i dont take my religion from a sufi. evidence of anything in religion is a must.
who cares about my authority or javed akhtar? the classical scholars are the authority on the matter, and they say Javed Akhtar is a kafir, and vande mataram is not allowed. my own opinion/authority is not even worth the dust under the feet of the classical islamic scholars.
But you said only the first two generations count.
Where did these classical scholars come from now?
The one in Egypt who passed some interesting fatwas?
Millions think he was very classical.
Cheers, Doc