Four Iran border guards killed in clash on Pakistan frontier

[Windjammer]

This is a law enforcement issue, the problems that are faced on the IND-BD border are to do with smuggling and illegal migration.


"Tension" because of a difference in opinion of boundaries but not a single loss of life to either side's security in decades.


Another law enforcement issue but, again, these differences have never lead to serious violence.


There is only one border of India's that sees Indian security officers killed and anything like the hostility Pakistan faces on all of its borders (except with China).

Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi

http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1809/18090220.htm

 

[Areesh]

It's neither first nor the last attack on Iranian forces from Pakistani side of the border, but still lets talk again about Kulbhoshan.

No let's not talk about Kalbhushan since because of your sectarian affiliation your loyalty is more with Iran than Pakistan.

 

[A-Team]

Thought it was only an AF-Pak or PAK-Indian thing to trade barbs at each other, it seems that Iranian-PAK are no better

 

[Sage]

We have no problem with pakistan... Only saudi financed terrorists creating problems!

We do have a problem with Pakistan since Khomenai regime ...KSA started funding only when Iran started spreading its tentacles...!

 

[SOHEIL]

We do have a problem with Pakistan since Khomenai regime ...KSA started funding only when Iran started spreading its tentacles...!

Thanks KSA for creating terrorism to stop Iran's influence !

You are great

 

[khail007]

Pak issues with AF on the Torkham border
Pak issues with India on the Indian border
Pak issues with Iran on the Iranian border

The only exception is Chinese border, two inferences can be made

- All these three countries are in cahoots to harm Pakistan.

OR

- Pakistan is to blame for destabilizing the neighbourhood.

No trolling, only objective counter argumentation please

Dear let aside the issues with other border. I will discuss the issue among yours and mines:
Since long we are blaming each other but unable to do anything good except blame games.
If I am going to manage my borders with yours to control the movement of such culprits who are harming both countries, you started firing at the border which resulted fatalities on both sides. May I know the reason or logic behind it?
There is nothing like a free lunch in this materialistic world, did you know what you had paid or further going to pay as a result, if you are familiar with urdu/hindi then please go to following link and judge yourself:
http://www.bbc.com/urdu/multimedia/2016/07/160706_iraq_chilcot_statue_qs

Could you please give your opinion on USA and Pakistan's involvement in Afghanistan during Russian occupation?

Gentleman, you have to put your house in order and I have to control mine. We are neighbours so we have to collaborate. General Raheel, on Eid day again given assurances to control our side and requested for reciprocation. We mutually have to look for the solution none else going to help.
http://www.dawn.com/news/1269442/pa...pects-same-approach-from-them-says-gen-raheel

Please also consider, why American killed a person responsible for peace negotiations from taliban side once the process begins. I am unable to understand, if you have some logical or valid points ... thanks in advance.

 

[Sage]

Thanks KSA for creating terrorism to stop Iran's influence !

You are great

Thanks to both for making Pakistan a den of their sectarian violence ...!

 

[sohail.ishaque]

It's neither first nor the last attack on Iranian forces from Pakistani side of the border, but still lets talk again about Kulbhoshan.

What a dumbazz u r.. i believe ur an indian with a false flag... anyway, the news is about iranian border guards killed in iran NEAR PAKISTANI BORDER, it never says its from Pakistani border instead its near Pakistani border within Iran,..

and Yes, Kulbhoshan is a totally different story, its an onduty officer arrested by our forces and i believe he is being served well,.. btw if u feel that much pain for him, you can offer ur azz instead of his for chitrol..

 

[SOHEIL]

it never says its from Pakistani border

 

[haviZsultan]

For Iran every death even on the border means something. They are not like us, not like us as in they do not see violence and daily death as a common thing, a normal thing and years of stability have conditioned them no matter what we say about the Khomenei's they have brought peace to a weary land. I would like my countrymen to see things in context here. Iran does not face daily suicide bombings and killings of its people and it treats these things very very seriously. Their main security problem is our border like ours is Afghanistan.

We must improve our border management system with Iran to subdue threats like these and quick talks should take place between the 2 countries for better border management. LEJ is very much active in Balochistan and is not just a hater of Iran but all shias including our countrymen. We can blame Afghanistan for violence because they are a poorer nation with poor security along the border, no stability and no control over its territory but with Iran its mostly our border being used to attack them. Lets see things in perspective here. The onus is on us to improve border management, security and control on the border with Iran.

@SOHEIL @A-Team @haman10 @kollang @Serpentine

 

[Serpentine]

There should be a combination of measures against this problem. Build modern walls on the border, station drones, invest in that poor region, better communication with the bordering countries and also fight direct or proxy wars agaist those who finance or promote the ideology of these groups.

Exactly, we can't just blame Pakistan for this, but ourselves too. Whether we like it or not, Pakistan has enough on its plate in their country, we can't expect them to catch every single terrorist (while I believe they could have done much better in past years on some cases).

On our side, we have to build a huge and modern wall on Pak and Afghan border, and shoot every unauthorized moving object near the border, be it a plastic bag or a human being. This will be much better.

To those who say Jaish al-Adl is an Iranian group based in Iran: There is a reason why ALL of their attacks are near the Iran-Pakistan border areas, doesn't take a genius to know the reason. We should solve this problem ourselves instead of waiting for Pakistan, but that doesn't mean you can ignore the problem here.

For Iran every death even on the border means something. They are not like us, not like us as in they do not see violence and daily death as a common thing, a normal thing and years of stability have conditioned them no matter what we say about the Khomenei's they have brought peace to a weary land. I would like my countrymen to see things in context here. Iran does not face daily suicide bombings and killings of its people and it treats these things very very seriously. Their main security problem is our border like ours is Afghanistan.

We must improve our border management system with Iran to subdue threats like these and quick talks should take place between the 2 countries for better border management. LEJ is very much active in Balochistan and is not just a hater of Iran but all shias including our countrymen. We can blame Afghanistan for violence because they are a poorer nation with poor security along the border, no stability and no control over its territory but with Iran its mostly our border being used to attack them. Lets see things in perspective here. The onus is on us to improve border management, security and control on the border with Iran.

@SOHEIL @A-Team @haman10 @kollang @Serpentine

Bro, the only solution is building a wall. Let the traffic between 2 countries goes through official and legal routes. It's not just about terrorism, but also smuggling and drug trafficking.

 

[Drashid]

We have to drone them inside pakistan...

Was that sarcasm?

 

[RoadRunner401]

Pak issues with AF on the Torkham border

Afghan and Indian Trained terrorist can't cross into Pakistan. Afghans get upset and start to fire and kill Pakistani border guards and one of our major, we retaliate, and that's our fault.

Pak issues with Iran on the Iranian border

Again Indian and Afghan nexus at work, 98% of the insurgency in Baluchistan is financed by India and Afghanistan they get their training in Afghan government run Camps. our military have been fighting insurgency fanned by India with the help of Afghans for years. Again somehow that's Pakistan fault because.



Indian Spy gets caught in Pakistan that was supplying and training terrorist in Baluchistan. The fact he was operating out of Afghanistan means nothing.

All of sudden Pakistani, Iranian border is a hotspot guess who benefits, India and Afghanistan, not Pakistan.


This is my all time fav.

Three guys, a Canadian farmer, Afghan and an American engineer are working together one day. They come across a lantern and a Genie pops out of it.

"I will give each of you one wish, which is three wishes says the Genie.

The Canadian says, "I am a farmer, my dad was a farmer, and my son will also farm. I want the land to be forever fertile in Canada."

Pooooof! With the blink of the Genie's eye, the land in Canada was forever made fertile for farming.

Afghan was amazed, so he said, "I want a wall around Afghanistan, so that no infidels, Americans can come into our precious state."

Pooooof! Again, with the blink of the Genie's e! ye, there was a huge wall around Afghanistan.

The American engineer asks, "I am very curious. Please tell me more about this wall".

The Genie explains, "Well, it's about 5000 feet high, 500 feet thick and completely surrounds the country. Nothing can get in or out, it's virtually impenetrable."

The American engineer says, "Fill it with water." Pooooof!

 

[SOHEIL]

Was that sarcasm?

Why?

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

sad for it to happen on Eid day....very sad. Jaish e Adl is a terrorist group and should be treated as one....hunt them down one by one. We also hope that Iran will do more to ensure no foreign state or non state actors exploit Iranian territory against Pakistan - such as the indian navy officer-turned spy who was hiding in Chah bahar and now in our custody