious charges and therefore was in jail but father passed away peacefully in some christian sounding hospital.

There's really nothing to discuss here.
 
84-Year-Old Activist Stan Swamy Dies In Hospital Waiting For Bail

Elgar Parishad Case: Stan Swamy had told the High Court via video-conferencing that his health had consistently declined at the Taloja prison in Navi Mumbai and if he was not granted interim bail, he "would die soon".

All India Reported by Saurabh Gupta, Edited by Deepshikha Ghosh Updated: July 05, 2021 7:20 pm IST

Elgar Parishad Case: Stan Swamy was being treated at Holy Family Hospital in Mumbai

New Delhi:
Stan Swamy, an 84-year-old priest-activist arrested under an anti-terror law in the Elgar Parishad case last year, died today in the middle of his fight for bail on health grounds. The Jesuit priest had been on a ventilator since yesterday when his health took a sharp turn for the worse.

Stan Swamy was being treated at the private Holy Family Hospital in Mumbai following a court order on May 28. The National Investigation Agency (NIA) had suggested a government hospital, to which, he had said: "I'd rather die here in prison."

Jailed near Mumbai since October, Stan Swamy spent the last few months of his life fighting legal battles for even the smallest of needs. In December, he was allowed a straw and a sipper in jail, which he had requested in court on account of Parkinson's disease. He had requested medical treatment and interim bail multiple times.

The NIA, which arrested him in October from his home in a widely criticized late-night swoop, opposed his bail request in court and had said there was no "conclusive proof" of his medical ailments. The agency held firm to its argument that Stan Swamy was a Maoist who had plotted to cause unrest in the country.

Stan Swamy had told the High Court via video-conferencing that his health had consistently declined at the Taloja prison in Navi Mumbai and if he was not granted interim bail, he "would die soon".

Last week, Stan Swamy had filed a fresh plea for bail in the Bombay High Court, challenging the stringent conditions for bail to an accused charged under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA). When the hearing started today, his lawyer told the High Court that the activist had died at 1.30 pm.

Messages and tributes poured in, with opposition parties and activists accusing the government of hounding the elderly activist.

UN Special Rapporteur for Human Rights Defenders, Mary Lawlor, shared his video along with a message: "The news from India today is devastating. Human Rights Defender and Jesuit priest Fr Stan Swamy has died in custody, nine months after his arrest on false charges of terrorism. Jailing HRDs (Human Rights Defenders) is inexcusable." EU'S Special Representative for Human Rights, Eamon Gilmore, also tweeted.

Stan Swamy had in the past complained to the court of poor health facilities in prison. He and other accused in the case had alleged neglect by prison officials in ensuring medical aid, tests, hygiene and social distancing in the time of Covid.

The Elgar Parishad case relates to an event on December 31, 2017 in Koregaon-Bhima near Pune, which was followed by violence and arson that left one person dead. Investigators claim that activists at the event, an Elgar Parishad meet, had made inflammatory speeches and provocative statements that led to violence the next day.

The NIA said senior leaders of the CPI (Maoist), a banned organisation under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, were in contact with the organisers of the Elgar Parishad event as well as the arrested activists, and aimed to spread Maoist and Naxal ideology and encourage unlawful activities.

Stan Swamy, who had worked with tribals in Jharkhand for over five decades, was accused by the NIA of links to Naxals, especially the banned CPI (Maoists). He was arrested from his home in Jharkhand capital Ranchi by a team of NIA officials from Delhi. He had denied the charges and had flagged his health worries to investigators.

Two days before his arrest, he had said in a video statement: "They are even asking me to go to Mumbai for further interrogation, which I am refusing to go. Because of my age, I have certain ailments. There is the epidemic which is ravaging the country... This is something that I am communicating to them and let us hope that some human sense will prevail."

Several prominent activists, scholars and lawyers have spent over two years in jail as they wait for trial in the case.

Stan Swamy was the oldest to be arrested. He had also tested positive for the coronavirus at a private hospital last month and was subsequently shifted to the ICU.

---

Jamahir's comment : This activist was in the same jail ( Taloja ) that that poisonous, right-wing, crooked journalist Arnab Goswami was also jailed for some time. Snake Arnab was released but Father Stan Swamy was kept jailed despite his ailments ( he had asked for a drink sipper because he had Parkinson's disease ). Unfortunate.

---

@Joe Shearer @Naofumi @Drizzt @Goenitz
Please add this video to the first post, lot of people don't have reading habit. If they stumble upon this thread in the future via Google Search. let them get a summary from video.
 
Please add this video to the first post, lot of people don't have reading habit. If they stumble upon this thread in the future via Google Search. let them get a summary from video.

Added. Thanks for the vid.

---

@-=virus=-, please watch the vid above.

@Fireurimagination @lightoftruth, the vid above uses facts to question the legitimacy of NIA. Please watch the vid.
 
The guy was an ailing man of 84 years of age, @jamahir What exactly is all the outrage about ?
He was being investigated on serious charges, neither you, nor any of the other outraged leftist, nor me and people on the other side of the issue know the details of the investigation. The Naxal/maoist problem IS a national security issue. It may well be the case that investigations into Swamy have led to more information.

The government did not kill him, he died of old age and covid in a hospital getting good care.

What is all this hysteria about ?
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom