Chandrayaan-3 Mission Successfully Landed!!!

[Rank]

I would save my congratulations for the Indian people achieving sustainability and uplifting themselves from poverty and filth. I would not want Pakistan to invest in such a program.

I'd prefer our money be invested in birth control programs to save us. I don't believe this publicity stunt is in the benefit of the Indian people.

No offense.



And sustainability most importantly.

by doing and achieving this, India will get customers and int partnerships. That will create good amount of jobs and eventually generate $$$ for the country.

You cant finish or over come poverity esp size like country India. For govt, the most important thing is to create opportunities and jobs that will help to uplift middle and lower.

 

[ThunderCat]

by doing and achieving this, India will get customers and int partnerships. That will create good amount of jobs and eventually generate $$$ for the country.

You cant finish or over come poverity esp size like country India. For govt, the most important thing is to create opportunities and jobs that will help to uplift middle and lower.

Which is why India can never compared to China. It's like comparing Africa and Europe.

China achieved sustainability India is going the other way with poverty and misery only worsening. Artificially eliminating poverty by circulating money is not the answer.

Any economic fluctuation will have devastating consequences. Not to mention industrial waste/pollution.

Likewise for Pakistan. Gwadar and CPEC are not the answer. They will have bad ecological consequences and contribute further to destruction in our country.

You'd also need lots of resources to start a capital and circulate money. More exploitation more shortages. It is a doomsday in the making.

Beg to differ

While the mission itself might not look like yielding instant benefits economically, it serves in many ways to further interest in people of India to take up STEM subjects.

Secondly in mid to long-term it establishes India as a viable partner for anyone, who wants to take up Space based endeavors. Many nations are using services of ISRO now to launch their satellites.

On the mission itself, if the rover and lander manage to confirm existence of water in ice form and any other minerals that might exist on Moon, this mission will help in India and others take up more missions and lead to both scientific and commercial benefits for India.

Sometimes we have to take up missions, which will yield benefits at later date. Its like Planting a Tree now, so that the next generation can eat it.

Interestingly GOI actually reduced its funding to ISRO this year, as it had to allocate for other human endeavors. Sustainability like you said is desirable, but it cannot be achieved immediately. That's the hard truth

Not sustainable. All those suggested moon mining programs will also cost way more than this moon launch project. It's an investment into further loss.

Just because resources at home are running out, exploiting it from elsewhere is not the solution. Infinite growth cannot continue.

Just like CPEC, Gawadar etc. It's prolonging the problem of growth by circulating money and exploiting resources to get that money and to keep circulating it.

 

[ThunderCat]

.Finally, nowhere does it say that you have to eradicate 100% of poverty or have 100% of the population literate before you can build a rocket. This is not an RTS tech tree. You can chew gum and walk at the same time.

But eradicating 80% + poverty sounds like a good proposal considering the plight of India's population. Even much richer countries are not engaging in this sort of idiocy.

And yes eradicating poverty 100% should be a goal for any country. Let alone the poorest country on Earth.

 

[vikan]

Which is why India can never compared to China. It's like comparing Africa and Europe.

China achieved sustainability India is going the other way with poverty and misery only worsening. Artificially eliminating poverty by circulating money is not the answer.

Any economic fluctuation will have devastating consequences. Not to mention industrial waste/pollution.

Likewise for Pakistan. Gwadar and CPEC are not the answer. They will have bad ecological consequences and contribute further to destruction in our country.

You'd also need lots of resources to start a capital and circulate money. More exploitation more shortages. It is a doomsday in the making.



Not sustainable. All those suggested moon mining programs will also cost way more than this moon launch project. It's an investment into further loss.

Just because resources at home are running out, exploiting it from elsewhere is not the solution. Infinite growth cannot continue.

Just like CPEC, Gawadar etc. It's prolonging the problem of growth by circulating money and exploiting resources to get that money and to keep circulating it.

Wait, what? Your post makes absolutely zero sense, its all over the place and the wrong place. Generating an income source is wrong according to you? The point @Rank Is making is about creating jobs in India that will help Indians come out of poverty ir generally improve living conditions. Your post is going all over the place in directions i cannot understand. What are you trying to say here?

I dont want to comment on Gwadar, i hardly know anything about it, but isnt circulating the money the whole point of economic growth, if you hoard your money and it never enters the economy then whats the point of having that money. Are you even sure you have a point here?

But eradicating 80% + poverty sounds like a good proposal considering the plight of India's population. Even much richer countries are not engaging in this sort of idiocy.

And yes eradicating poverty 100% should be a goal for any country. Let alone the poorest country on Earth.

And since when has technological advace been the exclusive right of "rich" nations? We are supposed to just work on the basic mimimun tech and let other contries develop new tech and then we keep playing catchup to them? Do you simply post because you cant digest the fact India did accomplish something impressive? Like you are truly ignorant of the positive outcome this mission will have on the people in general? The thousands of kids and youth actully being inspired by the success of this mission means nothing? Dreaming for the future means nothing to you? You have never in your life looked at someones success and thought "i want to be successful one day, i will better my life, i will work for it"? Like ever?

 

[ThunderCat]

but isnt circulating the money the whole point of economic growth, if you hoard your money and it never enters the economy then whats the point of having that money. Are you even sure you have a point here?

Yes it is and it's not sustainable. Economic growth does not equal to improved living standards. Economic growth is not finite. It's not sustainable. It's not ecological.

Yes I am sure I have a point. Maybe that's why I made that post...

 

[vikan]

Yes it is and it's not sustainable. Economic growth does not equal to improved living standards. Economic growth is not finite. It's not sustainable. It's not ecological.

Yes I am sure I have a point. Maybe that's why I made that post...

Then pray tell us what is a sustainable way and what is it that India is doing worng?

 

[CallSignMaverick]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1694910034344595856

 

[RashidKhanTheLegend]

Then pray tell us what is a sustainable way and what is it that India is doing worng?

 

[vikan]

View attachment 948386

Not entirely sure why i even asked him to explain. I mean going by his last two posts in this thread nothing he wrote makes sense, it goes against logic and he hasnt given any reasonable explanation for his statements and i dont think he will be able to. I wont be holding my breath.

 

[Laser]

Next mission setup a gas station on Moon.
View attachment 948156

wahan electric gariyan chalainge.

View attachment 948386

Tumhari success pe khushi huwi hai. q k Asian mulk ne ye achievement hasil ki hai. balkay apnay hal pe pareshani hai. k ham kis taraf ja rahe hain.

 

[SoulSpokesman]

@ThunderCat


China achieved sustainability India is going the other way with poverty and misery only worsening.

China became a nuclear power and a space power before it eliminated poverty. Yes, India has a lot of poverty and misery, but it is not worsening.

Regards

 

[ThunderCat]

Then pray tell us what is a sustainable way and what is it that India is doing worng?

Not doing what China did, but rather doing the opposite. Right now you folks have more poverty in Africa and should be investing in sustainability.

You tried & failed. Pakistan tried & failed.
Pakistan's advantage is it hasn't reached India and Bangladesh's density- yet.

China became a nuclear power and a space power before it eliminated poverty. Yes, India has a lot of poverty and misery, but it is not worsening.

Regards

Strawman argument. The Chinese have become way less poor. Their poverty is incomparable to India's. They have much more sustainable infrastructure, much better healthcare, education, gender-equality.

India surpasses all of SS Africa in poverty. No comparison here. The Chinese find it offensive to be compared to such a country.

When even countries like Brazil, Japan, South Korea, France, United Kingdom, Nederlands, Nordic countries have not bothered with such projects, the world's poorest country is pulling off publicity stunts.

Will this distract people from the ground realities? I remember a UAE vlogger on YouTube saying "your people are more than 95% in poverty (exaggeration) and you're sending pizza boxes to the moon."

That is the common norm for foreigners to react to these publicity stunts.

 

[CallSignMaverick]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1694820392504840282

 

[CallSignMaverick]

 

[vikan]

Not doing what China did, but rather doing the opposite. Right now you folks have more poverty in Africa and should be investing in sustainability.

You tried & failed. Pakistan tried & failed.
Pakistan's advantage is it hasn't reached India and Bangladesh's density- yet.



Strawman argument. The Chinese have become way less poor. Their poverty is incomparable to India's. They have much more sustainable infrastructure, much better healthcare, education, gender-equality.

India surpasses all of SS Africa in poverty. No comparison here. The Chinese find it offensive to be compared to such a country.

When even countries like Brazil, Japan, South Korea, France, United Kingdom, Nederlands, Nordic countries have not bothered with such projects, the world's poorest country is pulling off publicity stunts.

Will this distract people from the ground realities? I remember a UAE vlogger on YouTube saying "your people are more than 95% in poverty (exaggeration) and you're sending pizza boxes to the moon."

That is the common norm for foreigners to react to these publicity stunts.

Not a single statement in your entire post details anything about what india is doing wrong or what india should be doing. Its just a rant about India this that.

And @SoulSpokesman has already drawn parallels to Indias situation now vs chinas situation a few decades ago but according to you its ok for China to have stuck with the path and not Ok for India. Sour grapes? And a UAE vlogger is now the final word on India's future road map? This vlogger is the representative of the whole world?