First World War - Finding Pakistan's place in history.

[SQ8]

Must we drag Isarel in this?


Winners get the spoils of war.

Losers like Mufti-e-Azam aka minister in the court of Hitler, do what?

--- Well! they loose.

My answer was specific to Sartak Ganguly.. Simple to get that isnt it?

 

[Kompromat]

Neither was muslim empire ( if there was any). Please get off your high horse .

All caliphates were.

 

[unbiasedopinion]

Read Vedas other than Rig Veda.

No matter what, the claim of not chaging the civilization, race, etc is flawed and wrong. I am just debating on it.

 

[Narashima]

Wow wow wow - the Buddha statues we have excavated must have been placed there by some jin bhoots.

bhai mere buddhism spread during the reign of ashoka(200 BC approx.) , you have a very little knowledge of southasian history.

 

[Cherokee]

All caliphates were.

Thats bs you !! . Divide started just after prophet dying .

 

[ExtraOdinary]

Wow wow wow - the Buddha statues we have excavated must have been placed there by some jin bhoots.

You excavated Buddha statues in Indus Valley sites , you do know there is a time gap of 2 millenia between Buddha and IVC

 

[FaujHistorian]

Please elaborate how a single points of yours is related to mine . Thanks in advance .

GVC - True Hindu civilization

IVC - Non Hindu civilizations


Read Vedic literature of later periods.

 

[Kompromat]

No matter what, the claim of not chaging the civilization, race, etc is flawed and wrong. I am just debating on it.

Bhai na karo debate, no one is begging your critical opinion.

 

[Cherokee]

GVC - True Hindu civilization

IVC - Non Hindu civilizations


Read Vedic literature of later periods.

Try harder dude . This is not making sense .

 

[Kompromat]

You excavated Buddha statues in Indus Valley sites , you do know there is a time gap of 2 millenia between Buddha and IVC

 

[unbiasedopinion]

What kind of shame? - Are Egyptians or Iraqis or Iranians ashamed of their pagan past? - Hell no. Hinduism had failed our people and their aspirations, therefore we eradicated it and replaced it with a new system which distributed equity among us and made us all equals.

Wow wow wow - the Buddha statues we have excavated must have been placed there by some jin bhoots.

I would like to buy that theory rather than your knowledge of history. You don't have an iota about history of this part of the world.

 

[FaujHistorian]

No matter what, the claim of not chaging the civilization, race, etc is flawed and wrong. I am just debating on it.

?????????????????

No idea what you are saying. Clearly your stance goes against Vedas.


Bhai sahib

This is a thread on WW-1 soldiers. please open a new thread on vedas and we can discuss more

Try harder dude . This is not making sense .

Sure.

if it goes against decade old propaganda, it won't make sense. Sorry to see.

you don't even believe in Vedas if they go against your beliefs (not too different from Islamists aka ISIS and Qaida's selective reading of Quran). looks like it.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Wow wow wow - the Buddha statues we have excavated must have been placed there by some jin bhoots.

u are an admin
aliens came and took it to the past

 

[SQ8]

Neither was muslim empire ( if there was any). Please get off your high horse .

There were various empires that claimed Muslim lineage. But essentially all were. There was No Islamic empire as such but the caliphate always existed. Regardless of whether Mughals ruled India or the Mysore dynasty.. or Indonesian rule.. the Caliphate was around from the first days of the empire and while it shifted around.. it was always recognized as an entity.

Even in its dying days the Caliphate had its influence on the affairs of various Muslim rulers throughout the world. And not just Muslim rulers, but generally any sphere of influence recognized it.

What is pertinent to the discussion regarding Pakistan and its existence before 47, is that Muslims considered the Caliphate as their final allegiance sans any actual weight to it ;other than some sort of common spiritual link and a "pan-Islamic" link to say the Caliphate was able to account certain Muslim rulers for their actions.

 

[unbiasedopinion]

Bhai sahib
This is a thread on WW-1 soldiers. please open a new thread on vedas and we can discuss more

Bhai mere, I agree but I responded to one of the post where there is claim of not changing civilization. Either tell the OP to modify it or ask him if he wants to debate it, then open another thread on this.