Husain Haqqani leaks secret order by Yousaf Raza Gillani

[TheDarkKnight]

I never wrote "dont accuse these politicians of anything -". But accusing them of a capital crime, rather than embezzlement? In Pakistan that's incitement to murder, since Pakistan has an ugly record of vigilante and mob "justice".

So don't accuse anybody of a crime that involves capital punishment due to fear of mob justice and let the crime go unpunished even on the political arena? Mob justice doesn't happen after people find out that the accussation is of the nature that potentially carries a capital punishment per our constitution - moderate offences such theft, burglary, harassment etc have faced mob justice.

Why don't you study Pakistani history more to come up with an answer yourself?

You are the one who said there is a 'fashion' in Pakistan about people taking law in their own hands. I only asked to back up your claim even with one example where a politician accused of a treasonous act faced mob justice - examples are there for honor killings, blasphemy due to known social problems - but none as far as I know for treason accusations against politicians.

Anyway let the mods know if these posts have put our honorable ex ambassador Haqqani who is in US, ex prime minister Gilani's, and ex president Zardari's lives in anymore danger.

 

[Solomon2]

So don't accuse anybody of a crime that involves capital punishment due to fear of mob justice and let the crime go unpunished even on the political arena?

There's no foundation for accusing - the necklace, Gilani, right? - with a capital crime, rather than embezzlement. That doesn't mean advocating that the crime - or alleged crime, or stupidity - should go unpunished by the courts, or by parliament, or by the voters.

Mob justice doesn't happen after people find out that the accussation is of the nature that potentially carries a capital punishment per our constitution - moderate offences such theft, burglary, harassment etc have faced mob justice.

What a sad commentary.

You are the one who said there is a 'fashion' in Pakistan about people taking law in their own hands. I only asked to back up your claim even with one example where a politician accused of a treasonous act faced mob justice -

No, you didn't use the term "mob justice", you wrote "Has anyone taken law in their own hands -". Still, I suppose every blasphemer is a kind of politician, don't you?

Anyway let the mods know if these posts have put our honorable ex ambassador Haqqani who is in US, ex prime minister Gilani's, and ex president Zardari's lives in anymore danger.

So if they DO come to harm then it's somehow my fault?

 

[TheDarkKnight]

There's no foundation for accusing - the necklace, Gilani, right? - with a capital crime, rather than embezzlement. That doesn't mean advocating that the crime - or alleged crime, or stupidity - should go unpunished by the courts, or by parliament, or by the voters.

No, you didn't use the term "mob justice", you wrote "Has anyone taken law in their own hands -". Still, I suppose every blasphemer is a kind of politician, don't you?

What jiberrish is this! Stop equating reactions to blasphemy with accusations of treason against these politicians. Accusations and political opinions are made by public against individuals, especially public office holders, based on what ever evidence is revealed in public. If some lunatics take law in their hands for other offences, like blasphemy, due to their religious and cultural issues, that doesnt mean the public should seal their mouths for these politicians about alleged treason acts. And you haven't even produced a single example of mob justice or people taking law in their hands against politician due to treason accusations - the so called fashion thats prevalent only in Pakistan according to you.