Chand dheaki k maslay per NASA ka jawab

[B.K.N]

So does travel on camels is sunnah.. Why u guys feeling shame to ride on camels???

Who feels shame in riding on camel they aren't the fastest or safest or comfortable source of traveling also there aren't a lot of camels to ride on

 

[The Accountant]

The method you are proposing does not involve sighting the moon but rather lunar calculations without physical moon sighting. Is that your argument?

The Sunnah method has been very clearly defined as

1) Physical Moonsighting or Witness testimony

2) completion of 30 days

The above are simple methods still valid today. So would you keep it simple or over complicate this with scientific calculations and what not?

Also note namaz timings are based upon solar timings whereas ramzan start is upon moon / lunar timings. You cant compare the two. Please read discussions on this thread, instead of me answering the same examples over and over again.

Also note , this has nothing to do with Mullahs. It is only for making Sunnah relevant. You can very well study the religion yourself. Stop making your hatred for Mullahs force you to stop following Sunnah.

The sunnah method of identifying sahar is when you are able to distinguish white thread with black ... why dont you sit with white and black thread every morning ?

Sunnah is relevant ... no one is stopping you from following the sunnah ... you should saw the moon but if somebody is lying in fornt of everyone and you know that he is lying then how can we still believe it ...

As i asked if someone become witness that sun is half passed and its zihar time at 2 am will you acceot that ?
Similarly if Allah gave us brain and we found out that moon cannot be visible before a particular date then how come we accept that testimony ?
Are we brain dead or Allah has asked us to not to rely on your wisdom even if someone is tellong lie on your face ?

I love my religion and religion is keep me asking again again to use my brain in following islam and dont be blind followers of ancestors or leaders ...

 

[313ghazi]

https://www.dawn.com/news/1486484/s...id-is-traditional-but-is-it-totally-redundant

 

[Riz]

Who feels shame in riding on camel they aren't the fastest or safest or comfortable source of traveling also there aren't a lot of camels to ride on

How many u needed to ride... I can provide u 4 camels af the cost of 1 mrhran.. and who told u camels are not comfortable??? Arabs call them dessert car... And why do u need to travel fast if our prophet PBUH use to ride on camels.. Its sunnah and u are bound to follow sunnah if u are not following or doesn't want to follow then why u guys need moon sighting instead of better & modern ways???

 

[B.K.N]

How many u needed to ride... I can provide u 4 camels af the cost of 1 mrhran.. and who told u camels are not comfortable??? Arabs call them dessert car... And why do u need to travel fast if our prophet PBUH use to ride on camels.. Its sunnah and u are bound to follow sunnah if u are not following or doesn't want to follow then why u guys need moon sighting instead of better & modern ways???

I know people ride camel for fun
But they are not comfortable for long travel
also they aren't safe male camels can even kill you
Prophet used to travel on camels because no other source of transportation was available

 

[Riz]

I know people ride camel for fun
But they are not comfortable for long travel
also they aren't safe male camels can even kill you
Prophet used to travel on camels because no other source of transportation was available

There was no other way available for moon sighting at that time.... Why every fake mulla want moon sighting and don't want to use plenty of options available right now

 

[B.K.N]

There was no other way available for moon sighting at that time.... Why every fake mulla want moon sighting and don't want to use plenty of options available right now

Only popalzai insists on sighting

 

[Riz]

Only popalzai insists on sighting

He is an idiot

 

[criticalerror]

The sunnah method of identifying sahar is when you are able to distinguish white thread with black ... why dont you sit with white and black thread every morning ?

Sunnah is relevant ... no one is stopping you from following the sunnah ... you should saw the moon but if somebody is lying in fornt of everyone and you know that he is lying then how can we still believe it ...

As i asked if someone become witness that sun is half passed and its zihar time at 2 am will you acceot that ?
Similarly if Allah gave us brain and we found out that moon cannot be visible before a particular date then how come we accept that testimony ?
Are we brain dead or Allah has asked us to not to rely on your wisdom even if someone is tellong lie on your face ?

I love my religion and religion is keep me asking again again to use my brain in following islam and dont be blind followers of ancestors or leaders ...

As i said, you are comparing apples and oranges. I sound like a broken record. I explained the Sunnah method of establishing Ramzan, which you conveniently disregarded.

You are abolishing the Sunnah of moon sighting in favour of lunar calculations. Seems like stopping to me.

Witness testimony is established and verified through proper methods. Otherwise every year there are scores of people purporting to be witnesses of the moon. I agree with your statement on not agreeing to someone saying they sighted the moon when it is scientifically impossible. Using the science as an aid is perfectly permissible.

Allah has given us a brain, not for refining our religion but to follow the religion through thick and thin.To use that brain to accommodate Sunnah in these modern times. Comparing following and refusal to leave Sunnah to being brain dead, is what is actually brain dead. I am a blind follower of Allah and His Prophet (PBUH) alone. I don’t follow any Mullah. I read the Hadeeth and came to my conclusions.

 

[criticalerror]

There was no other way available for moon sighting at that time.... Why every fake mulla want moon sighting and don't want to use plenty of options available right now

Our Prophet(PBUH) insists on moon sighting. Stop spewing nonsense about what you know not. Also note lunar calculations were available at the time of the Prophet (PBUH). Go through the thread .

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

No the simplest one would be to sight the moon. The scientific one requires calculations and what not.

How do you sight the moon with cloud cover/bad weather etc? Complications already added to your solution and way to much room for human error.

The scientific solution is the best and most credible one.

 

[Defense Reader]

2 mullaho main murgi haram

Imran sir idhr kam 3 pr pounch chuka hai

 

[Imran Khan]

Imran sir idhr kam 3 pr pounch chuka hai

jitny ziada hoon gay utna ziada udham machy ga .

 

[Defense Reader]

jitny ziada hoon gay utna ziada udham machy ga .

Much tu gya hai sir pehly Pakistan main 2 Eid hoti thin ab KPK main 2 or Pakistan main 3
28 rozon k sath

 

[Imran Khan]

Much tu gya hai sir pehly Pakistan main 2 Eid hoti thin ab KPK main 2 or Pakistan main 3
28 rozon k sath

good for gov more revenue hoga . mera khayal hai saal main 5-7 eids honi chayee