How common are blasphemy lynchings in Bangladesh and Afghanistan?

[Vikki]

I was just wondering why lynchings related to blasphemy dont occur in BD and Afg when both those countries are as illiterate or as underdeveloped as pak if not worse.
Both those countries follow the same hanafi version of islam like pakistan too.

 

[SecularNationalist]

Blasphemy lynchings don't happen in other Muslim countries as well. Pakistan is the only country where they happen.
Say thanks to Saudi Arabian oil money which funded Wahhabism in pakistani and erode all the secular values ,tolerance we once had .

 

[aziqbal]

oh please a indian member talking about lynching

like he doest know about the Mob lynching in India

talk about taking advantage of a situation and pleading innocent

mods issue a ban for his thread

Mob Lynching: The Epidemic Of New India

Mob Lynching: The Epidemic Of New India

Shilpa Roy, Guwahati “All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood” – United Nations Charter, 1945 As the cases of mob lynching are rising recently, they have become...

www.northeasttoday.in

 

[hussain0216]

I was just wondering why lynchings related to blasphemy dont occur in BD and Afg when both those countries are as illiterate or as underdeveloped as pak if not worse.
Both those countries follow the same hanafi version of islam like pakistan too.

Hindus got hammered in Bangladesh only a few weeks ago

And afghanis have pretty much wiped Hindus out

 

[Sulman Badshah]

It happened in Afghanistan, Murder of Farkhunda Malikzada is one example of it

and if we compare with BD , then Pakistani Molvi's are more organized and powerful here and people follow them blindly (they create the narrative of lynching and taking law into their hands)


And Last year 10 Pakistani's were brutally murdered in SHINNING INDIA, no justice have been served to them so far, none of the people have been convicted so far

as compared to India if we look at Pakistan than more than 100 have been arrested in the country (some will get death sentences by next year, we are sure of it)

 

[Titanium100]

All these 3 mentioned countries are not Lynch countries and if it happens it is very very rare incidents where as in India 100 lynchings can happen in just one day because it has deep rooted lynch culture.

The Indian IQ

 

[Maula Jatt]

We follow mostly Barelvi sect (shrine/sufi oriented) - who ever converted almost always converted to this sect
I don't know about Bangladesh but in Afghan and on the other side of Indus, they don't follow this sect

This sect due to years of I'd say neglect- nicely/discrimination, shunning by MS despite being majority in favor of some hard core people made them react - They chose this moment to show they are loco too and aren't soft

This is purely just my opinion though or what I feel

 

[Vikki]

It happened in Afghanistan, Murder of Farkhunda Malikzada is one example of it

and if we compare with BD , then Pakistani Molvi's are more organized and powerful here and people follow them blindly (they create the narrative of lynching and taking law into their hands)

Ooh..i didnt know about the afghan incident .thnx for the information..anyway not much comes out of afghanistan owing to absence of much electronic media...

 

[JackTheRipper]

I was just wondering why lynchings related to blasphemy dont occur in BD and Afg when both those countries are as illiterate or as underdeveloped as pak if not worse.
Both those countries follow the same hanafi version of islam like pakistan too.

No, It happens in Bangladesh,

Bangladesh's Hindus living in fear following mob attacks

Homes and temples of Hindu Bangladeshis have been torched across the country, and at least seven killed.

www.bbc.com

Two Hindu men killed, temples vandalised in Bangladesh violence

Religious violence erupts after photo circulated on social media shows the Quran placed on the knee of a Hindu deity.

www.aljazeera.com

In Afghanistan, they do not need to lynch, they have sharp knives to slaughter.

I have heard news, 1 Afghani killed European who left Islam in Europe.

Afghan man sentenced to life for killing converted Muslim – DW – 02/09/2018

An Afghan man has been sentenced to life in prison for killing a woman because she had converted to Christianity. The court recognized a 'very high degree of culpability' in handing down its decision.

www.dw.com

You should have asked, Blasphemy happens in Bangladesh, Afghanistan or not?
Yes, it happens but reasons may be different, Blasphemy may be insult of Quran, Prophet, Prophet Companions and several other reasons.

And Hindus can kill for eating beef, Sikh can also kills you for Blasphemy, and some news are also circulated few weeks ago, so blasphemy is different on different areas, based on different religions, sect and etc. But in Pakistan situation is even worst, too much violence and extremism after Zia ul Haq.

* Sorry for my weak English and if my posts hurt you..

 

[Vikki]

https://www.ucanews.com/news/mob-lynches-bangladeshi-muslim-for-alleged-blasphemy/90099

Oh my bad...it seems Bangladesh is no better either...maybe becoz indian media doesnt cover BD news that much I am not aware of these things in BD..another thing maybe my lack of knowledge of bengali.
As urdu is understood very well in india we get to know everything that happens in pak.

We follow mostly Barelvi sect (shrine/sufi oriented) - who ever converted almost always converted to this sect
I don't know about Bangladesh but in Afghan and on the other side of Indus, they don't follow this sect

This sect due to years of I'd say neglect- nicely/discrimination, shunning by MS despite being majority in favor of some hard core people made them react - They chose this moment to show they are loco too and aren't soft

This is purely just my opinion though or what I feel

What is MS?

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

It is a cultural thing. Similarly, lynchings happen in India for cow and other religious reasons. How many are punished? Consenting adults get lynched or prosecuted for 'love jihad' marriage. Incapability of accepting or dealing with differences in modern times.

 

[Vikki]

No, It happens in Bangladesh,

Bangladesh's Hindus living in fear following mob attacks

Homes and temples of Hindu Bangladeshis have been torched across the country, and at least seven killed.

www.bbc.com

Two Hindu men killed, temples vandalised in Bangladesh violence

Religious violence erupts after photo circulated on social media shows the Quran placed on the knee of a Hindu deity.

www.aljazeera.com

In Afghanistan, they do not need to lynch, they have sharp knives to slaughter.

I have heard news, 1 Afghani killed European who left Islam in Europe.

Afghan man sentenced to life for killing converted Muslim – DW – 02/09/2018

An Afghan man has been sentenced to life in prison for killing a woman because she had converted to Christianity. The court recognized a 'very high degree of culpability' in handing down its decision.

www.dw.com

You should have asked, Blasphemy happens in Bangladesh, Afghanistan or not?
Yes, it happens but reasons may be different, Blasphemy may be insult of Quran, Prophet, Prophet Companions and several other reasons.

And Hindus can kill for eating beef, Sikh can also kills you for Blasphemy, and some news are also circulated few weeks ago, so blasphemy is different on different areas, based on different religions, sect and etc

* Sorry for my weak English..

Edited the title...I must add hindus dont lynch anyone on religious grounds or for dietary habits.
Hindus mostly dont have the concept of any religious affiliation as we are divided on caste lines.
The lynchings you heard on news are done by some right wing groups mostly in backward state of UP...this is a recent phenomena...
You would not hear such news from other parts of india.
Yes, hindu muslim riots happen where both sides suffer according to the proportion of their population.

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Edited the title...I must add hindus dont lynch anyone on religious grounds or for dietary habits.
Hindus mostly dont have the concept of any religious affiliation as we are divided on caste lines.
The lynchings you heard in news are done by some right wing groups mostly in backward state of UP.
You would not hear such news from other parts of india.

Recently, a South Indian Muslim man was lynched and hacked to pieces for wanting to marry Hindu woman.

 

[Vikki]

Recently, a South Indian Muslim man was lynched and hacked to pieces for wanting to marry Hindu woman.

Is that related to blasphemy lynching? It was an honour killing...I repeat hindus dont take religious criticism seriously...we are even free to mock our gods and holy books.
We dont identify ourselves with religion...we have different identities.
Caste and language are more dominant identities in India( but you wouldnt see anyone shivering with anger if their caste or language is made fun of).
The lynchings where muslims were victims were not related to blasphemy..it got more to do with hatred for muslims....cow is just an excuse.
Most kerala hindus eat beef...nobody looks down upon them.

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Honor killing

The lynching in Pakistan of the Sri Lankan is also 'honor killing' stemming from a religious socio- culture rather than religion. The transgression he is accused of does not warrant death punishment in religion.