RescueRanger
PDF THINK TANK: CONSULTANT
- Joined
- Sep 20, 2008
- Messages
- 16,370
- Reaction score
- 244
- Country
- Location
Note how some Indian posters come here and elect to lecture Pakistan saying "you did nothing for them [Afghan's]".
I am old enough to have lived through the conflict of the 80's and the AK culture in the 90's and the terrorism of the 00's. No nation has done more for Afghan's than Pakistan. Please don't come and lecture us here about this, we have hosted them for 40 years. We opened our homes to Afghan's, people in India will either have selective amnesia or chose to ignore the generosity of the people of Pakistan for Afghans.
Out of the 4.4 million Afghan refugees estimated to be living in Pakistan, there are1.73 million who have no legal documents to stay. [Source: IRC]
Pakistan helped the Afghan people fight for their homeland:
We "Pakistanis" have been hospitable to Afghan's, before people from India lecture Pakistan on Afghan refugees, you need to understand that MANY Afghans choose NOT to integrate into Pakistani society:
After the US led evacuation of Afghanistan and the takeover of the Taliban, we had to open our doors AGAIN to the Afghans:
Afghans with PoR cards or Afghan Citizen Cards were allowed to have jobs and even study in Pakistan:
The problem is a large number of Afghan refugees refused to obtain PoR cards. How can any country house undocumented, unvetted people?
If undocumented migrants DO NOT pose a problem or a threat, then why did the EU just expel 29% of them and is expected to fast track the expulsion of more next year?
Out of the total number of 105,865 non-EU citizens who were instructed to leave an EU member state, 26,600 were repatriated to other countries.
Finally and most importantly before anyone in India lectures PAKISTAN and Pakistanis on what we have done for Afghanistan, what are YOU doing? Where were you for 40 years? Why did your government refuse to accept Afghan Refugees despite pleas and applications after the soviet invasion, with New Delhi citing that it had no obligation to do so as it wasn't a signatory to the UN Convention of Refugees?
Why did India refuse Asylum and refugee of over 60,000 Afghan's from entering India after the Taliban takeover in 2021?
I am old enough to have lived through the conflict of the 80's and the AK culture in the 90's and the terrorism of the 00's. No nation has done more for Afghan's than Pakistan. Please don't come and lecture us here about this, we have hosted them for 40 years. We opened our homes to Afghan's, people in India will either have selective amnesia or chose to ignore the generosity of the people of Pakistan for Afghans.
Out of the 4.4 million Afghan refugees estimated to be living in Pakistan, there are1.73 million who have no legal documents to stay. [Source: IRC]
Pakistan helped the Afghan people fight for their homeland:
We "Pakistanis" have been hospitable to Afghan's, before people from India lecture Pakistan on Afghan refugees, you need to understand that MANY Afghans choose NOT to integrate into Pakistani society:
After the US led evacuation of Afghanistan and the takeover of the Taliban, we had to open our doors AGAIN to the Afghans:
Afghans with PoR cards or Afghan Citizen Cards were allowed to have jobs and even study in Pakistan:
- YouTube
ÐивÑÑÑÑÑ Ð²Ñдео, ÑлÑÑайÑе ÑлÑÐ±Ð»ÐµÐ½Ñ Ð¼ÑзикÑ, заванÑажÑйÑе оÑигÑналÑний конÑÐµÐ½Ñ Ñ Ð´ÑлÑÑÑÑÑ Ð²ÑÑм Ñим Ñз дÑÑзÑми, ÑÑм'ÑÑ Ð¹ ÑÑлим ÑвÑÑом на YouTube.
www.youtube.com
The problem is a large number of Afghan refugees refused to obtain PoR cards. How can any country house undocumented, unvetted people?
If undocumented migrants DO NOT pose a problem or a threat, then why did the EU just expel 29% of them and is expected to fast track the expulsion of more next year?
Out of the total number of 105,865 non-EU citizens who were instructed to leave an EU member state, 26,600 were repatriated to other countries.
Finally and most importantly before anyone in India lectures PAKISTAN and Pakistanis on what we have done for Afghanistan, what are YOU doing? Where were you for 40 years? Why did your government refuse to accept Afghan Refugees despite pleas and applications after the soviet invasion, with New Delhi citing that it had no obligation to do so as it wasn't a signatory to the UN Convention of Refugees?
Why did India refuse Asylum and refugee of over 60,000 Afghan's from entering India after the Taliban takeover in 2021?
Afghan Refugees in India Highlight the Need for Indian Domestic Refugee Law
India will offer ad hoc emergency visas to Afghan refugees, but lacks any domestic law to protect asylum seekers long term.
www.justsecurity.org
The Endless Wait of Afghan Refugees
Afghan refugees in India fear ending up with nothing. Fariba Hakimi, 42, escaped from Afghanistan in 2018 with two of her daughters. Her other two daughters were sold to the Taliban by her husband...
pulitzercenter.org