What's new

Global Firepower - 2014 Ranks

still its the most accurate list around imo.. is there someone else listing such stuff ? however its has been always interesting to discuss on such lists, at the end of the day this is a defence forum over here :)
 
.
These rankings are a sham, IMO. The comparisons do not take into account the combat experience or qualitative discipline and capabilities of combat platforms. There has to be a penalty for obsolescent equipment and lack of combat experience, which the list never bothers itself with.

Having a 100 Mig 21s is not the same as having a 100 Su 30s. Also, many Navies downgrade/upgrade their ship classes deliberately. A 4000 ton vessel is classed as a Corvette in some Navies while a 3000 ton vessel is classed as a Destroyer in some others.

Also, a country having a coast doesn't automatically need an Aircraft Carrier. A Nation like Israel having Aircraft Carriers and Nuclear submarines would be overkill, and it doesn't warrant a penalty for not having them. Also, a peninsula like India having just a dozen submarines is simply not good enough. But that's not reflected in the rankings. To me, other than the top 3, the other rankings are all inconsistent with their actual capabilities.

What you say makes sense overall - India is on number 4, who do you think can replace India?

I think the top 4 is right the one's following - Japan, France, Germany, Turkey, Pakistan do not follow complete logic.
 
.
Realistic top 10

1.USA
2. Russia
3. GB
4. Germany
5. France
6. Japan
8. China
9. South Korea
10. Israel
11. Turkey
 
. .
1. USA
2. RUSSIA
3. CHINA
4. UK
5. FRANCE
6. GERMANY
7. INDIA
8. JAPAN
9. TURKEY
10. SOUTH KOREA
11. ISRAEL

Realistic top 10

1.USA
2. Russia
3. GB
4. Germany
5. France
6. Japan
8. China
9. South Korea
10. Israel
11. Turkey
Can GB beat china in war? so realistic...
 
.
LOL! They put Israel at 11 to make it look weaker and under threat when we all know they're in the top 6. :lol:


You guys see 'conspiracy' in everything. That's a nice weakness which surely could be exploited in times of tumult.
 
.
Its not worth the energy to come up with a list. The only thing that matters is whether or not a given military can accomplish its objectives that were set out by its leaders.
 
.
You guys see 'conspiracy' in everything. That's a nice weakness which surely could be exploited in times of tumult.

It's not conspiracy it's fact son, Israel has to advertise to the international world that it is facing numerous detrimental threats or else it won't have an excuse for its existence and expansion.
 
.
It's not conspiracy it's fact son, Israel has to advertise to the international world that it is facing numerous detrimental threats or else it won't have an excuse for its existence and expansion.


After 1967 (long before your time, junior) Israel doesn't need to exaggerate the threat to it.
 
.
After 1967 (long before your time, junior) Israel doesn't need to exaggerate the threat to it.

Yes they do, please tell us what imminent threats Israel or faces or major threats? I don't get why you see being part of an American is to support Israel? Could you please explain the logic to this?
 
.
Yes they do, please tell us what imminent threats Israel or faces or major threats? I don't get why you see being part of an American is to support Israel? Could you please explain the logic to this?

Where the hell have you been bud? Israel is the 51st state of USA. Come on now
 
. .
Why are Indians fapping over this website, it's what 12 year old boys go to satisfy their ego
 
.
1. USA
2. RUSSIA
3. CHINA
4. UK
5. FRANCE
6. GERMANY
7. INDIA
8. JAPAN
9. TURKEY
10. SOUTH KOREA
11. ISRAEL


Can GB beat china in war? so realistic...

No doubt! GB has a superior Navy, much better than China. Although for their Air Force. Don't forget, GB is an Island. One more thing. GB has a high tech defense industry, self sufficient of ~90%.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom