What's new

How can Pakistan counter India’s ABM system?

The only successful way of countering an ABM system is to develop one of our own. We can upgrade our missiles all we want but even if there is a 10% chance of our missiles getting intercepted, that puts us at a serious disadvantage via-a-via India. Developing a counter system to intercept Indian incoming attack is the only way we can answer such a threat.
However obtaining such a capability would prove to be challenging, but with our track record, certainly not impossible.

sounds like a good solution but nonetheless will prove difficult for Pakistan ABM systems do not come cheap and for Pak to fund development of a system would be a strain on the already fragile economy perhaps Pak should undertake a joint development with China that would definitely be a way to counter the Indian ABM system
 
.
sounds like a good solution but nonetheless will prove difficult for Pakistan ABM systems do not come cheap and for Pak to fund development of a system would be a strain on the already fragile economy perhaps Pak should undertake a joint development with China that would definitely be a way to counter the Indian ABM system

Pakistans economy maybe fragile or whatever you may want to call it, but it isnt going to remain the same forever. Fact is we are constantly developing and upgrading our strategic assets and that is not happening without money. Make no mistake about it if we need to develop such a system arranging funds would not be an issue.
 
.
^^ in that case you need to cover Lahore, Islamabad,Rawalpindi and Karachi with ABM shield as they produce most of Pak GDP
 
.
.
Pakistan realistically cannot counter indian missile shield! however, what pakistan can do is unleash such a salvo of so many missiles onto india that some do manage to get through the missile shield. that is the only hope Pakistan currently can have. Other than that the geographic proximty of both nations is such that any missile shield close to the border will have very little time of interception.

In the case of india it has depth unlike Pakistan which is width is pretty shallow compared to india.

Livefist: Indian Missile Shield Ready: DRDO Chief

its alomost surreal how far the indians have come in indengious ICMB & ABM defense tech so quickly

Livefist: India Tests Advanced Interceptor Missile In User Config

its alomost surreal how far the indians have come in indengious ICMB & ABM defense tech so quickly

Livefist: India Tests Advanced Interceptor Missile In User Config

surreal???????? what's surreal its all thanks to RUSSIA!
 
. .
Pakistan realistically cannot counter indian missile shield! however, what pakistan can do is unleash such a salvo of so many missiles onto india that some do manage to get through the missile shield.
Firstly lean English it's Pakistan and India ( not pakistan and india ) if intentional at least hav some respect for ur nation.

Secondly Wow so after you have ur salvo of missiles and according to your logic our ABM will be dried our leaving us nothing but open our umbrellas and wonder ????


AHH WAT THE HELL you can even notify us so that we could turn off our radars, airborne warning systems, quick reaction systems, active satellite systems and all the systems costing billions of $, 'cause U came up with such a mind blowin brilliant plan.

Grow up kid.
 
.
^^ in that case you need to cover Lahore, Islamabad,Rawalpindi and Karachi with ABM shield as they produce most of Pak GDP

Add Faisalabad to the list as well as it has most of our textile industry.
 
.
Pakistans economy maybe fragile or whatever you may want to call it, but it isnt going to remain the same forever. Fact is we are constantly developing and upgrading our strategic assets and that is not happening without money. Make no mistake about it if we need to develop such a system arranging funds would not be an issue.

How ur so sure of that??? The miracles don't happen over night. And it take decades to build good economy that too when u have every ingredient of it.
 
.
Firstly lean English it's Pakistan and India ( not pakistan and india ) if intentional at least hav some respect for ur nation.

Secondly Wow so after you have ur salvo of missiles and according to your logic our ABM will be dried our leaving us nothing but open our umbrellas and wonder ????


AHH WAT THE HELL you can even notify us so that we could turn off our radars, airborne warning systems, quick reaction systems, active satellite systems and all the systems costing billions of $, 'cause U came up with such a mind blowin brilliant plan.

Grow up kid.

:hitwall: GOray chalaygayay lekin tumhay chor gayaay! it doesn't matter if i write india or pakistan with capital or not.

and comment only if you understand. Ask your army men no missile shield is 100% capable of defense some missiels will eventually get through! it is not a BLOODY wall ask your army men before commenting!
 
.
iCEMAN.

How can Russia provide the indian ABM system WHEN they dont have one THEMSELVES.

This is a indengious programme developed by indians FOR india

just like the ARIHANT nuke sub & the AGNI FIVE ICMB.

However the indians are JOINTLY devloping FGFA fighter project and the BRAHMOS cruise missles HYPER SONIC version
 
.
iCEMAN.

How can Russia provide the indian ABM system WHEN they dont have one THEMSELVES.

This is a indengious programme developed by indians FOR india

just like the ARIHANT nuke sub & the AGNI FIVE ICMB.

However the indians are JOINTLY devloping FGFA fighter project and the BRAHMOS cruise missles HYPER SONIC version


are you serios!! RUSSIA HAS an ABM! S-300PMU-2 please tell me you heard of it!

Soviet A-35 anti-ballistic missile system, designed to protect Moscow. was deployed in 71!
 
.
are you serios!! RUSSIA HAS an ABM! S-300PMU-2 please tell me you heard of it!

Soviet A-35 anti-ballistic missile system, designed to protect Moscow. was deployed in 71!

Yes Russians have very good Anti-ballistic and air-defense system available but their anti-ballistic missile system are not as accurate and hence use Nuclear warhead in proximity fuse mode... while Indian Anti-ballistic missiles use the direct hit and proximity-fuse aswell for different layers... certain advancements are also there over Russian system such gimbaled warhead.

The Electronics(solid state) used on Indian system are much better than any Russian or Chinese Anti-missile or aircraft system... and can perform much better tracking upto much longer ranges and cannot be jammed... yes there has been Israeli assistance with the electronics part... and thats mutual.

Even my donkey knows better!

That can be seen.. demonstration not required.
 
.
According to the latest interview if Dr. Saraswat, The Indian BDM system requires 4 interceptors (2 PAD's and 2AAD's) for a kill probability of ~99.5 % for intermediate missiles of upto 2000 km range. It is quite clear that the armed forces (IAF) and DRDO have mutually agreed on the requirement for a new exo-atmospheric interceptor to tide over the limitations of the PAD (as it was a modified prithvi missile with inherent limitations). Therefore the phase 1 operationalization of Indian BMD is still a few years away. However, we can expect AAD's to be operationalized as an interim first step towards a robust Pakistan specific BMD. From what I understand, a single launcher carries 6 AAD interceptors and a battery should have about 4 to 6 launchers (as is the norm with air defence units). If we assume 2 to 4 batteries for a city like Delhi, we are talking about > 96 AAD interceptors. Once PDV is inducted (sometime after 2015) and phase 1 becomes operational, the system should have commensurate number of PDV's as per the operational scenarios. This translates to the ability to target more than 20 incoming intermediate range missiles overall. Therefore Pakistan would have to launch atleast 20 to have a reasonable certainty of getting through Delhi's defences.

However, looking at India's plans for its BMD, it seems that is will be based on a two tiered system with phase 2 planned for testing from next year. If that's the case, it would make sense for India to have short range (current) LRTR's and associated missile batteries deployed to counter the Pakistani threat while the longer range LRTR (currently under development) and phase 2 batteries deployed against the Chinese threats. While the radars will in all likelihood be placed closer to the borders, India it seems has a long way to go with phase 1 deployment for major cities (atleast 2018), phase 2 deployment of major cities (atleast 2024) with an integrated air defence network comprising newly inducted air defense radars (both aerial and ground based). Pakistani planners have atleast 6 years to develop adequate countermeasures to try and blunt the Indian BMD. The best way is to increase missile range so as to have DT missile which have a higher speed and also fly at relatively low altitudes ( < 50 km) to make interception difficult. Another method to look into are MIRV's ofcourse with dummy warheads which would seriously blunt Indian BMD. I am sure Pakistan would be already developing such systems though from the available pictures and some videos of Pakistani missile launches, Pakistan is yet to test MIRV capability.
 
.
Yes Russians have very good Anti-ballistic and air-defense system available but their anti-ballistic missile system are not as accurate and hence use Nuclear warhead in proximity fuse mode... while Indian Anti-ballistic missiles use the direct hit and proximity-fuse aswell for different layers... certain advancements are also there over Russian system such gimbaled warhead.

The Electronics(solid state) used on Indian system are much better than any Russian or Chinese Anti-missile or aircraft system... and can perform much better tracking upto much longer ranges and cannot be jammed... yes there has been Israeli assistance with the electronics part... and thats mutual.



That can be seen.. demonstration not required.


and what is the source of this super secret information??
did you team-up with assanage on this?


the fact is that no system can prevent a MAD scenario when the warring nations are next-door neighbors...if the missiles had to travel thousands of kms...it'd have been easier shooting them down...
you have to detect a missile launch and need significant time to prep your own ABM shayBMs...India has tested the ABMS in the most ideal of scenarios possible...a bloody simulation!!!
this ABM deal imo is for show and propaganda...just as the nukes of the 2 countires...
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom