First Sikh Army Officer

[AmnaR]

thank you for being honest



the UK Pakistanis are much smarter than the ones from North America. However, she has asked a question not appropriate for this thread, and not even appropriate to discuss anyways

if he gets killed then he is a hero.

"shaheed" is an Arabic word, which for a muslim has specific meaning @AmnaR



Pakistan is certainly an Islam ka Qila. Its an Islamic land, with non-Muslim minorities.

Why the HYPOCRISY?? What is the motto of our Army? Jihad Fi Sabillilah. Why would a non muslim do Jihad for Allah? Oh and please, Pakistan is a Qila, yes. Not Islam ka Qilla. Can Islam ka Qilla be an ALLY of NON MUSLIMS who are actively killing muslims. not only an ally, but actually HELP?

Get this notion out of your head. WE WILL DO WHATS BEST FOR OUR COUNTRY!! No matter WHAT. Period

 

[Multani]

Why the HYPOCRISY?? What is the motto of our Army? Jihad Fi Sabillilah. Why would a non muslim do Jihad for Allah? Oh and please, Pakistan is a Qila, yes. Not Islam ka Qilla. Can Islam ka Qilla be an ALLY of NON MUSLIMS who are actively killing muslims. not only an ally, but actually HELP?

Get this notion out of your head. WE WILL DO WHATS BEST FOR OUR COUNTRY!! No matter WHAT. Period

which hypocrisy sister? you are quick to jump to conclusions, and calm down. jihad fi sabilAllah is an Arabic word which means "strive with physical effort on the path of Allah". This concept if for Muslim soldiers, not non-Muslims.

Pakistan is Islam ka Qila because it is a Muslim land, with a Muslim population of 96% that has a well established tradition of culture and spiritualty.

What you are talking about is secular contemporary politics by some Muslims in this land that bears no burden on the others, who keep Pakistan alive as an Islam ka Qila. Its like your brother takes to drinking in the UK, but your slate is clear though. All you can do is try to bring your brother to the right path.

 

[Donatello]

Mods you should close this thread
It has gone to the usual flamebait.
@nuclearpak @Aeronaut

 

[HariPrasad]

The first Sikh officer in Pak Army (infantry), Capt Harcharan Singh, is now an ADC to a Corps Commander

Excellent News.....

https://twitter.com/x/status/472374257675026432

Congrats To Mr. Harcharan Singh!!!!!!!!

 

[Alfa-Fighter]

That makes no sense, the example you gave of the Jat regiment is because the regiment is made up of members of the Jat community who are Hindu that's why there motto is "Jat Balwan, Jai Bhagwan". It's not all Hindu based, the Sikh regiments(all three of them) have there own motto. Very poor examples you are giving.

Nowadays it's 15% Sikh according to estimates. Not because Sikhs are joining less but because more groups are joining. In the old days the Indian army would recruit in areas with "martial races" such as Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan for Sikhs, Gurkhas and Rajputs etc but now they are recruiting all over India so the percentage has gone down.

Sikhs make up 25% of all ranks in the Indian Army and 30% of its officers,
Sikh Regiment - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

they nearly from 2% of population while muslims make 14% of population in india and hardly contribute anything. They was everything free , food , job, space etc.

 

[Shahmir]

Sikhs make up 25% of all ranks in the Indian Army and 30% of its officers,
Sikh Regiment - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

they nearly from 2% of population while muslims make 14% of population in india and hardly contribute anything. They was everything free , food , job, space etc.

Hindus are using sikhs as cannon fodder for wars , their higher % just shows that mindset. Hindu is intelligent , khud drawing rooms mein aram karta hai , aur bechare sikh ko marney ke liye dhara dhar bharti kar raha hai.

 

[Alfa-Fighter]

Hindus are using sikhs as cannon fodder for wars , their higher % just shows that mindset. Hindu is intelligent , khud drawing rooms mein aram karta hai , aur bechare sikh ko marney ke liye dhara dhar bharti kar raha hai.

lol.... what about 14% muslims who seeks always benefit and don't do any contribution ?

Hindu's don't for force them to join they join because they want to defend lands and contribute to society and also don't seek any benefit because they know how work hard and uplift unlike other so called minority.

 

[Shahmir]

lol.... what about 14% muslims who seeks always benefit and don't do any contribution ?

Hindu's don't for force them to join they join because they want to defend lands and contribute to society and also don't seek any benefit because they know how work hard and uplift unlike other so called minority.

Because Muslmis are intelligent they dont want to die for hindu banniyas, this is the job for "the most "intelligent" nation" of sicks only

 

[jatt+gutts]

Because Muslmis are intelligent they dont want to die for hindu banniyas, this is the job for "the most "intelligent" nation" of sicks only

yea thats why they are poorest in india and sikhs richest. to be in army one has to pass some requirements. sikhs met those requirements easily whereas muslims cant.. its simple as that

 

[Pakistani E]

I really don't mean to divert this topic and seriously I am not trolling but can someone tell me why other minorities are always paraded around by others, while ahmadi soldiers are forbidden from going above a brigadier rank? There are probably over a thousand ahmadis in Pak army, how come no mention of them?

 

[Shahmir]

I really don't mean to divert this topic and seriously I am not trolling but can someone tell me why other minorities are always paraded around by others, while ahmadi soldiers are forbidden from going above a brigadier rank? There are probably over a thousand ahmadis in Pak army, how come no mention of them?

Because they are not "ahmedi" , they are "marzai" this is their real name.

 

[Pakistani E]

Because they are not "ahmedi" , they are "marzai" this is their real name.

sorry my comment was directed at people with an IQ of 90 or above. Move along son, nothing to see here.

 

[damdam786]

Well if Pakistan gets attacked then everyone in it gets hurt, so its only logical PA should have people from every section of society.