Chinese PLA now intrude into Taksing zone in Arunachal Pradesh

[Tractor]

Yes,I agree with you,too.Communication promotes mutual understanding.
There is a brigadier-level meet at Kibithu on October 23.Wish we will solve the unpleasant border dispute problem some days or 1~2 years later.

So China already given up vast land which our own territory?That is really not a good massage.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Why we release? Bro. Ask the report of 1962 from Beijing, ask them to declassify it.

So how exactly do you expect us to believe these border clashes are our fault, if you can't prove it?

Just because you say so?

You can believe what you want. India is pushing and we are responding. Just like before.

 

[kaku1]

So how exactly do you expect us to believe these border clashes are our fault, if you can't prove it?

Just because you say so?

You can believe what you want. India is pushing and we are responding.

Facepalm. Bro, my simple statement is that, why you asking official 1962 govt. report from India, why not from CPC?

Did you have much more faith in India and not in your own govt.

 

[kyle Chiang]

So China already given up vast land which our own territory?That is really not a good massage.

Sinking into border conflicts doesn't fit our interest.And negotiation doesn't means giving up.

• 
  China's peaceful rise needs a good international atmosphere.
  
  And if China and India still fight against with each other,do you thin who benefit more?Of course,no India,no China.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Facepalm. Bro, my simple statement is that, why you asking official 1962 govt. report from India, why not from CPC?

Did you have much more faith in India and not in your own govt.

I'm not asking for any report. You have comprehension problems.

Why would I ask for the Henderson-Brooks report when it had already been freely leaked/released to the internet?

It's available for anyone to read.

 

[kaku1]

I'm not asking for any report. You have comprehension problems.

Why would I ask for the Henderson-Brooks report when it had already been freely leaked/released to the internet?

It's available for anyone to read.

@Chinese-Dragon I dont understand a thing, you want to prove your point with an Indian Govt. report. Amazing. I didnt find anywhere else in the world. BTW, why you asking Indian govt. report, are you an Indian citizen? What rights you have even asking for it?

Leave it, bro, I think you are Rahul Gandhi Part 2, I even dont want to go in 1962, you still want. And I think you create this 100 page thread, with your same rhetoric. So, leave it.

 

[Tractor]

Sinking into border conflicts doesn't fit our interest.And negotiation doesn't means giving up.

• 
  China's peaceful rise needs a good international atmosphere.
  
  And if China and India still fight against with each other,do you thin who benefit more?Of course,no India,no China.

No,do you think any other interests are much important than sovereignty which our very core interest asTwocents said?

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

@Chinese-Dragon I dont understand a thing, you want to prove your point with an Indian Govt. report. Amazing. I didnt find anywhere else in the world. BTW, why you asking Henderson-Brook report, are you an Indian citizen? What rights you have even asking for it?

Leave it, bro, I think you are Rahul Gandhi Part 2, I even dont want to go in 1962, you still want. And I think you create this 100 page thread, with your same rhetoric. So, leave it.

You still don't understand.

I am not asking for the Henderson-Brooks report.

Why would I ask for something that is freely available on the internet?

 

[Joeblow]

So China already given up vast land which our own territory?That is really not a good massage.

Define China for me. Do you mean People's Republic of China? or the Qing empire? Here's my stance. PRC never had these territories. It was already our territory before the PRC came into existence. The Qing empire did. So if the Qing empire is your definition of China then you have a claim over Mongolia along with Arunachal Pradesh/south Tibet. However, then you have to back off from ladakh because you signed a treaty of mutual non-aggression with the Sikh empire. Now if you're looking at it through the prism of history then there are 2 civilizations here. Chinese and Indian. Yours is north of the Himalayas and ours is south of it. AP or S. Tibet is south of the Himalayas. So what prespective do we take? What is the solution here?

 

[kaku1]

You still don't understand.

I am not asking for the Henderson-Brooks report.

Why would I ask for something that is freely available on the internet?

Ok, if you dont want that. Even why asking for other govt. reports?

Why not China going to UN, with there own assessment and reports? And still even why classified? Did CPC trying for some cover up.

Definetely, India did a cover up, just after 1962. But what were reason for China? If they were morally correct.

 

[Tractor]

Define China for me. Do you mean People's Republic of China? or the Qing empire? Here's my stance. PRC never had these territories. It was already our territory before the PRC came into existence. The Qing empire did. So if the Qing empire is your definition of China then you have a claim over Mongolia along with Arunachal Pradesh/south Tibet. However, then you have to back off from ladakh because you signed a treaty of mutual non-aggression with the Sikh empire. Now if you're looking at it through the prism of history then there are 2 civilizations here. Chinese and Indian. Yours is north of the Himalayas and ours is south of it. AP or S. Tibet is south of the Himalayas. So what prespective do we take? What is the solution here?

I only know AP is within our own territory since long and right now and of course you are free to consider our own maps as fake ones.

 

[Gandhiv]

In 1962 Chinese backstabbed and overwhelmed sparsely manned border posts of Indian army with their human wave tactic, thus taking higher causalities, but I am not sure how this will work in 2014 as now for Chinese public prize of war will be much higher when news 1000s of soldiers killed of one child era will start arriving to mainstream Chinese media.
There is no way now Chinese can occupy Arunachal as India knows Chinese chameleons’ every trick. The next war between India and China will be end of CCP rule and muscle power of its protector PLA.

 

[kyle Chiang]

No,do you think any other interests are much important than sovereignty which our very core interest asTwocents said?

You can seek "果敢" on Baidu.And you will learn much more about political games about "sovereignty".
All decision should made in the strategy level,not noly national emotion.That's what our 5000 years history has told us.

 

[Speeder 2]

2014, about 50 years after 1962, it's time for China to fix this bunch of completely shameless liars once again,

 

[Tshering22]

Ok, so what does that have with the PLA intruding into Indian territory 50 years later? And what is @kyle Chiang so upset about?

It simply means that the Congress and its supporters have been traitors to the country, leaving us militarily and economically so backward that they can actually think of doing this, all while a militarily tiny Philippines and a small but gutsy Vietnam ram their ships head on and chuck their belligerent forces out of their waters.

It means that we should be ashamed of this situation today where they actually have the courage to intrude, overlooking their president's orders.

If PLA is out of Xi's control, then we have a lot to worry as we will now have two hostile countries that are controlled by their militaries.