Imran Khan Announces to give Pak Citizenship to Afghan Refugees

[Peaceful Civilian]

IAM SORRY TO EVERY PMLN SUPPORTER IAM ASHAMED.

What PMLN has done to Pakistan and ruined us at such extent, it will take decades to pay, generation to generation.
Don't overreact on suggestion. and you have to pass law to implement.
This is democray, one can criticize and reject it, and let the majority to decide on Parliment for the best interest of Pakistan.
This is PMLN which supported taliban in 1990s, PMLN still supports punjabi taliban, & banned extremist organisation, LEJ terrorist abid raza kotli from gujrat still won MNA seat on PMLN ticket. Read his history. And there are many other examples of PMLN and their affiliatation with banned organisations.

 

[SoulSpokesman]

@Imad.Khan

Heart warming story, sir.

Regards

 

[padamchen]

Pakistan was created for Muslims of Hindustan (sub continent) only.

LOL very convenient.

Then what are you doing with Pashtun and Baloch lands?

IF that was the stated span of the goal, Pakistan should NEVER have spilled beyond the east bank of the Indus.

This my friend is called a Gordian knot ....

Cheers, Doc

This is the only way Pakhtuns can electorally dominate the Punjabis. This has been Imran Khan's plan all along am surprised people didn't see it coming.

Pakistan's Didi?

Cheers, Doc

 

[Areesh]

LOL very convenient.

Then what are you doing with Pashtun and Baloch lands?

IF that was the stated span of the goal, Pakistan should NEVER have spilled beyond the east bank of the Indus.

This my friend is called a Gordian knot ....

Cheers, Doc



Pakistan's Didi?

Cheers, Doc

Parsi gandu at his gandu pan again.

 

[Men in Green]

Its NOT happening.
You need to compile data, to have them on sheets and lists to keep track and load them back. Use some common sense mate. How else you think we should send them back? Wait and try to understand what is happening rather than criticizing everything just for the sake of it.

who told you this? any source to back this claim ?

 

[SoulSpokesman]

@padamchen

Doc,

IK is only doing the inevitable. I am sure you have read history, before the call of duty took you to Eye Eye Tee and later Eye Eye Yumm. Afghans never needed a visa/permit to come to the Punjab and Sindh (and beyond)- they just walked over whenever they wanted to. Dont see why they shudnt continue to do so.

Regards

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Those crying now, and they are legion here, should first realize that it was always going to be the natural progression of things the day the idea of Pakistan reached out beyond the ethnogeographic boundaries of the Indic civilization and hobbled together a confederacy of the eastern most reaches of the Iranic one as well.

It was always overreach. And there were always going to be consequences.

I don'tthink you still understand. You must admit my thoughts on this subject have been validated. I at times was the lone voice here. The minority. But you overlook something. Never use PDF as measure of the real Pakistan. Do you really think PDF represents the real demography of Pakistan? It represents either ex-pats with internet connections or Pakistani's from the better economic segments of society which is mostly urban. Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad and a few nodes in between. The cyberspace gives you a skewed view of Pakistan.

And you still are slave to the Gangatic view of the region. The Indus basin is not and has never been the preserve of one homogenous ethnic group. The Indus Basin is the fracture zone between the west and east. It's history has been defined by that. Two currents spilling into Indus for millenia. It has always been a set of two. Where the West converged with the East. You can go as far back as Mehr Garh or Gandhara, Taxila you will see the west and east creating a syncretic civilization. To be sure the tide kept shifting but the 'gateway' aspect always existed.

What you did and many like you is get entirely absorbed with the reality of the previous century which of course under the British rule saw Indus becoming locked with the east - the Ganga Plains but 1947 undid that. So in a sense we are merely seeing the re-adjustment to the status quo that prevailed in history. Imean look at the Afghan Empire. What you call 'Indic' is firmly part of a westerly based empire. And this pattern goes back to Persian, Greek, Kushan times. However if your template is the British Raj then I can see why you have a problem understanding this concept of Indus as a unique - in that it is convergence of civilizations. And has always been that. From the Gangatic POV, same but annoyingly detached and differant. From Iranic POV same but with annoying accretions that were differant. We are the Anatolia of the east. A bridge between west and east and I would argue even the north. CPEC is in fact the historical reconfiguration of the silk road that saw Bhuddism travel north from Taxila to China.

 

[SoulSpokesman]

@Indus Pakistan

Kaptaan sahib,

Well written. But the integration of GV and IV were not just Brit handiwork, IMHO. It was Sultanate and Mughal contribution too.

Regards

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Well written. But the integration of GV and IV were not just Brit handiwork, IMHO. It was Sultanate and Mughal contribution too.

I agree. Any geography unless it is a island in a ocean will be influenced by it's neigbouring regions. No doubt GV and western hinterlands have always impacted on IV. And continue to do so. Today Afghanistan/Iran and India have direct impact on Pakistan. From Islamabad's POV foreign policy is largely about how to deal wit these factors.

 

[Imad.Khan]

@Imad.Khan

Heart warming story, sir.

Regards

People here have a very narrow vision of things. They keep forgetting that just like not all fingers are the same, just like that not all the people are the same. Everything is based on circumstances. I am Pakistani today because my great grandfather decided to move here 50 or 60 years before partition. If he hadnt done that i would be an Afghan citizen. They also dont understand that its not the child's fault that he/she is born to parents who are refugees, so why should he be punished for it. They also keep forgetting people like Tarek fateh who is ethnically punjabi but nobody calls all punjabis namak haram.

 

[SoulSpokesman]

Kaptaan sb,

As I see it, Pak's cis Indus provinces -Punjab and Sindh are linguistically closer to NW Indian nationalities (gujju, punju and rajasthani) than the trans-Indus nationalities, but religiously closer to the latter lot. (I will leave ethnic as it tends to degenerate into racist name calling). But a more fundamental diff is that the cis-Indus nationalities are more of what would be described as settled folk whereas trans Indus nationalities would be closer to be what wud in the past be described as nomadic folk.

That I see as Pak's key political challenge. How to integrate the two groups.

Regards

 

[padamchen]

@padamchen

Doc,

IK is only doing the inevitable. I am sure you have read history, before the call of duty took you to Eye Eye Tee and later Eye Eye Yumm. Afghans never needed a visa/permit to come to the Punjab and Sindh (and beyond)- they just walked over whenever they wanted to. Dont see why they shudnt continue to do so.

Regards

It was actually AFMC bro. The brains never extended to the exalted two.

Like Indus here, I believe what we are seeing today (provided IK lasts/is allowed to last) is the rest of the region saying enough is enough, we are no longer ready to be held hostage to Punjabi family drama.

Civilizations will prevail.

Modern ideas will need to bend to accommodate. Or be swept away by blood (lines ...).

Cheers, Doc

 

[Abu Zarrar]

PTM point of view

https://twitter.com/x/status/1041591978335461376

 

[War Thunder]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1041374706354540545

@Arsalan @Indus Pakistan @war&peace will you guys still wait for 6 months and then criticize him? Legalize Afghanis really? Whats worst next legalize TTP??

IAM SORRY TO EVERY PMLN SUPPORTER AND PAKISTANIS I VOTED FOR THIS TALIBAN KHAN. IAM ASHAMED.

You are an idiot who lacks the brain to understand how things work in countries or in a fair system.
A child was born and raised in your land, what's the problem with giving him citizenship? Is ethics and morality more important than your tiny whiny ego of Aghans being this and that and you being better?
Is every one not equal and have the same rights in an Islamic state, the one based on the idea of State of the Prophet (S.A.W)? If so, then man up and take responsibility of owning up to the kids who ended up taking birth in your land while you were hosting them.
Escaping responsibility and caring for ones own self is the trait of weak insecure and shallow souls. Ones not worthy of being refered to as Muslims. Correct your mindset already ffs...

Pakistanis have earned worse name in foreign lands for their jahilana and uncivilized behavior.....Afghans are still better off....So let's not even get started on this topic.

 

[SoulSpokesman]

@padamchen

Dont take Eye Eye Tee/Eye Eye Umm quite literally- AIIMS/AFMC etc come within the same bracket. The ones that Dada (@Joe Shearer) would label as Macaulay sahib's lost children- the ones who (ab)used their brains for the vulgar job of earning daal roti.

Regards