What's new

How India's 'Garden City' became a garbage city

haidian

BANNED
Joined
Dec 18, 2010
Messages
4,888
Reaction score
1
Country
China
Location
China
How India's 'Garden City' became a garbage city
AFP | Updated: Jan 25, 2017, 11.22 AM IST
56772656.jpg

BENGALURU: The stench of rubbish hanging over swathes of Bengaluru is so powerful it rouses residents in the middle of the night, the fetid result of a trash crisis that threatens its reputation as one of India's nicest places to live.

Hailed first as the country's Garden City and then its Silicon Valley, drawing in multinational IT firms and their monied executives, today Bengaluru is paying a heavy price for its success — it's a city overflowing with garbage, its infrastructure and waste collection services unable to keep up with decades of unchecked growth.

"You will wake from your dreams because of the smell," says local Kamesh Rastogi.

"You have to close the doors, but even then there is no respite," he adds.

The capital of Karnataka state, Bengaluru was once a favourite retreat for families seeking respite from the heat of the surrounding southern farming plains and particularly popular with people in retirement.

Located on a plateau and blessed with a relatively cool climate, the city is dotted with public parks and gardens as well as a network of lakes.

But since marketing itself as India's tech hub, drawing in a raft of multinationals, Bengaluru's population has soared from three million at the start of the 1990s to in excess of eight million.

The surge has placed huge pressure on its municipality, which stands accused of inadequate urban planning and, in particular, of failing to cope with the accompanying rise in waste volumes.

When Rastogi, who works for the tech firm Oracle, bought an apartment a decade ago in a leafy suburb called HSR Layout, he thought he was moving into one of Bengaluru's most pristine neighbourhoods.

But as part of efforts to cope with the 3,500 tonnes of rubbish that are generated in the city every day, the municipality reopened a mothballed waste treatment plant near his apartment in 2013.

At the time of construction, the plant was some distance beyond Bengaluru's outskirts but it has since been encircled by the urban sprawl of the last quarter of a century.

Furious residents, many of them executives for international tech companies, set up a neighbourhood association to campaign for the plant's closure and relocation.

Contacted by AFP, management at the plant said an air filter was being installed to clean up emissions but residents are unconvinced.

"I feel I have to be reincarnated to see these changes happening," one of them quipped.

Anger is growing throughout the city, with newspapers carrying stories of litter louts being beaten up on the streets by furious residents.

And rather than its old nickname as India's Garden City, Bengaluru is now simply dubbed garbage city.

The municipality's waste management team turned down several requests to speak to AFP.

But around a hundred CCTV cameras have been installed to catch fly tippers in two districts that have become regular dumping grounds.

The municipality has even installed GPS devices in dump trucks to ensure crews don't take short cuts and is reportedly considering hiring ex-servicemen with the authority to fine offenders to enforce "garbage discipline".

Campaigners say such measures are little more than sticking plasters and the crisis can only be resolved once the municipality increases its capacity to treat rubbish.

"It's mostly what we call trying to douse the fire when it happens, instead of a systemic approach to resolve these issues," said Venkatesh Kannaiah, an activist with the Janaagraha civic organisation.

As awareness grows about the environmental impact of India's increasingly consumerist society, more residents are trying to recycle or setting up their own compost heaps.

"Bengaluru used to be one of the most beautiful cities in India, and look at it now," said Myriam Shankar, a member of the Solid Waste Management Round Table pressure group.

Shankar, an Italian-German, first arrived in India in 2004. Now married to a lawyer, she regards Bengaluru as home.

She and her fellow activists try to raise awareness at schools and in companies about the advantages of recycling.

Shankar believes things have improved inside gated communities, where residents are beginning to come up with their own solutions, but it's a different situation beyond the city's compounds.

"Outside, you have a very diverse society and to get all these people singing to the same tune, it is difficult. You have things like corruption, literacy or illiteracy... It takes time."

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...ecame-a-garbage-city/articleshow/56772655.cms
 
.
How India's 'Garden City' became a garbage city
AFP | Updated: Jan 25, 2017, 11.22 AM IST
56772656.jpg

BENGALURU: The stench of rubbish hanging over swathes of Bengaluru is so powerful it rouses residents in the middle of the night, the fetid result of a trash crisis that threatens its reputation as one of India's nicest places to live.

Hailed first as the country's Garden City and then its Silicon Valley, drawing in multinational IT firms and their monied executives, today Bengaluru is paying a heavy price for its success — it's a city overflowing with garbage, its infrastructure and waste collection services unable to keep up with decades of unchecked growth.

"You will wake from your dreams because of the smell," says local Kamesh Rastogi.

"You have to close the doors, but even then there is no respite," he adds.

The capital of Karnataka state, Bengaluru was once a favourite retreat for families seeking respite from the heat of the surrounding southern farming plains and particularly popular with people in retirement.

Located on a plateau and blessed with a relatively cool climate, the city is dotted with public parks and gardens as well as a network of lakes.

But since marketing itself as India's tech hub, drawing in a raft of multinationals, Bengaluru's population has soared from three million at the start of the 1990s to in excess of eight million.

The surge has placed huge pressure on its municipality, which stands accused of inadequate urban planning and, in particular, of failing to cope with the accompanying rise in waste volumes.

When Rastogi, who works for the tech firm Oracle, bought an apartment a decade ago in a leafy suburb called HSR Layout, he thought he was moving into one of Bengaluru's most pristine neighbourhoods.

But as part of efforts to cope with the 3,500 tonnes of rubbish that are generated in the city every day, the municipality reopened a mothballed waste treatment plant near his apartment in 2013.

At the time of construction, the plant was some distance beyond Bengaluru's outskirts but it has since been encircled by the urban sprawl of the last quarter of a century.

Furious residents, many of them executives for international tech companies, set up a neighbourhood association to campaign for the plant's closure and relocation.

Contacted by AFP, management at the plant said an air filter was being installed to clean up emissions but residents are unconvinced.

"I feel I have to be reincarnated to see these changes happening," one of them quipped.

Anger is growing throughout the city, with newspapers carrying stories of litter louts being beaten up on the streets by furious residents.

And rather than its old nickname as India's Garden City, Bengaluru is now simply dubbed garbage city.

The municipality's waste management team turned down several requests to speak to AFP.

But around a hundred CCTV cameras have been installed to catch fly tippers in two districts that have become regular dumping grounds.

The municipality has even installed GPS devices in dump trucks to ensure crews don't take short cuts and is reportedly considering hiring ex-servicemen with the authority to fine offenders to enforce "garbage discipline".

Campaigners say such measures are little more than sticking plasters and the crisis can only be resolved once the municipality increases its capacity to treat rubbish.

"It's mostly what we call trying to douse the fire when it happens, instead of a systemic approach to resolve these issues," said Venkatesh Kannaiah, an activist with the Janaagraha civic organisation.

As awareness grows about the environmental impact of India's increasingly consumerist society, more residents are trying to recycle or setting up their own compost heaps.

"Bengaluru used to be one of the most beautiful cities in India, and look at it now," said Myriam Shankar, a member of the Solid Waste Management Round Table pressure group.

Shankar, an Italian-German, first arrived in India in 2004. Now married to a lawyer, she regards Bengaluru as home.

She and her fellow activists try to raise awareness at schools and in companies about the advantages of recycling.

Shankar believes things have improved inside gated communities, where residents are beginning to come up with their own solutions, but it's a different situation beyond the city's compounds.

"Outside, you have a very diverse society and to get all these people singing to the same tune, it is difficult. You have things like corruption, literacy or illiteracy... It takes time."

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...ecame-a-garbage-city/articleshow/56772655.cms

Yup I am from Bangalore and I know we can manage our waste better. feels pathetic at how we Bangaloreans dump garbage here and there :( lack of rule of law and lack of law enforcement making people take things for granted.
 
.
Bangalore was the best city in India during the early 2000's, Relatively clean, Green and with nice weather.. Awesome pub culture and night life

Now it's just another Indian city, Dusty unplanned and chaotic
 
.
Even Chennai is not different. Pass through Royapettah flyover to see rubbish spread across the region. The problem is because of huge population in these cities. There is no spread out of population in most of India, as scarcity of resources especially water and electricity makes it difficult. Besides, no rain and barren lands. People flock to big cities essentially making it big urban agglomerations. The City corporations cannot really much do when the poorest of the poor came and build slums across.
 
.
Even Chennai is not different. Pass through Royapettah flyover to see rubbish spread across the region. The problem is because of huge population in these cities. There is no spread out of population in most of India, as scarcity of resources especially water and electricity makes it difficult. Besides, no rain and barren lands. People flock to big cities essentially making it big urban agglomerations. The City corporations cannot really much do when the poorest of the poor came and build slums across.
Even in Hyderabad if you go out of tech city..Poor waste management..
 
. .
Bangalore was the best city in India during the early 2000's, Relatively clean, Green and with nice weather.. Awesome pub culture and night life

Now it's just another Indian city, Dusty unplanned and chaotic
Bangalore is declared as the most dynamic city in the world last week..
The rankings are based on parameters such as population, technology and R&D, connectivity, output and corporate activity, education, and real estate investment. These are rankings released by real estate consultancy firm James Lang Laselle at the World Economic Forum in Davos..
 
.
Bangalore is declared as the most dynamic city in the world last week..
The rankings are based on parameters such as population, technology and R&D, connectivity, output and corporate activity, education, and real estate investment. These are rankings released by real estate consultancy firm James Lang Laselle at the World Economic Forum in Davos..

Thats based on it being a center for Information technology, And foreign investment

Here were discussing on livability i dont think anyone who has been visiting Bangalore need a consultancy firm affirm how the city has turned to worse over the decades

The issue is unmitigated, Unplanned development for the sake of development.. There needs to be more environmental awareness by those authorities
 
Last edited:
.
Yes, We need a robust garbage cleaning system. May be a fertilizer plant using garbage or a power plant using garbage will be very nice. My city has a very robust garbage collection system.
 
.
Bangalore is declared as the most dynamic city in the world last week..
The rankings are based on parameters such as population, technology and R&D, connectivity, output and corporate activity, education, and real estate investment. These are rankings released by real estate consultancy firm James Lang Laselle at the World Economic Forum in Davos..

Too much population and too many IT companies setting shops. Bangalore infrastructure is not able to cope with the growth.
 
.
Yes, We need a robust garbage cleaning system. May be a fertilizer plant using garbage or a power plant using garbage will be very nice. My city has a very robust garbage collection system.

Indians need to put garbage in the trush can first. The parents than need to teach the kids. In the old days, would the Dalits collect the garbage burn them?
 
Last edited:
.
Indians need to put garbage in the trust can first. The parents than need to teach the kids. In the old days, would the Dalits collect the garbage burn them?

Dont know, but they will all certainly have better spelling skills than you will ever have.
 
.
Bangalore was the best city in India during the early 2000's, Relatively clean, Green and with nice weather.. Awesome pub culture and night life

Now it's just another Indian city, Dusty unplanned and chaotic
True sir, this is due to the mass migration from villages and towns to the cities.
The city planning goes for a toss due to such humongous human tide.
I predict the situation becoming more severe unless we invest heavily in tier 2 and tier 3 cities.
 
. .
True sir, this is due to the mass migration from villages and towns to the cities.
The city planning goes for a toss due to such humongous human tide.
I predict the situation becoming more severe unless we invest heavily in tier 2 and tier 3 cities.

Town planning need to be strictly adhered to, Then some of these problems can be overcome.. I think the perennial problem in South Asia is you can get anything passed for an illegal buck by the authorities, Squatters will get political backing by local politicians.. Most of it down to corruption
 
.
Back
Top Bottom