What's new

Exclusive: India losing more soldiers in Red Corridors than J-K

kurup

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 10, 2012
Messages
10,563
Reaction score
-2
Country
India
Location
India
naxals-1-1_650_021714090211.jpg
A file photo of CRPF personnel on patrol in Nandigarm, West Bengal. Members of the force have borne the brunt of Maoist insurgency.

A deadly trend has struck roots in India's Red Corridor over the past three years. A soldier fighting Maoists deep inside the jungles of central and southcentral India is far more likely to be killed than his uniformed brothers taking on militants in Jammu and Kashmir or insurgents in the North-east.
Rebels in the Red zone are killing more soldiers than are dying in all insurgency-hit areas put together. Official data from the Union home ministry shows that at least one security personnel loses his life to Maoists possibility of the enemy surprising security forces makes the job of their personnel highly risky.

"Numbers can never tell the real horror tales. There is death at every step," says an official who has served in these highrisk zones. Maoists are acknowledged experts in planting improvised explosive devices (IEDs) and are always devising new strategies to ensure mass killings. And they seem to be getting better. There have been recent incidents when several security personnel have been butchered in one ambush. Sources say IED explosions have been responsible for most deaths. "They plan attacks and ambush our forces resulting in large killings," the officer said.

Scary numbers

The numbers tell the tale. The death toll of security personnel killed between 2011 and 2013 was 371 in the Maoist zone; the number of incidents of violence in the Red zone was 4,311. High intensity conflict zones like Jammu & Kashmir, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur and Meghalaya seem safer than the Maoist bastions of Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh or Orissa where most the security personnel killings have taken place. The total death toll in all insurgency-affected areas was 239 in the same period and the number of incidents of violence 3,123.

naxals-1-650_021714090211.jpg

"Terrorism is a product of enemy countries. But that's not the case with Maoists. They are receiving support from many quarters within the country The government is restrained against them," said Ajai Raj Sharma, former Director-General of the Border Security Force. Insurgency in the Northeast has been controlled but that's not the case with Maoists, he said. "In Jammu & Kashmir there is a higher risk involved of being caught as the terrorists infiltrate from Pakistan. The Maoists can plan their offences better since they don't have to bother about getting people from outside," Sharma explained.

The main force fighting the Maoists is the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), and is most affected by the tough conditions at hand. "No wonder the attrition rate in CRPF is highest among paramilitary forces," said one officer on condition of anonymity.

The CRPF also accounts for nearly 40 per cent of the suicides that take place in all paramilitary forces.

Sources say in many cases the reasons can be attributed to the Maoist insurgency. The number of suicides in the force is on the rise. The disturbing trend has been a cause of worry for the home ministry; since 2008 the CRPF has had the most suicides. The Maoist insurgency has taken its toll on the force in more ways than one.

naxals-2_650_021714090211.jpg

Sources say in many cases the reasons can be attributed to the Maoist. In the last five years the force has seen more than 700 people take voluntary retirement.

Civilians unsafe

Civilians in the Maoist areas fare no better. In the last three years, a thousand civilians have been killed in the war between the rebels and security forces. The civilian death count in other insurgency zones was 389. In fact, the number of civilians killed in the Red corridor is much more than the number of security forces and the number of Maoists killed.

naxals-1_mos_021714090211.jpg


Exclusive: India losing more soldiers in Red Corridors than J-K : India, News - India Today
 
Last edited:
Actually its a classical case of proving anything by statistics.. This fact is due to reduction in the fatalities in J&K etc and not the other way around :)

If you see below, the fatalities due to left wing extremism have remain more of less same since 2005, and have shown a slight increase till 2010 and decrease post that

On the other hand, in J&K the count has decreased by over 90% between 2005 and 2013..

Trust indian media to put a negative spin on this :D

eaijup.jpg
 
Actually its a classical case of proving anything by statistics.. This fact is due to reduction in the fatalities in J&K etc and not the other way around :)

If you see below, the fatalities due to left wing extremism have remain more of less same since 2005, and have shown a slight increase till 2010 and decrease post that

On the other hand, in J&K the count has decreased by over 90% between 2005 and 2013..

Trust indian media to put a negative spin on this :D

eaijup.jpg
mate this cumulative fatalities include at least 7k-9k tangos who were killed by our Security Forces in this period of time,following link provides the exact figure of the total tangos killed by the Indian Security Forces in the past 20 years.
India Fatalities :: South Asia Terrorism portal
 
371 security forces martyred in last 3 years.
I will say that casualties in last few years have been very much reduced. Before 2010, casuaties were like 300+ security forces/year so actually maoists are weakening.
PS: Kashmir insurgency is all time low. In last 3 years we have hardly lost 100 soldiers there.
 
Actually its a classical case of proving anything by statistics.. This fact is due to reduction in the fatalities in J&K etc and not the other way around :)

If you see below, the fatalities due to left wing extremism have remain more of less same since 2005, and have shown a slight increase till 2010 and decrease post that

On the other hand, in J&K the count has decreased by over 90% between 2005 and 2013..

Trust indian media to put a negative spin on this :D

eaijup.jpg
Exactly! What a way to spin such news!!
 
Naxals are leaderless, and our forces are patrolling deep inside the naxal belt. Hence we must expect higher fatality as a consequence of frequent encounters. In the start our casualties will be higher compared to the enemy casualties because it is us who are entering into the so called naxal "liberated zones". This is normal in any counter-terror operation. But this is also the beginning of the end. Naxals cannot win this war of attrition and will eventually have to dig deeper.

The positive outcome is that Naxals have been unable to increase their territory and the naxals are loosing the areas which were originally under their effective control.
 
Due to ambush and un proper protective measures for soldiers was the main reason for the death of valor s in the naxal affected regions.
 
Indian Army at her best yet again.
What a silly comment. Can you compare your policemen to the Pakistan Army? There are NO Indian Army personnel in the so called 'Red corridor'! Please get that into the space between you ears.

Secondly, it's better if they used the word 'police' or 'cops' than refer to them as 'soldiers'. Makes it sound like the Indian Army!! It's all about the CRPF, BSF and the local police.
 
We have paramilitary forces in the red corridor and military forces in J & K - As a matter of fact Paramilitary forces are not as trained as the army and also lack of proper protective gears and advanced arms and ammunition! Its time that the army should train the CRPF and other paramilitary forces and additional fund allocations to be made for more protective gears and advanced arms and ammunition! :coffee:
 
the article doesnt look that much credible.........there are only a handfull of those maoists present in chattisgarh..........remaining places have improved a lot....
 
Indian Army at her best yet again.

images


You don't even know who is deployed where; you don't even know whats the difference between paramilitary and military forces! Damn you don't even know the full form of CRPF but still you are at your best at trolling!

Ever thought what will happen if you send Karachi Police to tackle the situation in North-West Pakistan???? :sick:

They are cops/reserved police forces not regular military brats! :hitwall:

At least do some research before trolling! :coffee:
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom