If the Sikhs decided to cast their lot with Muslims and Pakistan in 1947??

[Aka123]

The cunning Hindu whispers discontent and discord among the peoples of the Subcontinent. Beware his lies.

Don't bring religion again and again. If I start speaking about your religion, you will start shouting blasphemy or die of a heart attack!!
But I won't do that as I respect all religion and know that their are nuisances in every religion.

 

[INDIC]

In relation to the topic, I think that Sikhs made a mistake in the 1940s. Their presence would have been welcomed and would have made Pakistan a more inclusive country and society. Their mistake was our and their loss. Punjab would not have been divided, first between East and West Punjab, and then East Punjab into Himachal Pradesh, Haryana, and Punjab. Also, Kashmir would not have been a problem.

Since everyone know what happened to Ahmedis. They were initially welcomed too.

 

[sms]

But Bhindranwale is considered a hero and a martyr among sikhs in the diaspora? I have seen huge pictures of Bhindranwale and Beant singh at Gurdwaras in Canada and USA.

Morons are every where in the world. There may be people in your neighborhood who think OBL was a hero sent by almighty.

Go check..

 

[Youknowme]

It seems like sikhs as a community would have been better off if they decided to cast their lot with the muslims instead of treacherous Congress in 1947?
If the sikhs had decided to join Pakistan, partition of punjab province would not have been necessary, and forced migration and massacres in punjab could have been avoided.

But instead sikhs had a foolish leader like Master Tara singh, who was waving a sword at Punjab Assembly in Lahore and foolishly declaring that sikhs can prevent the creation of Pakistan. He also said an inflammatory speech about muslims.

And within 3 decades after partition, sikhs were betrayed and back-stabbed by the treacherous hindu baniyas. They were further humiliated by Operation bluestar 1984. The indian government also took away haryana and himachal pradesh from the sikhs, who were now left with a truncated punjab where sikhs are barely 60% of the population.

Looking at the post independence political situation in Pakistan where Begali denied there share of resources and current situation in Pakistan where minority (Even Shia and ahemadia) Sikh would be more happy to be part of India and part away from Pakistan

Sikh being the community loyal to there country alway contributed to the growth of the country. Pakistan has done all failed attempt to fuel the khalistan movement but It has failed

1984 was very unfortunate and as a Indian we stand together with each other.....

 

[Ayush]

So, sikhs would have been better off in Pakistan
I wonder how hard @Flamingo or @Abingdonboy will hit me, if I tell them this joke.

I wonder if Manmohan would have become pakistani PM or whether there would have been a sikh army chief of Pakistan.
Oh! I forgot,the constitution of Pakistan barres a non muslim from holding such posts...

 

[INDIC]

How Pakistani textbook defame Sikhs and Hindus.

Class: 4
Subject: Social Studies
Pages: 80-81
“Sikhs destroyed the Muslim towns from the river Sutlej to the river Jamna. A
number of times the Sikhs crossed the river Jamna and looted and destroyed the
settlements of the Muslims. They truned the mosques into their ‘Gurdawaras’,
demolished the shrines of the Muslim saints and burnt religious schools and
libraries.”
Authors: Dr Miss Ferozah Yasmeen, Dr Azhar Hamid, Mian Muhammad Javed
Akhtar, Nasir-ur-Din Ghaznavi, Muhammad Zubair Hashmi, Bashir-ud-Din Malik
and Qazi Ajjad Ahmed.
Comment (inside backcover): “The Punjab Texbook Board is your own
organization. It produces quality and cost effective textbooks for you.”

Class: 4
Subject: Social Studies
Pages: 83
“The Muslims of Pakistan provided all the facilities to the Hindus and Sikhs who
left for India. But the Hindus and Sikhs looted the Muslims in India with both
hands and they attacked their caravans, busses and railway trains. Therefore
about 1 million Muslims were martyred on their way to Pakistan.”
21
Authors: Dr Miss Ferozah Yasmeen, Dr Azhar Hamid, Mian Muhammad Javed
Akhtar, Nasir-ur-Din Ghaznavi, Muhammad Zubair Hashmi, Bashir-ud-Din Malik
and Qazi Ajjad Ahmed.
Comment (inside backcover): “Approved by Federal Ministry of Education,
Government of Pakistan, Islamabad.”

Pages: 17
“Shah Wali Ullah (RA) was a mujadid of the 18th century….He knew that the
Sikhs, Marhattas were the enemies of Muslims.”
Text No. 27
Class: 9-10
Subject: Pakistan Studies

Here is what 70% of student population in Pakistan study | AA@Counter Terrorism, Imperialism, Extremism and Bigotry

 

[Youknowme]

So, sikhs would have been better off in Pakistan
I wonder how hard @Flamingo or @Abingdonboy will hit me, if I tell them this joke.

I wonder if Manmohan would have become pakistani PM or whether there would have been a sikh army chief of Pakistan.
Oh! I forgot,the constitution of Pakistan barres a non muslim from holding such posts...

They leave sports also .....If I m not wrong Non muslim can't be captain of the Cricket Team

BTW what about Sunny Deol

He would have done Border, Gaddar from other side ????

 

[kaykay]

Go tell this joke to an Indian Sikh and he will break your jaws right there!! They are extremely extremely extremely patriotic people and have a histroy of sacrifices for India.

 

[Arav_Rana]

Thread poster started thred at 7:42 am. Wow morning se hi sateya jate ho.
Why too many if exist in your world. Why dnt you people try to treat well your own countryman 1st. What have you done for your minority people.
And about sikh people. Well we are lucky that we have them. And we proud of them. We all fought together for freedom and nation. We didn't fight for our religon. We fought for whole country. Country love is still out of your mind reach. And people who got land in name of religon can't understand this.

 

[Ayush]

They leave sports also .....If I m not wrong Non muslim can't be captain of the Cricket Team

BTW what about Sunny Deol

He would have done Border, Gaddar from other side ????

Don't know abt becoming captain, but discrimination does take place, due to which yousuf youhana became md. yousouf

 

[third eye]

Whenever we have nothing or little else to do we start daydreaming.

This ' what if' thread is one of them.

The poster ought to know that communities did not have the option to chose India or Pakistan - only the princely states could. The rulers were hardly Pro Muslim hence all states of Punjab chose India over Pakistan.

 

[airuah]

why the fck does people want to open a thread for discussions that have no relevance today at all....

the threads like these" what if this had happened types?" are the craziest of them all.....and they are started by people who have an inferiority complex and they always wish that they were more than than what they are........

well people get real (or rather get a life)......your dreams are not gonna happen...its year 2013 and not 1947 to dream if things could happen differently.......

if you want amusement ,why don't you guys open threads "what if superman was real?" , "what if superman and batman fought for Pakistan in 1971 war?"..."what if Pakistanis could breathe underwater?"......

 

[Black Widow]

Today is Eid, at least today stop spreading lie and misinformation..


Your Allah will not grant you Jannat ..

 

[Aka123]

why the fck does people want to open a thread for discussions that have no relevance today at all....

the threads like these" what if this had happened types?" are the craziest of them all.....and they are started by people who have an inferiority complex and they always wish that they were more than than what they are........

well people get real (or rather get a life)......your dreams are not gonna happen...its year 2013 and not 1947 to dream if things could happen differently.......

if you want amusement ,why don't you guys open threads "what if superman was real?" , "what if superman and batman fought for Pakistan in 1971 war?"..."what if Pakistanis could breathe underwater?"......

 

[Khsaud31]

So why do sikhs say that "If we had a leader like Mr.Jinnah we would have been in our own homeland" .

LONG LIVE PAKISTAN

***** please there is no misinformation, nothing more than just a say of opinion

what if india had not fought with china in Sino-india war
"LONG LIVE PAKISTAN "