Did Pakistan Army kill three million Bengalis in Bangladesh?

[airmarshal]

Its a long read but worth it.

There is Indian and Bengali narrative that Pakistan Army killed 3 million Bengalis. This is mere propaganda as author of this article has refuted many claims with figures and eyewitness accounts.

This was an Indian sponsored state terrorism and we should call it what it was. Bangladesh creation was partly our folly but more of an Indian subversion.

https://oracleopinions.com/2018/08/26/did-pakistan-army-kill-three-million-bengalis-in-bangladesh/

 

[Rajesh Kumar]

Its a long read but worth it.

There is Indian and Bengali narrative that Pakistan Army killed 3 million Bengalis. This is mere propaganda as author of this article has refuted many claims with figures and eyewitness accounts.

This was an Indian sponsored state terrorism and we should call it what it was. Bangladesh creation was partly our folly but more of an Indian subversion.

https://oracleopinions.com/2018/08/26/did-pakistan-army-kill-three-million-bengalis-in-bangladesh/

I would suggest you to please read the history...... better to accept fault and move on. History has been written in book and nobody can change with any arguments.

 

[KAMDEV]

Its a long read but worth it.

There is Indian and Bengali narrative that Pakistan Army killed 3 million Bengalis. This is mere propaganda as author of this article has refuted many claims with figures and eyewitness accounts.

This was an Indian sponsored state terrorism and we should call it what it was. Bangladesh creation was partly our folly but more of an Indian subversion.

https://oracleopinions.com/2018/08/26/did-pakistan-army-kill-three-million-bengalis-in-bangladesh/

bangalis muslims and hindus were killed indiscriminately that's true , now it is not possible to count ,but numbers were substantial.

I would suggest you to please read the history...... better to accept fault and move on. History has been written in book and nobody can change with any arguments.

this is true .

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

BD’s own investigation during Mujib’s time put the figure of dead at 230K. He suppressed it of course!!! Politicians need some dramatic numbers to play in the arena of politics. By the by, when Bhutto came to Dhaka in 1974 to invite Mujib to an OIC meeting, folks thronged into the streets in such large numbers to greet him that BD paramilitary had to disperse them by force!!!

Interestingly, none of Mijib’s or his chief cohorts’ family members died in 1971. However, they were killed by scores in 1975 by BD folks themselves without any remorse whatsoever!!!

And, Mujib himself killed 40K ex Mukti Bahini Terrorists (MBT) when they defied his “one party one leader under India” rule and resorted to robbery, murders etc.!! Not to mention the one million folks that persished during a man made famine in 1974 due to wide spread corruption, his mismanagement, smuggling of relief goods to India etc..

And, many ex Pak Army officers, who joined MBT, killed one another via coups, betrayals etc. They lived by treachery, and they died by treachery...

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

Doesn't matter.

 

[khanmubashir]

Its highly inflated number

Bng never asked UN to do independent assessment as it did in Bosnia
Just told them to accept bng Indian fake claims
And thus UN doesn't consider 71 a genocide but a civil war
Pak own Mehmood rehman commission put estimate around 25000
Even India own NRI Oxford professor shermila Bose book dead reckoning put estimates in 20-30 k and also blames Indian sponsored mukti bahni as much responsible for atrocities as army
And in these dead estimates also include killed bihari community people at hands of mukti bahni

 

[airmarshal]

BD’s own investigation during Mujib’s time put the figure of dead at 230K. He suppressed it of course!!! Politicians need some dramatic numbers to play in the arena of politics. By the by, when Bhutto came to Dhaka in 1974 to invite Mujib to an OIC meeting, folks thronged into the streets in such large numbers to greet him that BD paramilitary had to disperse them by force!!!

Interestingly, none of Mijib’s or his chief cohorts’ family members died in 1971. However, they were killed by scores in 1975 by BD folks themselves without any remorse whatsoever!!!

And, Mujib himself killed 40K ex Mukti Bahini Terrorists (MBT) when they defied his “one party one leader under India” rule and resorted to robbery, murders etc.!! Not to mention the one million folks that persished during a man made famine in 1974 due to wide spread corruption, his mismanagement, smuggling of relief goods to India etc..

And, many ex Pak Army officers, who joined MBT, killed one another via coups, betrayals etc. They lived by treacher, and they died by treachery...

Read the article.

The recorded figure is about 57,000. This was report of inquiry commission formed by Mujib in Jan 1972. 3 million figure is just a propaganda number behind which Indians and Bengalis hide.

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

Its highly inflated number

Bng never asked UN to do independent assessment as it did in Bosnia
Just told them to accept bng Indian fake claims
And thus UN doesn't consider 71 a genocide but a civil war
Pak own Mehmood rehman commission put estimate around 25000
Even India own NRI Oxford professor shermila Bose book dead reckoning put estimates in 20-30 k and also blames Indian sponsored mukti bahni as much responsible for atrocities as army
And in these dead estimates also include killed bihari community people at hands of mukti bahni

Interestingly, Ms Bose is related to Subhas Bose, a true Indian Nationalist leader, who physically fought the British by commanding over Hindu, Muslim, Sikh etc. soldiers!!! He could unite them in one platform of Azad Hind Fouj!! He succeeded where Gandhi, Nehru etc. failed!!

 

[American Pakistani]

Read the article.

The recorded figure is about 57,000. This was report of inquiry commission formed by Mujib in Jan 1972. 3 million figure is just a propaganda number behind which Indians and Bengalis hide.

I even doubt it is 57k. The verified figure is somewhat around 25k which also includes mutkia terrorists.

 

[Mugwop]

Pakistanis were outnumbered in bangladesh even before india stepped in

 

[Musalman]

No , It was not possible for Pakistan Army to kill 3 million people in 9 months.

 

[airmarshal]

I will encourage you all to please read the article. Its a long one that is why I did not copy it.

 

[MastanKhan]

No , It was not possible for Pakistan Army to kill 3 million people in 9 months.

Hi,

The german military with all its resources could not kill that many in years---.

 

[khansaheeb]

I would suggest you to please read the history...... better to accept fault and move on. History has been written in book and nobody can change with any arguments.

There are some faults you can't move on from:-

 

[Musalman]

Hi,

The german military with all its resources could not kill that many in years---.

There were 25,000 to 30,000 troops in East Pakistan