Dwarka : Myth or reality?

[Peshwa]

People have come and lived in this region - they make up the diversity that exists in our beautiful country, and it is not shared with india, there are two rival civilizations in South Asia, the Indus and the ganges. That is the reality.

IVC = Birthplace of Hinduism....

That should be enough to end this path of denial you're hell bent on treading...

 

[Rafi]

Were there boundaries and fences as per UN mandate?

Or does that area include present day Indian Punjab and Indian Gujarat too?

By ur own words the balochis and pashtuns and many other ethincs cant claim this honour of the civilization.What a contradiction.

The Baloch, Kashmiri and Pashtun also share it. But not india.

 

[Bhairava]

What has been found is that the people living in Punjab and Sindh have the DNA markers that show they are the DIRECT descendants of the people of the IVC, and to a lesser extent Baloch, Kashmiri, Pashtun people.

Again has it been tested on the Indians to prove the exclusivity of the claim ?

You can see South Indians sharing the same DNA maker as that od the heart of the location of IVC.

As I said Pakistani culture is nothing but a bastardization of a whole lot of other cultures with the original IVC surviving safely in India.

Our culture sonny, has nothing in common with india.

Lol you NOT are a certifier of what is authentic Pakistani culture or not. Leave it to learned people.And FYI they think differently.

 

[SpArK]

IVC = Birthplace of Hinduism....

That should be enough to end this path of denial you're hell bent on treading...

Wait... he may even say a 5000 year old IVC inhabitant still lives there and told him everything.

 

[Rafi]

Oh yeah i have heard Indus valley Border security force.. Isnt it?

People needed passport , right?

But the locals are descendants not indians

 

[SpArK]

The Baloch, Kashmiri and Pashtun also share it. But not india.

How nice of you... If bangladesh was part they would have too, right Rafi?

 

[Rafi]

IVC = Birthplace of Hinduism....

That should be enough to end this path of denial you're hell bent on treading...

Our ancestors were not Hindu, the IVC people did not worship idols, buried their dead, and ate Beef.

---------- Post added at 07:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:26 PM ----------

Wait... he may even say a 5000 year old IVC inhabitant still lives there and told him everything.

Our DNA has proven we are it's inheritors.

 

[Rafi]

Again has it been tested on the Indians to prove the exclusivity of the claim ?

You can see South Indians sharing the same DNA maker as that od the heart of the location of IVC.

As I said Pakistani culture is nothing but a bastardization of a whole lot of other cultures with the original IVC surviving safely in India.



Lol you NOT are a certifier of what is authentic Pakistani culture or not. Leave it to learned people.And FYI they think differently.

But the specific DNA markers show that we are the direct descendants.

---------- Post added at 07:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:28 PM ----------

How nice of you... If bangladesh was part they would have too, right Rafi?

Not Bangladesh they are thousands of miles away from the IVC and it's sites.

 

[SpArK]

But the specific DNA markers show that we are the direct descendants.

Dont lie. A certain person saying so in a forum is not a good source.

 

[Bhairava]

Our ancestors were not Hindu, the IVC people did not worship idols, buried their dead, and ate Beef.

Other than Hindus, they were ? I don't know of any other religion that worships Lord Pashupathi (Lord Shiva) other than Hindus.

Our DNA has proven we are it's inheritors.

Yes, DNA doesn't lie.

 

[Bhairava]

But the specific DNA markers show that we are the direct descendants.

Can you be more specific like quoting some scientific journals, studies, research papers etc other than just waving the Pak flag and saying the same thing again and again ?

Because this DNA marker shows that the core IVC locations' DNA and that of the South India are the same confirming the exodus of the IVC inhabitants into India and the Dravidian regions of the South

 

[Rafi]

Dont lie. A certain person saying so in a forum is not a good source.

According to scientific studies, the bones of the people buried in the IVC site, corresponding to the date when it was flourishing (by carbon dating) and the people of Pakistan share the same markers for direct descent.

 

[SpArK]

According to scientific studies, the bones of the people buried in the IVC site, corresponding to the date when it was flourishing (by carbon dating) and the people of Pakistan share the same markers for direct descent.

Yup it was the same procedure which proved the inhabitants were spread all across the subcontinent.

Now u are learning, im glad Rafi.

 

[Rafi]

Can you be more specific like quoting some scientific journals, studies, research papers etc other than just waving the Pak flag and saying the same thing again and again ?

You should contact the archaeological department of Pakistan Museums of Pakistan they have conducted the scientific research. They have journals you can research it yourself.

 

[Bhairava]

According to scientific studies, the bones of the people buried in the IVC site, corresponding to the date when it was flourishing (by carbon dating) and the people of Pakistan share the same markers for direct descent.

Again you are mentioning studies, studies but not giving us any scientific links that show the exclusivity of IVC to Pakistan.

You may share the same markers and it is equally possible that many people in India may also share that same.