What's new

Exocets have kill switches …

. . . .
Quite interesting. Argies got 4 missile hits.

HMS Sheffield - warhead failed to explode. But the rocket motor ignited the missile magazine. Destroyer was sunk.

HMS Glamorgan was hit on the last day by a make shift truck launched Exocet. Again the warhead failed to explode and the destroyer survived.

Transport Atlantic Conveyor was mistaken for either HMS Hermes or Illustrious and got hit by 2 missiles. There are conflicting reports whether the warheads exploded or the missiles caused fire that ignited fuel bunkers. Ship sank.

So potentially none of the warheads exploded.

Iraqis fired to Exocets at USS Stark, one of them failed to detonate as well.

So 5 Exocets fired in anger with only one detonating.

I remember my dad was invited to a live fire exercise by Pak Navy during one of the Sea Spark Ex. An Exocet was launched by an Atlantique and the warhead failed to explode. One of the old gearing class destroyer moved in the finish the target off with its 5 inch guns. Navy folks were quite embarrassed 🙈
 
Last edited:
.
Quite interesting. Argies got 4 missile hits.

HMS Sheffield - warhead failed to explode. But the rocket motor ignited the missile magazine. Destroyer was sunk.

HMS Glamorgan was hit on the last day by a make shift truck launched Exocet. Again the warhead failed to explode and the destroyer survived.

Transport Atlantic Conveyor was mistaken for either HMS Hermes or Illustrious and got hit by 2 missiles. There are conflicting reports whether the warheads exploded or the missiles caused fire that ignited fuel bunkers. Ship sank.

So potentially none of the warheads exploded.

Iraqis fired to Exocets at USS Stark, one of them failed to detonate as well.

So 5 Exocets fired in anger with only one detonating.

I remember my dad was invited to a live fire exercise by Pak Navy during one of the Sea Spark Ex. An Exocet was launched by an Atlantique and the warhead failed to explode. One of the old gearing class destroyer moved in the finish the target off with its 5 inch guns. Navy folks were quite embarrassed 🙈

We don’t have these in inventory right?
 
.
Who cares, plenty of alternatives no strings attached suppliers of such armamemt.

Time when this kind of setup on armed systems was implemented as measure of political inflience had passed.
 
.
We don’t have these in inventory right?
Yes we do. But now primarily used by PN on Seakings. Pak Navy recently got 10 Qatari Seakings, some of them are equipped to launch Exocets.
But PAF primary anti ship weapon in C802 on JF17 (No 2 sqn).
Exocets have been withdrawn from No 8 sqn Mirages.
 
.
Yes we do. But now primarily used by PN on Seakings. Pak Navy recently got 10 Qatari Seakings, some of them are equipped to launch Exocets.
But PAF primary anti ship weapon in C802 on JF17 (No 2 sqn).
Exocets have been withdrawn from No 8 sqn Mirages.
Which one is the most capable anti ship missile in PN inventory?
Harpoon/Exocet/C802/Harbah/Smash/C302/CM 401?
 
.
Exocets have been withdrawn from No 8 sqn Mirages.
Are they still kept in wartime reserve, or the rounds are past their useful life too??
Also, w/o the Exocet, the Agave radar has no apparent purpose, so is it also removed to make way for more stores??
 
.
Quite interesting. Argies got 4 missile hits.

HMS Sheffield - warhead failed to explode. But the rocket motor ignited the missile magazine. Destroyer was sunk.

HMS Glamorgan was hit on the last day by a make shift truck launched Exocet. Again the warhead failed to explode and the destroyer survived.

Transport Atlantic Conveyor was mistaken for either HMS Hermes or Illustrious and got hit by 2 missiles. There are conflicting reports whether the warheads exploded or the missiles caused fire that ignited fuel bunkers. Ship sank.

So potentially none of the warheads exploded.

Iraqis fired to Exocets at USS Stark, one of them failed to detonate as well.

So 5 Exocets fired in anger with only one detonating.

I remember my dad was invited to a live fire exercise by Pak Navy during one of the Sea Spark Ex. An Exocet was launched by an Atlantique and the warhead failed to explode. One of the old gearing class destroyer moved in the finish the target off with its 5 inch guns. Navy folks were quite embarrassed 🙈
What are your sources? You basically said that not a single Exocet worked. Is that some kind of tale only a few know?

Second,this is a post by the telegraph,posted by Ali_Baba who will rush to discredit everything French and praise everything British.

For all we know,that's all bullshit there.
 
.
Probably a convenient distraction from all the political backlash the government is experiencing right now. There's never been any evidence of these so called kill switches. The French actually provided quite a lot of assistance to the UK at the time
 
.
HMS Glamorgan was hit on the last day by a make shift truck launched Exocet. Again the warhead failed to explode and the destroyer survived.
The warhead did detonate in this attack, evasive action from the crew saved the ship from total destruction. It was for all intent and purposes mission killed and rendered useless for the duration of the war.
HMS Sheffield - warhead failed to explode. But the rocket motor ignited the missile magazine. Destroyer was sunk.
There were 2 launched, one missed its target and the other impacted however did not detonate, the impact was immense.
Transport Atlantic Conveyor was mistaken for either HMS Hermes or Illustrious and got hit by 2 missiles. There are conflicting reports whether the warheads exploded or the missiles caused fire that ignited fuel bunkers. Ship sank.
The conflicting reports are of when the warheads detonated, not if. It is unknown if they detonated as soon as they impacted the hull or after penetrating it.

So 3 successful detonations, 1 miss and 1 unsuccessful detonation
 
. .
Every western system has a “kill switch” built in.

By “kill switch” I mean any of :

- pure kill switch : press a red button to send a signal and kaboom

- system not able to properly lock on specific targets like Turkish F16 never been able to lock on Israeli jets.

- even if properly locked on target, and launched, will miss target with higher rate for specific target so will not have real impact on the issue of war.

- a mix of all the points cited and maybe many more.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom