Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Why China Wants a G-3 World
i stop reading there. this is a failure beyond reasoning... China doesn't want ANY control group. because that would be to it's disadvantage. even the G20 is restrictive for China, China would prefer a world whereby there are many powers to which it can deal with each bilaterally: one-on-one, without a control group telling China what to and not to. It is to China's advantage to dilute political power, and the more player there is, the harder it is for US to dominate the discussion. Copenhagen was a good example whereby 100s of countries follow India and China's lead to walk out of the unfair treaty that would see the european have 3 times the quota of other countries. China's goal is not just to loosen the monopoly of power, it is to break it entirely.
right! China, if we deal with every country bilaterally, can win favorable arrangements against anyone through a smart combination of military, economic and political power.
When we deal in terms of blocs and alliances, we'll be no match for the US because the US has a bigger gang. For all the talk of how great and independent Europe is, 2 core nations, Germany and UK, are occupied by US troops.
...the more player there is, the harder it is for US to dominate the discussion. Copenhagen was a good example whereby 100s of countries follow India and China's lead to walk out of the unfair treaty that would see the european have 3 times the quota of other countries. China's goal is not just to loosen the monopoly of power, it is to break it entirely.
I don't think this is China's purpose. I agree with "akinkhoo" where he explained it was mainly a way to curtail American power, not as China's way to create it's own form of American-style domination. China has displayed a large degree of restraint in its international dealings, specifically in regards to less developed countries that it has the most leverage with. I have always been impressed by this generosity in light of atypical Anglo-American style hegemony vis-a-vis the relatively weak.right! China, if we deal with every country bilaterally, can win favorable arrangements against anyone through a smart combination of military, economic and political power....
It is to China's disadvantage to be the minority voice in any grouping of developed countries sharing the same ideologies and interests such as the hypothetical G-3 suggested by those writers. As somebody here wrote, China is not trying to loosen the existing monopoly of power, it is trying to break it entirely. Breaking it entirely means destroying the institutions that allow the perpetuation of that monopoly of power. China's interests mostly align with non-Western countries so it is to its advantage to perpetuate institutions such as the G-20 where the developed countries do not have a commanding voice as they would in a G-2 or G-3.Well we can all understand your point about China not wanting anybody to restrict her -- but it is conceivable that China, as the author points out, can use a G3 to her advantage and ensure that any restriction put on her by one is diffused by the other, and of course it may also be to China's advantage to see to it that it too can place restrictions on others who seek to do it to her, so to speak.
I don't think this is China's purpose. I agree with "akinkhoo" where he explained it was mainly a way to curtail American power, not as China's way to create it's own form of American-style domination. China has displayed a large degree of restraint in its international dealings, specifically in regards to less developed countries that it has the most leverage with. I have always been impressed by this generosity in light of atypical Anglo-American style hegemony vis-a-vis the relatively weak.