Cow slaughter to be punishable by life sentence in Indian state

[lastofthepatriots]

Making t bone tonight. This thread got me hungry.

 

[Crixus]

sorry off-topic Buddy may you share the address

Nothing so complicated.

You have desi daru ki dukaans that are government notified?

You have places in the north which even sell marijuana (ganja) under government license.

It's a well known fact that Muslims are spread across India. However, seeing as we are way outnumbered by Hindus, it is not conceivable that we would be in an actual majority in too many villages or towns or cities, leave alone districts or states.

So here I disagree with the solution being put forward by Show.

Neither should any Indian have to move to eat. He or she may move for employment. But to eat? Never. This is our country. Each and every one of us. There will be no more segregation. No more divisions.

Every Muslim (or Christian or Dalit or indeed beef eating Hindu - there are many more than let on here and on social.media) living anywhere in Zindia should have the means to eat as he pleases. When he pleases. In safety.

This on the back of the existing fact that (happily to a large extent because of dietary differences) most places Muslims tend to live together. Also for safety of course. Let's face it. This is India.

So you have Government notified abbatoirs making beef available in Muslim dominated areas. In cities, towns, villages. For those who want to procure beef from.

This is out of sight of Hindus. No Hindu around to get offended. And life goes on as before. Normal. People well fed. And social harmony having one less chance to break down.

Cheers, and kudos.

@gayMo



I'm from the Income Tax department - just 6.

 

[StraightShooter]

Please explain as to why there will be a need of humongous expansion of government machinery and would increase the expenses of the states?

Do you have Finance, Home, Law etc ministers by each district? You would have Mayors and Collectors.

Even in US the laws are by state. For example, In a democratic blue state like California, San Diego county is a Red county but they have to live with the laws of the state even if they don't like them.

We would have to either carve out new states or union territories for people who want to eat beef.. That's the easiest way.

 

[adil_minhas]

sorry off-topic Buddy may you share the address

No address man. They are small shops with proper sarkari certificate hung on the shutters. Typical pudiyas. No party packs.

 

[Safriz]

How do you know? All practicing Hindus consider cow as sacred.



Hindus do not have a single religious book and I never claimed that cow is our religious book rather cow is considered god as it has life. For Hindus Life and nature is God. Cow was declared as sacred in Bhagavad Gita



No. It is not.



Cow is a living animal while Quran is just a book without any life.

Yes but cow makes a juicy burger and beef nihari/ biryani and looks great on my BBQ.
Also the Hindu hype towards cow has no proper definition. Even slaughtering buffalo starts riots in India, which isn't a cow.
Hindus should first define their religion properly , same as Islam is defined in miniscule details.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Yes but cow makes a juicy burger and beef nihari/ biryani and looks great on my BBQ.
Also the Hindu hype towards cow has no proper definition. Even slaughtering buffalo starts riots in India, which isn't a cow.
Hindus should first define their religion properly , same as Islam is defined in miniscule details.

Indians are servient people by nature. They have no problem dressing their women up in mini skirts and pretending to have Anglo Saxon names from their call centers or claiming to be the worlds largest democracy thus considering themselves honorary whites. But Bhagwan forbid they eat some damn beef, even though the entire fucking world eats it other than them.

 

[StraightShooter]

Yes but cow makes a juicy burger and beef nihari/ biryani and looks great on my BBQ.
Also the Hindu hype towards cow has no proper definition. Even slaughtering buffalo starts riots in India, which isn't a cow.
Hindus should first define their religion properly , same as Islam is defined in miniscule details.

Per Hindu religion killing or destroying of any thing in this universe is discouraged. But there is a priority - Indian Breed of Cows, Other Cows, Buffaloes, other Mammals, other living things and non-living things.

Cow slaughter (Both Indian and non-Indian) is currently prohibited by law while others in the hierarchy including Buffalo are not.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Hindus are strange people. Even their Bhagwan gao mata eats meat.

 

[The_Showstopper]

Do you have Finance, Home, Law etc ministers by each district? You would have Mayors and Collectors.

Even in US the laws are by state. For example, In a democratic blue state like California, San Diego county is a Red county but they have to live with the laws of the state even if they don't like them.

We would have to either carve out new states or union territories for people who want to eat beef.. That's the easiest way.

You either misunderstood what I stated or you are just acting ignorant, I said that a State government should bring in a law where if a district/Town is non-Hindu majority, they can legally have a slaughter house and can consume beef in that particular district/Town. Local administrators(like collector/Mayor) can enforce those laws going by the demography. You don't need Finance ministers or Home ministers for this in each district.

 

[adil_minhas]

You either misunderstood what I stated or you are just acting ignorant, I said that a State government should bring in a law where if a district/Town is non-Hindu majority, they can legally have a slaughter house and can consume beef in that particular district/Town. Local administrators(like collector/Mayor) can enforce those laws going by the demography. You don't need Finance ministers or Home ministers for this in each district.

Bro how many district/towns in India will have a non Hindu majority?

For starters my city does not.

And I'm not moving.

 

[The_Showstopper]

Neither should any Indian have to move to eat. He or she may move for employment. But to eat? Never. This is our country. Each and every one of us. There will be no more segregation. No more divisions.

Every Muslim (or Christian or Dalit or indeed beef eating Hindu - there are many more than let on here and on social.media) living anywhere in Zindia should have the means to eat as he pleases. When he pleases. In safety.

Bro how many district/towns in India will have a non Hindu majority?

For starters my city does not.

And I'm not moving.

The issue is BJP has a problem with what you stated hence I thought let's beat them with their stick. If they are stating that Hindus are minority in that Geographical area hence a different law, why not implement it at a micro-level.

Muslim demography district-wise below

Muslims 20%+ in 86 districts, 50%+ in 19 | The Indian Express

 

[adil_minhas]

Gotcha may be you are talking about Bhang I have seen such shops in UP..... Cow , mandir, Babri Mosque, triple talak are just political spices to befool both Hindus and Muslims of India nothing more than that

Yup. Vrindavan was where I saw one last (while I was still stoning).

 

[Crixus]

I have seen in Barelly and Farrukhabad ......

Yup. Vrindavan was where I saw one last (while I was still stoning).

 

[StraightShooter]

You either misunderstood what I stated or you are just acting ignorant, I said that a State government should bring in a law where if a district/Town is non-Hindu majority, they can legally have a slaughter house and can consume beef in that particular district/Town. Local administrators(like collector/Mayor) can enforce those laws going by the demography. You don't need Finance ministers or Home ministers for this in each district.

It is not that simple.

Laws are made based on majority opinion without any discrimination. Now what is the basis to discriminate and make an exception for a city or district? It would be Muslim majority, correct. Now this would be be a slippery slope as each group would start asking to make an exception. Someone could ask for an exception at a neighborhood level or street level as @adil_minhas says that there are hardly any districts where Muslims are a majority.

Also, one should be careful what one wishes for. Tomorrow some Hindus groups would start asking for exceptions which are deemed sacred for Muslims.

When you implement a Law it have to be across the board with no discrimination.

If Cow slaughter is prohibited, it should be prohibited for all

If burning of Quran is prohibited, it should be prohibited for all

Center and State governments are matured levels of government branches. Districts, Cities are not.

 

[adil_minhas]

It is not that simple.

Laws are made based on majority opinion without any discrimination. Now what is the basis to discriminate and make an exception for a city or district? It would be Muslim majority, correct. Now this would be be a slippery slope as each group would start asking to make an exception. Someone could ask for an exception at a neighborhood level or street level as @adil_minhas says that there are hardly any districts where Muslims are a majority.

Also, one should be careful what one wishes for. Tomorrow some Hindus groups would start asking for exceptions which are deemed sacred for Muslims.

When you implement a Law it have to be across the board with no discrimination.

If Cow slaughter is prohibited, it should be prohibited for all

If burning of Quran is prohibited, it should be prohibited for all

Center and State governments are matured levels of government branches. Districts, Cities are not.

Do you know of any Hindu majority state or district where burning the Quran is legal.