Hajj cost may increase to Rs550,000 this year

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Maybe the Government should stop taxing people to death if it's not willing to provide any facilities.

Not everyone in Pakistan can afford to live in a Banigala Palace you know and fly around in a helicopter, looking down at people.

Maybe if everyone actually paid their taxes, didn't steal gas, electricity and water, the government wouldn't have to keep raising the direct and indirect taxes on the existing tiny tax paying base.

 

[El Sidd]

Maybe if everyone actually paid their taxes, didn't steal gas, electricity and water, the government wouldn't have to keep raising the direct and indirect taxes on the existing tiny tax paying base.

The government is obligated by the constitution to make provisions and take measures to promote Muslim way of life and the ease of it.

Indirect taxes are not being collected from a tiny base. It is being imposed on everything and everyone.

 

[HAIDER]

Even doing third marriage was not necessary.. Even he coming in politics was not necessary, even his birth was not necessary.
You tell me, what relief he brought to Pakistanis? Price of Everything has increased. People are committing suicides, and we are happy that Pakistans image has improved. Achar dalain image ka?
I am afraid that day is not far, when he will be kicked out of govt with a shout: don't come back again.

Another increase by KSA govt. Pak govt is not responsible to pay KSA govt increase in Haj cost every year.
https://www.news18.com/news/world/s...t-haj-pilgrimage-to-get-costlier-2357119.html

 

[fisher1]

Are you paying for the sangats visiting kp or govt has subsidized it lately? Man you are one jealous bratty Muslim.

I am one angry Muslim not a jealous one. Because Kartarpur was made with my tax money and i don't give my permission for it to be used on building shirk houses. It's a right that Islam gives to me.

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/130747/ruling-on-a-muslim-bequeathing-money-for-building-a-church

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/501...ns-for-the-church-will-he-fasting-be-accepted

I wish my tax money was rather spent on sending people willing to go to Hajj, on anything than building places where Kufr and Shirk is done.

What does that have to do with anything? Is Kartarpur in Saudi Arabia requiring international travel?

The tax money wasted on Kartarpur could've been spent on Hajj subsidy. Sikhs could've been taxed heavily but they can visit Pakistan cheaper than i can buy chalghoozas.


Oh and before someone twists and makes my comments anti-Islamic and make me an extremist.

Let it be known. I have zero issue with Sikhs building their worship places with their own money. THEIR OWN MONEY is the keyword. In fact, i have no issue if the government fed the poor sikhs with my tax money.

In fact, i once happily bought a mobile from a Sikh when i could've brought it from countless Muslims, i was raised up in a school with Christian friends who i helped in countless ways. So my advance middle finger here to the people who will twist my post to make me someone who wants to spread racial hatred or extremism.They should read the links i posted and understand the issue.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

The government is obligated by the constitution to make provisions and take measures to promote Muslim way of life and the ease of it.

Indirect taxes are not being collected from a tiny base. It is being imposed on everything and everyone.

Yes - that's why Pakistanis have access to airplanes and transport. Islam calls for those who can afford the Hajj to perform it.

Indirect taxes are collected because the direct tax base is so small.

 

[El Sidd]

Yes - that's why Pakistanis have access to airplanes and transport. Islam calls for those who can afford the Hajj to perform it.

Indirect taxes are collected because the direct tax base is so small.

What is the problem then if there is ample amount of indirect taxes to be invested back into the community?

The constitution obligates the government to make Muslim way of life easier and encourage that the community fulfills all basic tenants of Islam. The government if it cares for the argument of those who can afford should then also define ' istetaat ' of an individual and then force him to go to hajj but you do not see Muslims demanding that as there is no compulsion in Islam.

These half baked superficial ideas help no one as government fails to moderate her affairs with needs of time.

A government not catering to obligatory code of conduct as chartered by the constitution has no moral authority to collect tax from the Muslims direct or indirect in Pakistan.

 

[StormBreaker]

Even doing third marriage was not necessary.. Even he coming in politics was not necessary, even his birth was not necessary.
You tell me, what relief he brought to Pakistanis? Price of Everything has increased. People are committing suicides, and we are happy that Pakistans image has improved. Achar dalain image ka?
I am afraid that day is not far, when he will be kicked out of govt with a shout: don't come back again.

Ok, then what will come next ? Zardari ? Bilawal ? Maryam ?

Na martial law chahiye, na parha likha siasat dan chahiye, bas free ki plate mein dal roti chahiye aur ghar bhethe asan kamai.

World is not as easy as Pakistan, go out and witness for yourself.

You guys must be thankful to Allah for having a country where everything is quite cheap.

The problem is income, not expenses

 

[fitpOsitive]

Ok, then what will come next ? Zardari ? Bilawal ? Maryam ?

Na martial law chahiye, na parha likha siasat dan chahiye, bas free ki plate mein dal roti chahiye aur ghar bhethe asan kamai.

World is not as easy as Pakistan, go out and witness for yourself.

You guys must be thankful to Allah for having a country where everything is quite cheap.

The problem is income, not expenses

For ur kind information, I am not earning from Pakistan, and I am running two families, alhamdolillah. My life is everything but, easy. But such is life.
Imran Khan is an educated person, sincere person, agreed. But this thing is not his thing, and he is too stubborn to understand and appreciate that.
Problem in Pakistan is not political, it's of pure administrative type. It's like solving a screw driver issue with a gun.
It will be better that elders of Pakistan pay attention on this issue. Constitute a problem solving structure and take over Pakistan.
And no need to involve idiot voter.

And Imran Khan, he is good for image, and that's it.

And that Zerdari and Nawaz et al? Good for milking. No need to hang.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

The constitution obligates the government to make Muslim way of life easier

The Muslim way of life is being made easier- subsidizing Hajj is not part of it.

And indirect taxes don’t always make it to the government - we’ve see the traders protests already.

It will be better that elders of Pakistan pay attention on this issue.

And who are these ‘elders’? Who’s going to pick them? Who decides the kind of ‘problem solving structure’ to be used?

These kinds of claims are just nonsense along the lines of ‘Shariah Nizam’ will fix everything or ‘the Ulema’ will fix everything.

 

[El Sidd]

The Muslim way of life is being made easier- subsidizing Hajj is not part of it.

And indirect taxes don’t always make it to the government - we’ve see the traders protests already.

That is government's problem that it has so poor tax collecting mechanism.

Muslims in the country have made a lawful demand of exercising tax restrains during Hajj which in turn always turn a profit for the government

 

[YeBeWarned]

Good, Hajj needs to be done once in a life time and its when you have enough to go around, but these days people are doing 2-3 hajj's . As long as that increased money is going into the betterment of people I have no objection with it .

 

[fitpOsitive]

The Muslim way of life is being made easier- subsidizing Hajj is not part of it.

And indirect taxes don’t always make it to the government - we’ve see the traders protests already.


And who are these ‘elders’? Who’s going to pick them? Who decides the kind of ‘problem solving structure’ to be used?

These kinds of claims are just nonsense along the lines of ‘Shariah Nizam’ will fix everything or ‘the Ulema’ will fix everything.

Elders of Pakistan are : head of state Bank, chief of army staff, DG establishment division, DG finance division, secretary education and people like that, not politicians, neither Molvis, which you seem to be fearing the most.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

The tax money wasted on Kartarpur could've been spent on Hajj subsidy. Sikhs could've been taxed heavily but they can visit Pakistan cheaper than i can buy chalghoozas.

You’re bloody scum and a degenerate then - People like you are responsible for much of the hatred, bigotry & prejudice in this world.

Elders of Pakistan are : head of state Bank, chief of army staff, DG establishment division, DG finance division, secretary education and people like that, not politicians, neither Molvis, which you seem to be fearing the most.

Those heads are appointed by politicians. And who decided that these individuals you mentioned have the wisdom & qualification fo run the entire country?

Stop looking for magical, quick simplistic solutions to complex problems that were decades in the making in a complex & diverse country.

IK is on the right track, he’s going to need more than one term to fix all these issues and hopefully a larger majority to stop depending on some ‘coalition partners’.

 

[fitpOsitive]

You’re bloody scum and a degenerate then - People like you are responsible for much of the hatred, bigotry & prejudice in this world.


Those heads are appointed by politicians. And who decided that these individuals you mentioned have the wisdom & qualification fo run the entire country?

Stop looking for magical, quick simplistic solutions to complex problems that were decades in the making in a complex & diverse country.

IK is on the right track, he’s going to need more than one term to fix all these issues and hopefully a larger majority to stop depending on some ‘coalition partners’.

Problems are either solved in few days, or no one is sincere in solving the issues. We will talk in 2029 on this, if life permitted.
Imran Khan simply doesn't know what is wrong with Pakistan. He is just a showpiece. Trust me on that. I usually recognize people from his companions.

 

[I S I]

Couldn't increase the tax net so now let's make profits on the hajj aye lmao.

Maybe if everyone actually paid their taxes, didn't steal gas, electricity and water

k, start from your home then.