Can India’s nuclear doctrine survive clash with Pakistan?

[Hrk19]

Just advice us how many nuke india want to nuke only Punjab in Pakistan,Thats all we need.


Why till now China has not supported you in all wars including Kargil and Siachin.

it was not a world power until recently
recently for example they developed the capability to strike the us
anywho,they will bomb you especially if its to protect their investments

 

[SDS1]

You better talk with evidences or proves. Trolling is not the answer dude.

lol, check your News paper on 71 and your PTV recording ...lol their is ample of evidence....dude... read your country history first, real one..

 

[ravi gupta]

it was not a world power until recently
recently for example they developed the capability to strike the us
anywho,they will bomb you especially if its to protect their investments

Thank god,at least you get the point,that without papa China you cannot do anything.

Still disagree with your point since china has more investment and buisness in India,then in pakistan.
He would like to mediate between us to safeguards his investments in both countries,rather then entering in war from your side.

 

[Hrk19]

Thank god,at least you get the point,that without papa China you cannot do anything.

Still disagree with your point since china has more investment and buisness in India,then in pakistan.
He would like to mediate between us to safeguards his investments in both countries,rather then entering in war from your side.

yeah and no matter what you that point will be your downfall in case of war
so call it what you want,in the end,its still india with crippled limbs

 

[django]

For every nuke you fire we will fire three-four.

We have more than you.

 

[ShoutB]

We have more than you.

how do you know? When even PM of Pakistan would not really know the actual number. Rubbish"!

 

[django]

how do you know? When even PM of Pakistan would not really know the actual number. Rubbish"!

Assessments from many credible and reputable organisation seem to have Pak ahead.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

Just advice us how many nuke india want to nuke only Punjab in Pakistan,Thats all we need.

How old are you kiddo? Is that your idea of "massive retaliation" against Pakistan?

I hope your strategist are as dumb as you are, considering Pakistan nuke missile launching sites and bases are mostly outside Punjab. On a side note, speak to your Sikh community as well who form the majority of your forces as to what is their opinion about nuking Punjab.

 

[Armoured Division]

We have more than you.

Not according to Pakistani assessment:

Contrary to international estimates which give a watered down view, Pakistani assessment is that India has enough fissile material, both reactor- and weapon-grade plutonium, for more than 2,000 warheads.
A paper published by the International Institute of Strategic Studies this year noted: “New Delhi’s plutonium stocks also continue to pile up; according to one Pakistani assessment, by the end of 2013 India had produced enough weapons- and reactor-grade plutonium (0.8-1tn and 15tn respectively) for 2,000 warheads.”

http://www.dawn.com/news/1206051

 

[django]

Not according to Pakistani assessment:

http://www.dawn.com/news/1206051

Story probably a plant from some source at GHQ, every organisation wants extra funds.

 

[ravi gupta]

How old are you kiddo? Is that your idea of "massive retaliation" against Pakistan?

I hope your strategist are as dumb as you are, considering Pakistan nuke missile launching sites and bases are mostly outside Punjab. On a side note, speak to your Sikh community as well who form the majority of your forces as to what is their opinion about nuking Punjab.

getting personal means you are losing argument,Your majority 70% nuke installation and command centers are in punjab,rest will be also taken care off.Its your punjab in pakistan,LOL.

yeah and no matter what you that point will be your downfall in case of war
so call it what you want,in the end,its still india with crippled limbs

Yeah India mai be crippled but you may be no more at all ,there are no winners in nuke war.
Thats y its advisable to fight with conventional weapons.

 

[Omer iqbal Malik]

In all this discussion don't forget china ...coffee

 

[Armoured Division]

Story probably a plant from some source at GHQ, every organisation wants extra funds.

Using your logic IISS estimates could also be plants by west to make it easier for their industry to participate in India N-trade.

 

[django]

Using your logic IISS estimates could also be plants by west to make it easier for their industry to participate in India N-trade.

Bulletin of atomic scientists has scientists from all over the globe participating in their studies. Admit it your military is a big lumbering clumsy elephant.

g
Yeah India mai be crippled but you may be no more at all ,there are no winners in nuke war.
Thats y its advisable to fight with conventional weapons.

Hindia may be crippled LOL, it will become a radioactive dystopian wasteland dude, it will implode as a nation, It is so artificial the northern sates will all go their own way, their will be no command and control left, delhi , mumbia kolkata all gone, oppressed people will become free to breed mutants LOL

 

[ravi gupta]

Bulletin of atomic scientists has scientists from all over the globe participating in their studies. Admit it your military is a big lumbering clumsy elephant.


Hindia may be crippled LOL, it will become a radioactive dystopian wasteland dude, it will implode as a nation, It is so artificial the northern sates will all go their own way, their will be no command and control left, delhi , mumbia kolkata all gone, oppressed people will become free to breed mutants LOL

Actually you enter into discussion very late,question is how that is already discuss.
since its only PDF you can write whatever you are wish for and logic is nowhere be seen.