Imran has literally taken PPP by SURPRISE - and no one noticed.

[Zibago]

No...

That doesn't have support of media but that sword of governor rule should still be hanging on PPP thugs' heads.

Anything apart from governor rule can be worked upon. Stage is set.

PPP actually set the precedent for governor raj post 18th amendment by dismissing Balochistan government

 

[Imran Khan]

Aus ke baad zardari dubai bhag gaya tha wo yaad nahi?

ohh mery bhai phir bhi usko aik sooba dena para elections main . kher to hai apko . wo dhamki de gya army ne kya kiya phir?

 

[Cygnus Black]

PTI need to thrash the 18th amendment with the help of establishment

The same IK will beg for the restoration of 18th amendment after the next elections as PTI will be confined to KPK and then he would have to beg PM Maryam/Bilawal for funds for the completion of Peshawar BRT.

 

[Syed1.]

The same IK will beg for the restoration of 18th amendment after the next elections as PTI will be confined to KPK and then he would have to beg PM Maryam/Bilawal for funds for the completion of Peshawar BRT.

Look at the delusions of jiyalas


Karachi ko alag kar ke dikhain gaye. Karlo jo karna hai

 

[Pandora]

Saw waseem badami show someone name Manzoor Hasan i think was taking a real piss at this issue. According to him Sindh govt didnt give permission to Army. So that means Sindh Govt has been bypassed and PPP could even move an Inch. Personally i am against Army being used as laborers when we have situation at every border but if it jitters some nerves in PPP ranks then job well done.

 

[Cygnus Black]

Karachi ko alag kar ke dikhain gaye. Karlo jo karna hai

Jab Zia, Mushy and aur Altaf mil kar ye kaam nahi kar nahi kar sake to IK kis khet ki mooli hai?

 

[Pandora]

The same IK will beg for the restoration of 18th amendment after the next elections as PTI will be confined to KPK and then he would have to beg PM Maryam/Bilawal for funds for the completion of Peshawar BRT.

He never said anything about getting rid of 18th amendment entirely. His issues with 18th amendment are genuine as we have seen in recent pandemic. Federal govt was forced to provide relief via their own budget when Health is not even a federal subject. Same thing happened with Sugar and Wheat crisis where provinces were responsible for food but PPP oblivious of its duties didnt ever buy a single grain in year 2018-2019. When there was a lack of coordination every province couldn't even fix a single price of wheat grain. A uniform price would have relieved burden and made transfer of wheat from province to other easier. Then let move to Education where Sindh refused to adopt a uniform curriculum despite having one of the most crappy education system in entire country. If there is any province which needs education reforms most that is sindh but that power was curtailed by 18TH amendment. There are several matters where 18th amendment has proven to be curse so this should be reviewed.

 

[Syed1.]

Jab Zia, Mushy and aur Altaf mil kar ye kaam nahi kar nahi kar sake to IK kis khet ki mooli hai?

Dekhtay raho.. IK nahi tu oskay baad phir oskay baad phir oskay baad. Leken Karachi Sindh se alag ho kar rahayga.


Ya phir poora Sindh pe Urdu speakers ki hakumat hogi. Your choice

 

[Cygnus Black]

Ya phir poora Sindh pe Urdu speakers ki hakumat hogi. Your choice

Mujhe iss se koi problem nahi hai agar Urdu speakers vote lekar poore Soobe mein hukoomat karein ya poore mulk par.

 

[AZ1]

The same IK will beg for the restoration of 18th amendment after the next elections as PTI will be confined to KPK and then he would have to beg PM Maryam/Bilawal for funds for the completion of Peshawar BRT.

Bhutto nei aker bataya hoga future ka

 

[AZ1]

Mujhe iss se koi problem nahi hai agar Urdu speakers vote lekar poore Soobe mein hukoomat karein ya poore mulk par.

Bhutto wala jhoot yeh tou jabhi karachi per apna haq jama ke bethay hotay ho jab ke vote milta nahi batein suno

 

[S A L M A N.]

Personally I would love to see PTI move in however in all honesty I don't think there is any way they can. The only way that comes into my mind is through a constitutional amendment, for that they need a two third majority government, which PTI does not have.

The people of Karachi and Sindh need to stop voting for PPP and MQM. PPP is corrupt to the core and when MQM has people like Atlaaf Hussain, why do you need enemies? He is enough.

The main problem is that Karachi is poorly understood in far off Islamabad and the power centers of the Punjab.
The rest of Pakistan does not understand the underlying socioeconomic and political dynamics of Karachi. They just think that it is a simple problem of the people of Karachi voting for the PPP or MQM. It is deeper than that.
And for your information, MQM has been washed out from Karachi. The rest of the population literally spits in their face today. I have literally seen expletives being spray painted on the boundary wall of an MQM ex-MPA. That same MPA can now be seen moping around in dirty pyjamas or smoking cigarettes at the tea dhaba.
So, in short, MQM is history. PPP does not have a mandate in Karachi except in 2/3 constituencies. But, PPP has kept the rest of Sindh so pathetically underdeveloped that for all practical reasons it is still in 2000 BC. The people of interior Sindh are literally living like animals or perhaps worse, as bonded labourers. Karachi is the only thorn in their side because they know that Karachi's educated urban middle class has swung towards PTI and it is only a matter of time before the rest of Sindh does so as well albeit slowly. The PPP already has the end in sight and so it is just a matter of intensifying the plunder along the lines of the British in India.

 

[CriticalThinker02]

The main problem is that Karachi is poorly understood in far off Islamabad and the power centers of the Punjab.
The rest of Pakistan does not understand the underlying socioeconomic and political dynamics of Karachi. They just think that it is a simple problem of the people of Karachi voting for the PPP or MQM. It is deeper than that.
And for your information, MQM has been washed out from Karachi. The rest of the population literally spits in their face today. I have literally seen expletives being spray painted on the boundary wall of an MQM ex-MPA. That same MPA can now be seen moping around in dirty pyjamas or smoking cigarettes at the tea dhaba.
So, in short, MQM is history. PPP does not have a mandate in Karachi except in 2/3 constituencies. But, PPP has kept the rest of Sindh so pathetically underdeveloped that for all practical reasons it is still in 2000 BC. The people of interior Sindh are literally living like animals or perhaps worse, as bonded labourers. Karachi is the only thorn in their side because they know that Karachi's educated urban middle class has swung towards PTI and it is only a matter of time before the rest of Sindh does so as well albeit slowly. The PPP already has the end in sight and so it is just a matter of intensifying the plunder along the lines of the British in India.

Interior Sindh will never move away from PPP, they are too under-developed, too devoid of education, too brainwashed to not vote for PPP outside of ethnics no matter how much PPP sucks out their soul, they will always vote for PPP and because of that reason Karachi is screwed, the only way Karachi can be saved is if we get separate city state recognition with a separate electoral representatives or Federally administered, but PPP will fight tooth and nails for Karachi because more than 65% of Sindh's revenue is generated from Karachi while less than 2% is returned back in for development, the rest of Sindh is a wasteland, Karachi will turn in too if something drastic is not done in the future and that will be a major economic blow for Pakistan, we don't want to be part of the Sindh provincial government.

 

[PaklovesTurkiye]

Interior Sindh will never move away from PPP, they are too under-developed, too devoid of education, too brainwashed to not vote for PPP outside of ethnics no matter how much PPP sucks out their soul, they will always vote for PPP and because of that reason Karachi is screwed, the only way Karachi can be saved is if we get separate city state recognition with a separate electoral representatives or Federally administered, but PPP will fight tooth and nails for Karachi because more than 65% of Sindh's revenue is generated from Karachi while less than 2% is returned back in for development, the rest of Sindh is a wasteland, Karachi will turn in too if something drastic is not done in the future and that will be a major economic blow for Pakistan, we don't want to be part of the Sindh provincial government.

PPP's counterweight is needed in interior Sindh...GDA option is there.

Quite a lot of Sindhis are fed up with PPP as well

 

[Jungibaaz]

I think you folks are misreading what's actually going on. PTI's fight with PPP, or rather the federal government's fight with the main province they cannot control directly and politically is all about provincial funds and 18th division of revenues. Punjab has signed on since they are effectively run by IK himself, KPK is theirs so no fight there etc. But Sindh has resisted and this has been going on for a long time now.

Karachi and its situation is bad and PPP is rightly facing flak, but the federal and Sindh government tussle is largely irrelevant and based on finances, Karachi just another political tool being used in the game right now. I don't see any productive or constructive calls coming from the federal government regarding Karachi. IMO karachi needs decentralised and devovled governance. Federal is trying to repeal the 18th which in fact would only damage Karachi at best as it ensures more centralisation and not less, the rest is just bluster and outrage being directed at PPP because of the preceding fight about finances and the 18th.

The federal government have their own scores and books to settle. Ideologically PTI's current love of presidential style and ordinance driven rule, 18th repeal and more centralization is the last thing Karachi needs. Karachi needs to be free of Sindh level governance and have it local, it does not need to be used as a tool by those who want to centralise power for other reasons. If you're a Karachiite, PTI is not your savior nor is the federal government, you need to fight for your own city and local governance. Be free of PPP, and don't fall victim to being used as a political tool by the federal government, that is all.